Do you live in an old house? And is your old house a cold house?
In the winter, we like to think of our houses as being places where we can be warm and cosy, where we can shut out the winter blasts and perhaps enjoy a blazing fire. And as we approach Christmas, we are all the more conscious that the warmth of our homes is important as we welcome guests.
Now it may be that we have too romantic a notion of such cosy ideas. Does this image of winter days and festive domesticity date back, perhaps, to a Victorian fantasy chronicled in the pages of Dickens ’A Christmas Carol’ and ‘The Pickwick Papers’? Do we need to blame Sir Henry Cole, founder of the Victoria and Albert Museum, who in 1843 was the inventor and sender of the first Christmas card? It was illustrated by artist John Callcott Horsley with a picture of a happy family group celebrating together. Or do we go back to the Middle Ages, when aristocratic households kept open house at Christmas and where manor houses like Markenfield Hall were places of festivity and frolic?
Wherever the notion came from, we know that in winter our homes need to be warm and weather-tight. Successive governments have recognised that through, among other things, the payment of a Winter Fuel Allowance to people aged 60 and over – a welcome help, even if it does have overtones of Good King Wenceslas. But what if you live in an old house? Is it inevitable that your heating bills will be higher because of the more traditional way the house is built?
For the first time research has been done into this question on real houses, rather than in a laboratory. It was undertaken for the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings (SPAB), and the results, though rather technical, make interesting reading. In essence, the research, carried out by experts from SPAB and the universities of Glasgow and Portsmouth, looked at how much heat flows out of a building through its walls. Such heat transmission is measured in what are known as U-values.
The researchers set up their monitoring equipment on old walls of many kinds. They included granite walls, limestone walls and sandstone walls, as well as walls made of mud, straw, slate and brick and of timber with wattle-and-daub infilling. They measured how much heat the walls conducted over a period of time.
Now, you might expect that an old wall might lose more heat than a modern wall constructed with the latest techniques and stuffed full of high-tech insulation. In fact, the research found that this wasn’t necessarily true. The worst U-value was for a single-thickness brick wall that was part of the infill of a timber building – which hardly seems surprising. On the other hand, there were some excellent U-value readings for some potentially unlikely building materials, including straw and clay and light earth constructions. Stone buildings – especially limestone – gave good readings too, whether of rubble construction or of dressed blocks of stone.
The outcome of the research shows that historic buildings do have significant heat insulation properties. Of course, like any building, much of an old building’s thermal efficiency will depend also on other factors. These can include building’s location (hilltops may be self-evidently be colder than sheltered valleys), its design, the height of its ceilings, the way it is used and the way its services are configured.
And then there’s the thorny question of windows. Other SPAB research has demonstrated conclusively that a properly constructed and maintained wooden window can be as thermally-efficient as a uPVC replacement; original windows need not be drafty and should not be replaced with plastic ones in older buildings – as is done too much, in Ripon as well as elsewhere.
Our ancestors had their own techniques for making their homes warm and attractive. In medieval castles they lit great fires and hung up tapestries to retain the heat. When in Tudor times coal began to be burned instead of wood, they lined their walls with wooden panelling, less likely to be damaged by the blackening smoke. They imported screens to shield them from drafts, and, in Victorian times, invented ingenious heating systems to warm their rooms.
Today we have central heating and insulation. But we should not think that just because a house is old it will inevitably be a cold house. As long as it is well-maintained and carefully looked after, it will not need high-tech intervention to keep the heat in. So, whatever the age of your house, you should be able to look forward to a cosy Christmas. Mr Pickwick would no doubt be pleased!
