KEEPING THINGS TOGETHER

Division is good for the plots of stories. There would be no ‘Romeo and Juliet’ if Shakespeare had decided that the Montagues and the Capulets has been cosy next door neighbours, sharing holidays on the Venetian Lido. What if Mr McGregor in Beatrix Potter’s Peter Rabbit books had been a man who liked nothing better than seeing small animals eating his lettuces? Or if Lord Voldemort had been a cuddly children’s conjuror instead of Harry Potter’s arch-enemy? And how would Dickens’s story have developed if the Master of the Workhouse had said, ‘Of course, my boy! How much would you like?’ when Oliver Twist asked for more?

But what’s good for fiction isn’t necessarily good in reality – as every news bulletin reminds us. Unity is something that we should welcome. Think, for example, of Berlin between 1945 and 1990. Under the terms of the London Protocol of 1944 it was divided into four – one for the Russians and one each for the United States, France and the United Kingdom. For all sorts of reasons that division was not in the best interest of Germany, and the re-unification of the country, which saw the city of Berlin once more come together (though not without problems caused by the long split), was welcomed almost universally.

One particular symbol of the division of Berlin was, of course, the Berlin Wall, which was started in 1961 and lasted until the dramatic scenes of November 1989 when it was attacked as a symbol of all that was bad about division. One particular focus was the Brandenburg Gate, sited at the start of the avenue called Unter den Linden and built at the end of the 18th century by the architect Carl Gotthard von Langhans. The blocked gateway became a symbol of disunity, and it was one of the first buildings to be restored when Berlin was again one city.

Walls have long been a symbol of division, even in the United Kingdom. We have only to think of Hadrian’s Wall or, today, the 18-foot-high ‘Peace Line’ wall that separates Catholics and Protestants in Belfast. And in medieval Norfolk, the monks of Wymondham Priory (later Abbey) fell out so badly with the townspeople that they built a wall right across the middle of the church and had a tower each, complete with competing sets of bells.

The English have always taken a pragmatic view about the division of estates. The principle of primogeniture – in which the eldest-born son (or at least the oldest-surviving male heir) takes the whole of an estate – has its problems, not least when the eldest child is female. But it has kept estates together in a way that has not happened in other countries – think of the multiplicity of small farms in some European countries, each the result of division among several heirs on the death of the landowner. Or consider the many Ruritanian states that littered Germany until its unification – and even afterwards – which provided so many wives to English monarchs (and a husband, Albrecht von Saxe-Coburg und Gotha, for Queen Victoria).

Architecturally and historically, it is always preferable to keep groups of related buildings in one ownership, or at least under one control, especially if they were constructed in one building campaign with one distinct function. History is littered with examples of groups of buildings being in divided control and important historical links being lost – by alienation if not by demolition.

A current case in London highlights the problem. In Cleveland Street in the part of central London called Fitzrovia is a former workhouse. Built in 1775 as Covent Garden Workhouse, it has been many things in its time, its workhouse function gradually transforming into use as part of the Middlesex Hospital. Now University College London Hospitals NHS Trust wants to demolish it to build houses and flats. It’s a complicated story; some campaigners say they want affordable housing on the site instead of the commercial flats and shops planned; others object to the loss of the historic fabric and want the building listed to prevent demolition. There’s an additional twist – in fact an Oliver Twist – for it is believed that Dickens, who lived in the same street for five years, based his workhouse in the novel on the Cleveland Street workhouse.

Ripon, too, has a Workhouse. Unlike Cleveland Street’s example, ours is a listed building, so is, to some degree, protected from demolition and alteration. Yet it, too, is vulnerable. The site is in the ownership of North Yorkshire County Council. Some of the buildings form the Workhouse Museum, one of Ripon’s best assets for encouraging visitors. Part serves a valuable role as Community House. And now there may be a suggestion that the main block – the large building behind the gatehouse that fronts Allhallowgate – may no longer be required for council use.

What should be done with it? Ideally the integrity of the site should be preserved – and perhaps the best way to do that would be to have the building – which was the heart of the Workhouse – taken over by the Museum Trust. It would offer the Trust space to expand (and perhaps some income from leased space) and would give this important museum the chance to tell the story of the workhouse movement more fully in the place it happened. As the Cleveland Street saga shows, intact workhouses are largely disregarded. Ripon should set an example by showing that it values the totality of this miraculously-surviving part of its history.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.