Next week an exhibition about how Ripon Cathedral was restored by the eminent Victorian architect Sir Gilbert Scott opens – appropriately in the cathedral itself. The story of the restoration shows off Victorian society at its confident best – and perhaps has more than a few resonances for today.
Great buildings like the Cathedral – or the Minster as it was known until it became the seat of the newly-created Bishop of Ripon in 1836 – have always needed maintenance and repair. For the last century we’ve used the phrase ‘like painting the Forth Bridge’ to mean a never-ending task. Before the bridge was opened in 1890, there must have been other, similar phrases. One might have been ‘like maintaining the Minster’ – for there should always have been a campaign to do it.
How much work was actually undertaken is a bit of a mystery. When the central spire of the Minster fell down in 1660, there were, of course, repairs undertaken, but thereafter there seems to have been minimal maintenance. The 18th century in particular was, for the most part, not well known for the care it took of its cathedrals. If repairs were decided on at all – and often they were not – they were often of a rather drastic variety. In part this was again because of architectural fashion, a subject of this column a fortnight ago.
For architects like Nicholas Hawksmoor, who designed the obelisk in Ripon’s Market Square, or Sir Christopher Wren, Gothic architecture was old-fashioned and crude – a style that could be used to pretty effect but didn’t really deserve serious study or use. Within 50 years of Wren’s death in 1723, though, there were people taking Gothic architecture seriously. At least, they were studying it seriously; the buildings they began to construct were still in a rather flimsy-looking Gothic style, as if cut from cardboard rather than stone.
One of the architects who used Gothic was James Wyatt, designer (in the classical style, of course) of Ripon’s Town Hall. He built a gargantuan house in the Gothic style, Fonthill Abbey in Wiltshire, for the eccentric William Beckford. Unfortunately he omitted the foundations, so it fell down. Nevertheless, he became the favourite cathedral restorer at the end of the 18th century. His work was extremely heavy-handed. A classicist at heart, he liked symmetry and uniformity, so he ‘tidied up’ the cathedrals in his care, demolishing awkward chapels, removing spires, building new west fronts. At Salisbury he was accused of ‘barbarous invention’.
At Durham he demolished most of the Norman chapter house, replacing it with what a contemporary described as having ‘sash windows, stuccoed walls with a neat cornice, marble chimney pieces, and curtains . . . and mahogany chairs with horsehair seats’. How nice for the Dean and Chapter to have modern accommodation – but what a loss of historic fabric! As the great 19th century Gothic architect Pugin wrote of a visit to Hereford, ‘I rushed to the cathedral; but horror! dismay! The villain Wyatt had been there, the west front was his. Need I say more? No! All that is vile, cunning and rascally is included in the term Wyatt.’
Wyatt did not get his hands on Ripon Minster, and when the Dean and Chapter woke to the fact that perhaps something was needed in the way of repair, it was in the 1820s. Taste and ability had moved on a little, and they felt safe in entrusting the work to Edward Blore. He was really a domestic architect – large parts of Buckingham Palace are by him – but, as he sometimes built houses in the Gothic style, he was thought to be the right man for ecclesiastical work, too. As well as Ripon he restored Peterborough Cathedral and Westminster Abbey.
His main job at Ripon was to make the building watertight – which itself says much about the level of maintenance. He lowered the pitches of the roof and gave the nave a new, flat wooden ceiling. And it was probably Blore who gave the choir (the cathedral’s eastern arm) and the transepts ceilings of plaster and papier-mâché.
By 1862, when Scott’s restoration began, tastes had changed again. Scott was on a mission – a crusade, even – for true Gothic architecture. Like his inspiration, Pugin, he had no time for what he saw as fake, gimcrack work like Blore’s plaster roofs. He wanted purity – and if it wasn’t there, he created it (or, as he would argue, re-created it, from evidence he found there.
So, for example, at Ripon he built new stone vaults over the aisle of the nave, based on good evidence that they had been originally intended but never constructed. He provided new vaults for the choir and nave, too. Above all, he saved the three towers from collapse by providing new foundations and holding the stonework together with metal bracing. One of his most startling interventions is a great iron beam in the central tower, deliberately exposed as part of his work.
It is indisputable that Scott saved Ripon Cathedral from serious collapse – a fate not unknown (the central tower at Chichester Cathedral collapsed in 1861, just as Scott’s work at Ripon was about the start). And, on the whole, his work here was sensitive and well-judged. It was certainly appreciated by the people of Ripon and the diocese who, after the usual appeals and re-appeals, provided the funds – around £40,000 for the work.
Scott has been out of fashion for much of the last century, but we are now coming to realise that, self-opinionated and rather too sure of his infallibility as he was, he was still a fine architect and, often, a sensitive restorer. It’s good for Ripon to remember him in his bicentenary year.
