‘The train, which started at half-past one, jerked and rattled along an embankment whence she looked down through bare branches and branches freckled with yellow leaves into Bragdon Wood itself and thence along the edge of Brawl Park and so to the first stop at Duke’s Eaton. Here . . . the train settled back, when it stopped, with a little jerk and something like a sigh. And then there would be a noise of . . . coarse boots treading on the platform and after that a pause while the autumn sunlight grew warm on the window-pane and smells of wood and field from beyond the tiny station floated in. At quarter-past two she came to St. Anne’s, which was the terminus of the branch, and the end of everything.’
Does that remind you of anything? Perhaps it calls to mind one of the UK’s favourite poems: in which
Yes, I remember Adelstrop –
The name. because one afternoon
Of heat the express-train drew up there
Unwontedly. It was late June.
The steam hissed. Someone cleared his throat.
No one left and no one came
On the bare platform . . .
Edward Thomas’s poem Adelstrop, about a village station in Gloucestershire at which he stopped unexpectedly in June 1914, is very familiar. The first quotation is from a science fiction novel, perhaps little-read today, by C S Lewis of ‘Narnia’ fame. It is called ‘That Hideous Strength’.
Duke’s Eaton, St Anne’s, Adelstrop . . . whether fiction or fact, they are not local names to Ripon. But until the late 1960s you could have had much the same experience by boarding a train at Ripon station.
It’s easy, perhaps, to be nostalgic about the days of steam, about country stations where the chief occupation seemed to be gardening, occasionally interrupted by passenger or milk trains, about trundling along small branch lines with country views, as the heroine in the C S Lewis book did. Such reminiscences are comforting, but possibly not entirely in line with the reality of rail travel as it used to be.
Fast forward to 2026. Are we in science fiction territory again? Not if you believe the supporters of the new, super-fast railway line from London to Birmingham and (perhaps by 2032) on to Manchester and Leeds. By then travellers will be able to get from London to Birmingham in an amazing 23 minutes faster. It might be possible to shave a whole hour off the journey time from Leeds to London. And it will only cost us £17 billion (at today’s estimate) to go the first stretch to Birmingham – just £739,130,435 for each minute saved.
This is, of course, not a sensible way of looking at it. That might be the cost, but think of the savings to business. Because London is the focus of the country, so the argument runs, and is the centre of both business and government, it makes sense for people to reach London as fast as possible (curiously, the argument about leaving London as fast is possible is rarely put forward). Any saving of time is a saving of money, and money is paramount. So it makes sense to spend very large sums to save what may be even bigger sums.
Opponents of High Speed 2, as the scheme is known, have plenty of arguments against this – that there is no business case that stacks up in its favour, that it is too London-centric, that the cost in lost landscapes, historic buildings and blight on communities is too great – the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings has published alarming information about listed buildings to be demolished or that will be badly affected by the proximity of the HS2 line – and that the costs associated with shaving a few minutes off some journeys cannot be justified.
It will also run into trouble, with delays and legal costs, because of opposition from the Tory shires – even though, we are told, there is to be no public inquiry into the route and its justifications.
Railways are undoubtedly an excellent way of moving large numbers of people without the amounts of pollution associated with air or road transport. But to use that argument to promote a slightly-faster route into London is, perhaps, not logical. Is HS2 the way forward?
Consideration might be given, instead, to providing alternatives to cars or buses in places outside the capital. A look at a map of the rail network provides food for thought; if you live in the south-east, you nearly always have an accessible railway not too far away. In other parts of the country that’s not the case. Instead of spending billions on a single route, why not spend them on upgrading and reinstating lines that will have a greater impact on the mobility of people throughout the country?
Some lines have been brought back from the execution of Dr Beeching’s axe by volunteers – the Wensleydale Railway is a good example, which proves that a reopened line is not just for tourists but is used a great deal by local people. Just think how much more it might be used if public money was available to reopen its full length, from Northallerton, where it meets the east coast main line, to Garsdale, joining the Settle to Carlisle line. It would open up all sorts of possibilities for both visitors to the Dales and for the people who live there.
The line between York and Beverley is being carefully studied and promoted to relieve congestion and cut down the number of accidents on the A1079. Its reinstatement looks a distinct possibility.
And so to Ripon. There is an excellent business case for reopening the line through the city – certainly to Harrogate, to take the pressure off an equally accident-prone A61, and preferably to Northallerton, too. A few of those millions from the HS2 could transform Ripon’s economy in many ways. It may need a little subsidy to start with, but passengers would undoubtedly come – especially as fuel for cars continues to increase in price. Detailed thought has already been given to how this might be accomplished. It just needs the political will, and some crumbs from the HS2 table, to bring it about.
