David Winpenny, Co-Chairman of Ripon Civic Society, reflects on the talk by Dr Simon Thurley, Chief Executive of English Heritage for the 40th Anniversary of Ripon Civic Society.
When Simon Thurley spoke last Friday to mark Ripon Civic Society’s 40th Anniversary, the title of his talk was ‘Goodbye old England – does anyone out there care?’ and his theme was the way in which historic buildings were maintained and used.
He looked at different building types and underlined the problems faced by anyone who is trying to look after them or find new uses for them. There are the historically-important churches with tiny congregations which struggle to pay for the barest essentials, let alone meet the costs of major remedial work, even with the help of grants. There are Victorian schools that are solidly-built and of architectural merit but which are out of favour with modern educationists, who would rather throw up flimsy new short-life buildings than pay for proper repairs and modernisation. Farm buildings – like barns and cart sheds – that have outlived their original use yet are worthy of preservation; should they be converted into houses?
Industrial buildings, too, have their problems, when industry changes – Dr Thurley cited coal mines as an obvious example, but there are many others. And what about the seaside? The British invented the seaside holiday when railways gave them access to the coast, then abandoned it when cheap flights and package holidays offered them the escape to the sun. Then, of course, there are swimming pools – all over the country, not just in Ripon, people are fighting to save historic baths buildings that local authorities will not spend money on.
Much of this – not just the Spa Baths – strikes a chord in Ripon. We have redundant ecclesiastical buildings, especially the long-empty Chapel on Coltsgate Hill, crying out for a sustainable use. The former Cathedral Primary School – admittedly not of the same high quality as some of the Victorian Primary Schools in York or Leeds, but a collection of interesting buildings – has now formed the basis of a new housing development. We have problems with industrial buildings, especially the fine, Grade II-listed maltings on Ure Bank Top, which is shamefully being left to decay.
We have no seaside, but there is a lesson from some traditional resorts that are starting to reclaim the holidaymaker by building on their unique qualities and improving standards and facilities – for example the revamping of Scarborough’s Rotunda Museum and Morecambe’s Midland Hotel. They have seen how resorts like Southwold and Whitstable have always attracted ‘up-market’ visitors, and that this is part of the answer to their future prosperity. Ripon needs to follow their example by building on its uniqueness, too, rather than trying to ape larger towns around it; and it desperately needs more tourist accommodation.
Did Dr Thurley offer any solutions to these problems? Only in part. English Heritage cannot wave a magic wand over the country and bring all buildings back into economic use and fine fettle. The answer lies in local action. That is what the Save Our Spa group is doing at the present time – and what Ripon Civic Society has done for the last 40 years and will continue to do. We cannot wait for ‘them’ to do something. If we are among the people who do care about Old England – and New Ripon – we need to act together for the betterment of the city – and do it now.
