JOINED UP THINKING

Why do we have laws and rules that govern the way buildings look? asks David Winpenny, Co-Chairman of Ripon Civic Society.

What is the point of rules for how a building or a local area should look? Why does the government encourage local authorities to set up conservation areas? Why list buildings?

These are questions promoted by the letter in the Ripon Gazette (29 February) from Adrian Whitling of Littlethorpe, taking the Civic Society to task for championing terraces. He accuses us of wanting to ‘crush the poor terrace owner’ with a ‘vast dull instrument of prohibition and prejudice.’ What fun that might be! But the reality is different.

Mr Whitling makes the comparison between the Royal Crescent in Bath and some humble Ripon terraces. His point seems to be that because the small brick terraces of Ripon are not grand architecture, owners should have carte blanche to do whatever they wish to them, without reference to anyone else. This is an odd concept, and seems to imply that it’s OK for ‘the rich man in his castle’ to have to abide by rules that govern the look of his building, but that ‘the poor man at his gate’ can live in a hovel of his own creation.

Yet he later asks that ‘the tentacles of the Civic Society should retract and leave terrace owners to have the same rights of home improvement as owners of their detached dwelling members.’ Too many prejudices here to deal with, but there is an underlying truth to be reckoned with – should we regulate how our city looks, not for one particular section of the population but for the good of everyone?

This may bring us into wider questions about a ‘nanny state’, which is beyond the scope of both this column and of the Civic Society. Yet it remains a fact that our elected representatives, whether you like them or not, have over the years laid down rules that govern how we should regulate both new building and the existing building stock. They have seen fit to bring in different degrees of protection, from Scheduled Ancient Monuments, through Listed Buildings, to Local Conservation Areas. These are based not on class prejudice but on what is considered the best way of protecting the environment and its structures, and of preserving the look of a community.

Of course terraces consist of homes; that is their rasion d’etre. But Mr Whitling sees them as a collection of isolated units that happen to be joined together, rather than as a unity. To suggest that preserving the unity of a terrace is oppression is like saying that taking notice of traffic lights is an infringement of civil liberties. Without rules there is anarchy. The rules for the built environment look at the wider picture of what is good for the community rather than what is merely convenient for the individual – a principle upon which all our laws should be based. And that is why the Civic Society – whose members, detached, semi-detached and terraced, work for the good of the city – will continue to argue for moderation and common sense in dealing with all Ripon’s buildings.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.