Who said this?
‘All over the country the grime, muddle and decay of our Victorian heritage is being replaced and the quality of urban life uplifted.’
Was it (a) Stanley Baldwin in 1927; (b) Harold Wilson in 1967; or (c) Margaret Thatcher in 1987?
No prizes – and here’s the answer; it was Wilson. The year of the speech that included his remarks was one of the lowest points in our appreciation of Victorian architecture, despite the best endeavours of The Victorian Society (founded in 1958), John Betjeman and Nikolaus Pevsner, among others. So ridiculed were things Victorian in those days that Pevsner was once obliged to halt in a lecture on 19th century architecture to point out to the giggling audience that it was not meant to be funny.
If students thought that serious discussion of Victorian architecture was amusing, many of their elders thought that the buildings were irredeemably ugly. The epitome of ugliness was, for them, George Gilbert Scott’s Midland Hotel at St Pancras. Even the great and the good of the Royal Fine Art Commission, which promoted good design, followed fashion and hated it. It came very close to demolition; only Betjeman’s tenacity and persuasion saved it to become the glory that it is today.
In the year of Wilson’s speech St Pancras was given its reprieve and a Grade 1 listing. In the same year, too, another landmark building, or collection of buildings, was created. This was London’s Barbican centre, full of tower blocks and walkways – the ‘white heat’ of modern architecture – and much admired at the time. In 2003, though, it was voted ‘London’s Worst Building’.
Last year, another vote, for the worst buildings in Britain, again included the Barbican Centre, along with Birmingham’s new Bull Ring Centre, the Scottish Parliament Building in Edinburgh, the Millennium Dome (now The O2 Arena) and the Mall façade of Buckingham Palace.
It will be interesting to see if any of these reverse their rating over the next few years. For, certainly, taste in what is ugly will change, and what we now see as good and modern may fall from favour, while those we now reject be seen as important and, possibly, beautiful.
In 1908, when the Royal Commission on Historical Monuments (RCHM) was founded, even Georgian architecture was considered irredeemably modern and ugly. Its remit was to record monuments (including architecture) from the earliest times until – wait for it – 1700! A few years later it extended its scope, to take in another 14 years, ending with the death of Queen Anne. This was seen as perfectly rational, but it led to some odd things – even in the 1930s it told us that Syon House, one of the masterpieces of Robert Adam and a work of international importance, was ‘a modern building incorporating an undercroft of Henry V’.
So we must be careful in our attitudes to ugliness; beauty is both in the eye of the beholder and in the fashion of the times. Nevertheless, there are certain aspects even of Ripon that it might be safe to say are ugly.
Some of this ugliness is deliberate, some of it accidental. Take, for example, the block of flats on North Street that replaced the Congregational church with its tall spire. Comfortable and efficient as homes they may be; but they are not a thing of beauty. They were built in a time when little thought was given to aesthetics, only to utility – and we have not yet escaped that mind-set.
Almost opposite the flats is another manifestation of utilitarianism – the petrol filling station. Could this be more attractive? Perhaps, with some imagination and thought. Should it? That’s up to us – if we bothered to insist, it could happen, but the style is now probably too far entrenched in the national psyche even to register.
Schools, too, are not always as attractive as they might be. Primary schools of the 60s, 70s and 80s were built low and spreading, but not very attractively. Secondary schools have gone for blandness and utility. It’s unfortunate that for so many of us our childhoods are passed in buildings of such banality.
Then there are the purely functional buildings – the shed in the car park near Sainsbury’s, the extension to the former bus depot on Park Street for the carpet shop, the additions behind the Market Square shops.
Sometimes, decent buildings undergo what occasional Ripon resident Lewis Carroll would have called ‘uglification’. The former Kearsley’s works, now a timber yard, in Trinity Lane have been badly treated, with blocked windows and altered doors. The premises now occupied by the Masonic Hall on the corner of Water Skellgate and Low Skellgate – a sensitive site at a prominent junction – have not been sensitively treated, and the corner could well be improved.
Harold Wilson’s desire to remove Victorian squalor may have seemed admirable in 1967; today, it looks like arrogance. We must be careful with our past – but there are certainly things we could do to improve our future.
