MAKING A DATE WITH BUILDINGS

‘Women and wine,’ wrote the playwright and poet Oliver Goldsmith in She Stoops to Conquer, ‘should never be dated.’ As an aphorism, it is hardly up there with some of Oscar Wilde’s, but it was considered worthy of inclusion in the Oxford Dictionary of Quotations – though it has been dropped from the latest edition.

But what about dating buildings? This is, of course, the stock-in-trade of architectural historians. The Buildings of England guides are full of dates – Pevsner was not content until, with his Teutonic thoroughness, he had pinned a date on and structure worthy of mention in his books.

How do you date a building? There are, of course, several ways. One is documentary evidence. If you can dig out the original architect’s drawings and see the date on them, you have hit gold. Even if they are not dated, it’s not too hard to pin down a building within the architect’s work – and it’s likely, anyway, that you would know, or be able easily to find, the dates he (usually he) was working. Or there may be building accounts, contemporary descriptions, drawings, engravings – even photographs. All these can point you to a date.

In the absence of these, what do you do? After some years of studying buildings, it’s actually quite straightforward to assign at least a tentative date to a building from its style. You can use the broad-brush approach – Medieval, Tudor, Georgian, Victorian are all fairly safe. Within those time slots it is possible to define different styles. For medieval architecture we have well-known categories – Norman, Early English, Decorated, Perpendicular – that were first categorised in Thomas Rickman’s 1817 publication An Attempt to discriminate the Styles of English Architecture from the Conquest to the Reformation. The terms he introduced were so useful they have been used ever since.

All this is fine for people with some knowledge of architectural history – but what about the ordinary passer-by, or the tourist, who wants some idea about a building’s date without having to mug up their reticulated tracery or their Palladian windows? That is, of course, when we have cause to be grateful to the builders who have thoughtfully added the date into the very fabric of a building.

So let us cheer the Board of Guardians of the Ripon Workhouse who boldly labelled their gatehouse ERECTED A.D. 1854. It’s in a no-nonsense font, and no messing about with fancy Roman numerals. It seems to say, ‘We are plain men, doing a good work for modern times’.

Five years later they were followed by the promoters of the Temperance Hall on Duck Hill, dating their building in attractive serifed lettering. And in 1863 the Gothic houses in High St Agnesgate had the date added, too – this time in, of course, curvy Gothic numbers displayed on a shield. Round the corner in Low St Agnesgate a wooden beam above an entrance archway has the date 1898 in an Arts-and-Crafts style. And by 1904 we were into the Art Nouveau, with the date stylishly displayed in the Spa Baths.

The Spa Baths building also has an inscribed stone noting its opening by HRH Princess Henry of Battenberg and Princess Ena, as well as a foundation stone – giving the dating of the building a belt-and-braces certainty. Foundation stones are usually reliable; the one on the former Girls’ High School building is particularly informative, giving not just the date of Saturday 30th May 1908, but also the names of the stone-layer, of the Town Clerk and of the architects, too.

All of these can obviously tell us the date of the building – but we need to be careful. Look, for example, at the date in the centre of the Old Deanery Hotel. There is a panel with the coat of arms of King George III and the date 1799. But this is not the date of most of the building; it was only altered then. The original building dates to more than 150 years earlier – as is apparent from its style.

Perhaps the most misleading date in Ripon is that on the obelisk in the Market Square. The plaque on it clearly says ‘MDCCLXXXI ERECTED AT THE EXPENSE OR WILLIAM AISLABIE ESQUIRE:’ 1781 was the year William Aislabie died, but it wasn’t he who had the obelisk put up – that happened in 1702, to Nicholas Hawksmoor’s design. It was only repaired in 1781. Many generations have been confused by the plaque, which was put up in 1785.

The unwary might also be confused by the prominent date of 1775 on the former Williamson Varnish Works building by Borrage Bridge. The date refers to the founding of the firm; the date of the building is to be found round the back on a terracotta plaque. It was put up in 1925.

Neither of these was intended to confuse passers-by – any more than the date of 1675 displayed in nail heads on the great west door of Ripon Cathedral. One suspects that this was a mark of pride in workmanship from the joiner – and one that was well-deserved, as his doors still do the job for which they were intended, as their recent opening showed.

And what of today? Only the most prestigious new buildings these days have official foundation stones. Otherwise, we rely on the whim of a designer or of a developer. There is, for example a 1993 date on the bridge over the Skell that links Barefoot Street to Williamson Drive. Houses on Princess Road have a cast stone date of 2005. There are a few others, but perhaps not many. So here’s a plea to planners and developers; please help future generations by showing pride in your buildings and putting a date, clearly and permanently, on them!

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.