David Winpenny looks at the implications of the government’s ideas for the ‘Big Society’
When Margaret Thatcher wrote (in Woman’s Own, October 1987) that ‘There is no such thing as society. There are individual men and women, and there are families’, she produced one of her more contentious thoughts. It provoked anger and puzzlement in equal measure, and there were, significantly, few people willing to back up her assertion.
Fast forward to 2010. Here’s another Conservative-led government. Is society again going to take a back seat? Are we once again to follow our individual paths (looking after number one, you may say), or is there a new ideology?
Enter ‘The Big Society’. It’s an idea, its proponents say, whose time has come (just as the Blairites praised the ‘Big Tent’). A concept that comes from the ‘progressive Conservative’ camp, the Big Society is, according to Liberal leader Nick Clegg, the Deputy Prime Minster, ‘nothing less than a huge cultural shift, where people, in their everyday lives, in their communities, in their homes, on their street, don’t always turn to answers from officialdom, from local authorities, from government, but . . . feel free and empowered to help themselves and help their communities.’
So what will this ‘cultural shift’ actually mean for us? How will we be changed, and how will things change around us? And how long will this transformation from reliance on outside agencies to communities helping themselves actually take?
There are some eye-catching headlines. There are to be elected mayors and police chiefs. Free schools, with government funding, will be encouraged. There’ll be a ‘Big Society Bank’, with money from unclaimed bank and building society accounts, which will give money to support charities and local enterprises. Young people will be encouraged (or possibly compelled – it’ not entirely clear) to take part in a National Citizens’ Service. There’ll be a ‘Big Society Day’ (order the bunting now) and 5,000 ‘community organisers’ will be trained to ‘facilitate’ local groups.
This is largely window-dressing, though. The most radical change will, apparently, be on two, closely-linked, fronts – the planning laws and the role of local authorities. The planning system is to be reformed so that local communities can protect and take over facilities and services. There are even moves to hand funding over to local communities to spend on projects they believe are for their local benefit.
This may be a painful transition, especially for local government, which has seen its role diminished over the last decades. Since the local government shakeup of 1974, the autonomy of local authorities has been eroded. Much of this was due to the centralising tendencies of Mrs Thatcher’s administration. And now her successor wants to take more powers away, this time to pass them in the opposite direction – down to local people.
At this point there may be loud cheers from many communities that feel ignored or slighted by the local authority under which they live. There are complaints from Ripon, for example, that Harrogate Borough Council ignores Ripon’s needs. There are similar complaints from Whitby about Scarborough Borough Council, and from Beverley about the unitary East Riding of Yorkshire Council. No doubt other examples are legion. Giving local people the major say in their own destiny would seem to be the answer.
But hang on. If local authorities are leaned on heavily by central government to take grass-roots ideas on planning and on other matters into account, what will that actually mean? To which local groups and organisations do they listen? And who arbitrates when the different voices of a local community clamour for different and opposing changes? Are parish councils considered the local voice or as part of local government?
These are all questions that need to be answered before we can embrace the Big Society. And there are others. Does Big Society envisage the setting up of new community groups that bring together community and voluntary organisations to work alongside local authority representatives, as is already happening with the Greater Ripon Improvement Partnership? If so, will such groups have more clout than, say, a group set up to protest against a motorway service station, a wind farm or an incinerator?
Disquiet has already been expressed about the possibility that Big Society initiatives may ride roughshod over already-established channels of communication and bypass organisations with years of experience. The Chairman of the Yorkshire and Humber Association of Civic Societies, which brings together around 40 local amenity societies, has recently written to the Prime Minister pointing out that organisations such as civic societies are already doing many of the things promulgated under the Big Society banner. ‘There is no need, in our view,’ he says, ‘to create the ‘Big Society’; it is already here. It just needs a helping hand and, sometimes a sympathetic ear. We should be most concerned if initiatives were started that duplicated things that are already happening and detracted attention and scarce resources from organisations and initiatives that already exist.’
So we watch and wait. There is certainly a feeling in the country that change is needed, but is the Big Society the answer? It has been suggested that it will take a generation before we know. Much will depend on how much it is embraced not by those of us who are already entrenched in society, but by the young people who follow us. It will also depend on whether – or more likely when – political ideology changes again, and another Big Idea takes its place. Maybe we should start planning now for the Big Shift . . .
