‘Wider still and wider shall thy bounds be set . . .’
After a time of patriotic flag waving for the Royal Wedding, it seems appropriate to see what Prince William’s father can teach Ripon, through his planned village of Poundbury on the outskirts of Dorchester in Dorset.
Of course, the Prince of Wales is no stranger to Ripon – his vision for the city, which among other plans would see a traffic-free link from the Market Square to the Cathedral, has mostly yet to be realised. Behind the royal plan was architect and urban planner Leon Krier, a Belgian architect who studied first in Stuttgart and then in the offices of the British architect James Stirling. He has taught at the Architectural Association and at the Royal College of Art, as well as in the USA at Yale and Princeton and at the University of Virginia. He now lives in the South of France.
His importance in Britain is that his ideas have been championed by the Prince. In his book ‘A Vision of Britain, HRH sets out his Krier-informed ideas – ideas that are also promulgated by The Prince’s Foundation for the Built Environment. The Foundation teaches, says the Prince of Wales’ own website, ‘by demonstration and through strategic partnerships that the timeless principles of traditional urban design are key to creating healthy and prosperous communities in a way compatible with people’s needs and aspirations for their homes, streets and neighbourhoods.’
Excellent – these are sentiments with which it is difficult to argue, and is full of lovely, ‘soft’ words – timeless, traditional, healthy, prosperous . . . who could object? No one, probably – while it stays as a vision. It is when it becomes the reality of bricks and mortar that doubts begin to creep in.
Why is this of interest to Ripon? Because it seems inevitable – and probably desirable – that the city should expend over the next decade or so to a size of 20,000 or more, in order to sustain the necessary infrastructure and economic well-being that the city really cries out for. Ripon is a similar size to Dorchester – between 16,000 and 17,000 people. It has similar architecture and streets (though not a cathedral nor anything as glorious as Ripon’s Market Square). It is, though, the headquarters of its local district council, which helps both employment and the town’s economy.
Adjacent to Dorchester is land owned by the Duchy of Cornwall, so when Dorchester was looking to expand, the Duchy farms immediately to the west of the town provided an ideal spot – both for the new houses and for the Prince of Wales to try out his experiment in social engineering.
Krier’s masterplan of the new Poundbury settlement (variously described as a village or a town, but never as a suburb), was first exhibited in 1989 and covers 400 acres. Of these, 150 are landscaping and the rest are buildings – residential, community and employment. The housing is an integrated mixture of owner-occupancy and social housing. Efforts have been made to provide work for the people of Poundbury – though how far a muesli factory and a chocolatier can offer large-scale employment remains to be seen.
The plan is split into phases. The first phase is now more than fifteen years old and is starting to look well-settled. Phase 2 looks, and is, newer, while Phase 3 is still under construction. What is worrying is the look of the phases. Phase 1 is clustered around a village hall – the Brownsword Hall – that bears a close family resemblance to the Market Hall in Tetbury, on the doorstep of Prince Charles’ Highgrove estate.
The houses around the hall are said to be in the ‘traditional’ style. What that means is that they are copies – pastiches – of Georgian buildings. If the original building that you are copying (or ‘interpreting’) dates from between 1760 and 1820, that’s fine. Anything else is not permitted. So it’s all sash windows, columns, the odd curly gable and one (just one) fanciful Gothick house that’s painted pink as if to nudge you in the ribs and say ‘Look how naughty I am!’
This gives the whole place an odd feeling; it’s pretty – but it’s dead. It’s like Clough Williams Ellis’s Portmeirion in North Wales, but without the fun. But worse follows. The transition into Phase 2 suggests a change of scale, from the cosy domestic of a village to the grander ideas of, say, a county town. And in Phase 3 the scale shifts to the vastness of an Italian Campo (‘Queen Mother Square’ full of inflated buildings and vast open spaces, bigger than Ripon’s Market Square). And though this is ‘traditional’ building, the construction methods are entirely modern. The buildings may look right, but it’s all faked – no traditional brick-built double walls here.
Poundbury seems to have started well, but it has grown too vast and too grandiose for its own good. It is in danger of distorting Dorchester, like a goitre. When Phase 4 is finished Poundbury will have 5000 people, with its own supermarket (Waitrose) and shops, its own community facilities and probably its own identity, separate from its mother settlement in Dorchester, which may then suffer as a consequence.
So what are the lessons of Poundbury that Ripon should take on board? First, that it’s probably not a good idea to build all your new houses on a single large site, even if you don’t have the Prince of Wales dictating the look of the place. Second, try to avoid the simplistic route of copying existing buildings, but strike out in a modern form. Third, don’t let the new settlement overshadow the old. Above all, the Poundbury lesson is that looks are not always everything – a place needs vitality, too. And that can’t be done just with a masterplan and some facades.
