MORE TREES, PLEASE!

Trees are in the news. A great groundswell of public opinion has arisen in opposition to the government’s proposals to find new ways of dealing with the woodlands currently owned and operated by the Forestry Commission.

Driven by the government’s stated desire to change organisation from the centre to ownership by the ‘Big Society’ (and, as a subtext, to save money) the plan is that the Commission’s 258,000 hectares of land – that’s nearly 700,000 acres or two per cent of the country’s land area – moves into other ownership or management. There is no preferred model of ownership; the consultation from the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) suggests ‘a mixed-model approach’.

This in reality means they want ‘new or existing charitable organisations to take on ownership or management of the heritage forests to secure their public benefits for the long-term future’ and that there will be ‘opportunities for community and civil society groups to buy or lease forests that they wish to own or manage’. Both these approaches will be limited to the smaller woodlands. For the larger, commercial forests, DEFRA envisages ‘finding commercial operators to take on long-term leases for the large-scale commercially valuable forests.’

What has been particularly exercising many people is the prospect that such a shedding of control over so much of our forest and woodland will lead to restricted access to vast tracts of land that is currently accessible to the public, or will open the sites up to unsuitable development.

There are concerns about lack of consultation before the plans went public; the National Trust, which would seem to be exactly one of the bodies the government should have got on-side before going public, is now highly critical of the move.

The Woodland Trust, another obvious candidate to take over some of the woodland, is also miffed. It says, ‘While we fully support the concept of community ownership, we don’t believe that the charitable sector can be the solution to future care of all of the publicly-owned heritage woodlands, as it will not have the resources to manage these for decades into the future without substantial and sustained government funding. We don’t believe the government has properly considered the feasibility of this option.’ It is also concerned that there is neither commitment nor guarantee in the proposals that will see the restoration of damaged ancient woods that are currently in public ownership.

DEFRA’s argument is that there will be guarantees to make sure that public access to woodland is continued; it says that ‘by leasing rather than selling, it will be possible to make sure that these forests continue to deliver public benefits through lease conditions’. This will require some fine balancing if prospective lessees are not to be put off by too-stringent a list of conditions, and if the public is to be satisfied that the level of access is what they think is desirable.

Concurrent with the hoo-ha about selling forests, the government has, with seemingly less fanfare, backed a scheme to plant trees in urban areas. Launched in December, the ‘Big Tree Plant’ (something else that’s labelled ‘Big’; will someone buy the government a thesaurus?) will over the next four years try to reverse the decline in the number of trees being planted in towns and cities. The scheme is backed with £4.2 million from DEFRA and is supported by groups including the Forestry Commission, The Woodland Trust, the Tree Council, Trees for Cities and Keep Britain Tidy.

Civic Voice, the national charity for the civic movement in England, of which Ripon Civic Society is a member, has welcomed the Big Tree Plant. Its president, Griff Rhys Jones, says it is ‘a great way for people to get together with their neighbours, civic society and local community groups to plant and care for more trees and improve the local environment for everyone. Plant a tree, change the future and the future will thank you for it.’

Over the last few decades Ripon has lost quite a lot of its roadside trees. Walk along the main approach roads into the city – Boroughbridge Road, North Road, Palace Road, Harrogate Road, Studley Road, Mallorie Park Drive, to name but a few – and you will soon spot the places where trees have been removed and not replaced.

Highways engineers don’t really like trees. Trees have so many disadvantages. They have roots that will insist on spreading under the carriageway. They have branches that might fall in high winds. Most have those dreadful things called leaves, which are shed in the autumn. So much better if we can avoid trees altogether, and if we can remove the ones that are there, all the better, seems to be the thinking.

These may be good arguments if you have a narrow, mechanistic perspective. But for most of us, trees are beautiful and life-enhancing. We love to see trees bordering roads; they soften the urban landscape and connect us a little to nature. And these days it’s possible to plant trees in special pits that restrict their root-spread so that the humps and bumps under the surface are avoided.

Ripon Civic Society is looking at the feasibility of planting more trees on the city’s approaches. Trees are vital both to life and to our wellbeing. That is why there is so much fuss about the proposed disposal of forests, and why there is so much support for the Big Tree Plant. More trees, please!

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.