CELEBRATE PEVSNER – BUT BEWARE WORSHIPPING HIM

David Winpenny, Co-Chairman of Ripon Civic Society, celebrates the work of Sir Nikolaus Pevsner – but calls for care about how we use his opinions.

Hurrah for Pevsner! And three cheers for his ‘Buildings of England’ series, which from its first volume (Cornwall, published in 1951) to its last (Staffordshire, 1974) catalogued in huge detail all the significant architectural delights of the country, from the ramparts of Berwick-upon-Tweed to the lighthouse at Lizard Point.

It was a stupendous achievement, and no one with an interest in architecture can travel the country today without a Pevsner. And it’s always a ‘Pevsner’, not a ‘Buildings of England’; like Hoover and Biro, his name has become synonymous with his product. His industry was phenomenal, and everyone in the country should be immensely grateful that so much information is available so easily from such an accessible source.

For each ‘Pevsner’ the author – a German-born academic at Birkbeck College, University of London – would have a research assistant trawl though all the existing printed material about the county, from the august pages of the Victoria County History (if that work covered the area) to small local guidebooks, if they were accessible. This work, done in national and local libraries, was then made into notes by the researcher. With these notes Pevsner set off, always driven by someone, to tackle the subject. He did a whole county in around a month, in the university vacations. He would rush round a place, then retire to his hotel room and write his first draft. It was unrelenting: ‘The journeys are just not human,’ he wrote. ‘To bed 11.00, 11.30, too tired even to read the paper. Up this morning at 6 to scribble, scribble, scribble.’

His scribbling is a mixture of opinion and architectural fact. His adjectives can be instructive. The sentence in the ‘Yorkshire: West Riding’ volume that describes Ripon’s Spa Baths has three: ‘The SWIMMING BATHS, with a florid porte-cochère of 1905 by S Stead, in brick and yellow terracotta, lies opposite an attractive Georgian house . . .’ Edwardian is dismissed as florid – Georgian is praised as attractive. And this single sentence brings up another point; these descriptions need some architectural knowledge (what’s a porte-cochère?) to follow all his descriptions. Not everyone will understand phrases such as ‘Cinquepartite vaulting shafts standing right on the abaci of the piers’ – a random quotation from his description of Ripon Cathedral.

Pevsner’s method of working had other problems. His notes might not include everything of worth – there are numerous examples of quite significant buildings being missed in the first editions of Pevsner. Or he might just have not been tuned in to the style. He admired modernist buildings (see how many steel and glass schools and factories occupy the plates in the books) and, on the whole, was dismissive of Edwardian buildings – hence his curt dealing with the Spa Baths, or his description of the Royal Hall in Harrogate as having ‘funnily short columns’ – and no mention of the interior at all.

The artist John Piper used to say that Pevsner told you ‘everything you wanted to know about a place – except what it’s like.’ You can get all the technical information and the dates of each part of a building from the books, but rarely an impression of what it is actually like to be there. It is cataloguing of the highest order – each detail pinned like a butterfly in a cork display box; fascinating – but dead. John Betjeman, who won the hearts of the English where Pevsner only won their admiration, called him ‘Herr Professor-Doktor’, reference to the Teutonic thoroughness of his work.

To say, as did a letter in last week’s ‘Ripon Gazette’ that ‘without Pevsner there would be no listed building register or system in the UK, no English Heritage or building preservation movements . . .’ is very wide of the mark – The Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings was founded in 1877 by William Morris, for example. And it is not wise to elevate Pevsner to Holy Writ; ‘if it’s not in Pevsner it can’t be of interest’ is the same as suggesting that if a word isn’t in Johnson’s Dictionary it shouldn’t be used. And Pevsner himself said that it was not the first editions that were important, but the later updates that would be much more valuable.

We are promised a revised Pevsner volume – ‘Yorkshire: West Riding (North)’ – soon, which will cover Ripon. It will be interesting then to see how much the descriptions have expanded. Yet even if we feel that the city has complete coverage, it will not be like the unalterable law of the Medes and the Persians. Taste, views, ideas move on; so should how we view our buildings.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.