Are you ready to take over planning for Ripon? No? Well, perhaps you should be. In the next few months a generous government is going to give you the responsibility for helping to decide planning matters locally.
You no doubt have two questions in your mind: why and how? For the why, you need to turn to the preamble to the Localism Bill, which is currently going through parliament and will give effect to a wonderful new world in which we all own and approve of everything that happens in our own locality.
The aim of the bill, writes the man responsible for steering it though the legislative process, is ‘to return power to the people to whom it belongs’. Few would disagree with Greg Clark, the Secretary of State for Decentralisation, that such an outcome should be generally welcomed. And the Deputy Prime Minster, Nick Clegg, has also underlined its importance to the government, writing that ‘Radical decentralisation means stripping away much of the top-down bureaucracy that previous governments have put in the way of frontline public services and civil society. It means giving local people the powers and funding to deliver what they want for their communities – with a particular determination to help those who need it most.’
This is all ‘motherhood and apple pie’ language, of course. It’s easy to agree that the heavy hand of government should be removed from local decisions. But what does it mean in practice – in other words, how will it work?
The ‘Essential Guide to Decentralisation and the Localism Bill’ gives us six vital actions to achieve the promised land in which no one objects to planning decisions because everyone has a part in them. They include commitments to:
• Lift the burden of bureaucracy by removing the cost and control of unnecessary red tape and regulation, whose effect is to restrict local action
• Empower communities to do things their way by creating rights for people to get involved with their communities and to direct their development
• Open up government to public scrutiny by releasing government information into the public domain, so that people can know how their money is spent, how it is used and to what effect
• Strengthen accountability to local people by giving every citizen the power to change the services provided to them through participation, choice or the ballot box
Underpinning all this will be a new power for local people to develop what is known as a ‘Neighbourhood Plan’, which will ‘give local people new rights to shape the development of the communities in which they live.’
The proposal is that this power will allow local groups to come together in towns and villages to decide, for example, where new houses should go. The bill envisages that in those areas where there are parish councils (as in the city of Ripon) the neighbourhood plan should be formulated in a cooperative way between the council and local people. Everyone will have the chance to influence the new Neighbourhood Plan, not just elected representatives. And when the Neighbourhood Plan is finalised, it will be put to a local referendum – so be prepared to cast your vote!
Once the Neighbourhood Plan has been agreed by voters it then goes to the Local Authority (in Ripon’s case to Harrogate Borough Council) who will have to use the Plan’s polices in setting its own. Or will it? Not if the Neighbourhood Plan conflicts with the council’s Local Development Framework or with national or international laws and regulations. In other words, ‘You can agree to do whatever you like, as long as we approve.’
Of course, developing your Neighbourhood Plan will depend on many factors, not least the time, ability and willingness of local people to engage in what could be a long and possible bruising set of negotiations to find a way through the tangle of conflicting opinions and come out with an agreed plan. It also, of course, depends on the willingness of elected representatives to listen to the views of their constituents.
If these changes are to work, local communities are going to need help. That help will need to include the provision of expert help – either practical, on-the-ground help or at the very least detailed examples and guidance – so they can make decisions based on fact rather than on prejudice. There need to be checks and safeguards to make sure that a vocal minority does not override the wishes of a majority.
Above all, perhaps, there needs to be a massive effort to overcome the scepticism with which the changes will inevitably be met. Some will say this is a way to take the blame for planning decisions that local people don’t like away from government and on to ‘the people’. How nice for them to say ‘You have only yourselves to blame’ when things go wrong!
The changes in the bill will inevitably put yet more pressure on volunteers – like members of the Civic Society – who already spend time and effort attempting to improve their local areas. The Minister has said that the government has set aside £3 million for national organisations to work with neighbourhoods to develop their plans – which seems an infinitesimally small amount when spread across the thousands of parishes and other groups (there are more than 620 parish councils in North Yorkshire alone).
It would be excellent to think that the plan will work – and that everyone should feel that they have a say in the outcome. We need to work hard to make sure that it does. But perhaps we should also ask the awkward question – ‘What happens if it fails?’
