In 1845 Charles Piazzi Smyth had an idea. As the Ripon Civic Society plaque on his former home, Clova on Clotherholme Road, notes, he was Astronomer Royal for Scotland. It came to him, as he later wrote, that ‘The atmosphere being so determined an opponent, every effort should be made to eliminate its effects as far as possible; and this can only be accomplished by rising above its grosser parts.’
To rise above these ‘grosser parts’ (by which he meant the atmospheric pollution of his day) he took practical steps. In June 1856 he sailed (in railway engineer Robert Stephenson’s yacht Titania) to Tenerife. Here he dragged a seven-and-a-half inch telescope up to Alta Vista on the Pico del Teide. Not only did he drag up the telescope; his wife Jessie went up, too.
At 10,700 feet above sea level he made the first experiments with a mountain-mounted telescope and reported that he was able to view the heavens with hugely-increased clarity. The drawings of Jupiter he made from his observations were described as ‘revelations.’ Not content with this, he also took stereoscopic photographs of his expedition. His book ‘Tenerife, an Astronomer’s Experiments’ was the first book to be illustrated with 3D pictures, taken with Dancer’s recently-patented stereoscopic camera. It was typical both of Smyth’s love of self-promotion as well as of his interest in experimentation – though it was perhaps a cul-de-sac in publishing.
Where Smyth led, others have followed. The most recent is the European Extremely Large Telescope (E-ELT) which has been constructed on the Cerro Armazones mountain in the central part of the Atacama Desert in Chile. As its somewhat humdrum name suggests, it is rather bigger that Smyth’s seven-and-a-half inch telescope, with a 40-metre main mirror. Its location, at more than 3,000 metres above sea level, was picked because the skies there are clear for about 320 nights a year, and because it is close to another mountain-top telescope, the equally-exciting Very Large Telescope.
Atmospheric pollution has long been a problem for astronomers, as Piazzi Smyth recognised. But in his day a problem that besets modern life had not really made its presence felt – light pollution. Pall Mall in London first had gas lighting in 1807; Preston was the first place outside the capital to have gas street lights, in 1825. But gas light, magical as it seemed to the Georgians, was not so bright, or so widespread, that it much affected the brilliance of the night skies. The moon still provided much of the night-time illumination, and for country people it remained so for a century or more – unless like the rustics in Hardy’s ‘The Return of the Native’ they collected glow-worms to light their gambling sessions.
Today, of course, electric light is everywhere – and getting ever more pervasive. Satellite images published by the Council for the Protection of Rural England (CPRE) show the UK in 1993 and in 2000. Colours show how much artificial light there is in each area of the country. As you would expect, the main conurbations are the brightest – it is easy to pick out the red denoting London, Birmingham, Manchester, Leeds and Glasgow on both maps. On the 1993 image, though, much of the country has patches of dark blue – areas with least light pollution.
By 2000 much more of the country was polluted; only the least populated areas – the Highlands, the Welsh hills, the Pennine uplands, Dartmoor – remained dark blue. And this was 11 years ago; light pollution has continued to get worse since.
You may not think it is a problem – we have light so we can see to go about our business. But if you live near a source of light pollution, you may have other thoughts. A CPRE survey last year found that the worst light pollution comes from road lighting, sports grounds, and businesses. More than 80 per cent of those lights were on all night. Half of the people surveyed said that such intrusive lighting hinders their sleep.
Significantly, 71 per cent of people have never complained – felling that there was little point in doing so. This seems to be backed up by another finding – that, of those who did complain, nearly three-quarters found their local council unsupportive. The most impressive finding, though, was that more than 99 per cent of people would wish to see the problems of wasted light addressed to cut energy waste and carbon emissions.
What is Ripon doing to help this problem of too much wasted artificial light? Not, it seems, a great deal. In some ways things are getting worse.
The historic city centre is a Conservation Area, in which there are special policies that include a prohibition on internally-illuminated shop signs. The idea of this is, presumably, two-fold; to prevent any tendency for the city centre to become a Las Vegas neon paradise, and to keep light levels down. Such internally-illuminated signs for shop fronts and businesses regularly appear in planning applications; the Civic Society always objects, as they are contrary to Harrogate Borough Council’s policies.
The Society is pleased to say that HBC upholds the objections and refuses such permission – but sometimes the premises go ahead in contravention to such refusal. Look at the pizza shop at the top of Kirkgate or, more recently the new wine shop which has illuminated signs for which permission has not been obtained. The Civic Society has asked HBC’s officers to look at these matters, and at the new 24-hour opening of the filling station on North Street, which now has its bright lights shining throughout the darkness hours, so that car washing can be done at 3.30 am.
We all need to be much more aware of light pollution, and look for ways of reducing it while maintaining safety. And that could bring us to street lights, and whether they could be switched off . . . The subject of another of these pieces, perhaps.
