TASTE AND SENSE

It’s remarkable how many sayings there are about taste. There’s the Latin tag ‘De gustibus non est disputandum’, which is rather loosely translated as ‘there’s no arguing about taste’. There’s the French ‘Chacun à son goût’ – ‘Each to his own taste’. And then, of course, there’s ‘One man’s meat is another man’s poison’.

All of which goes to show that indisputable truism – that taste is a very personal matter. Or is it?

In some matters, of course it is; some prefer tea to coffee, The Sun to The Guardian, Bach to the Arctic Monkeys. And then there are what you might call historical tastes; the Romans had a taste for gladiatorial combat, the Elizabethans for bear baiting, the Georgians for bare-knuckle fighting. The Victorians took laudanum and calomel in large quantities; smoking was almost the norm for much of the 20th century. Perhaps in the future our own generation will be castigated for something that many see as ordinary behaviour today – our driving fuel-hungry vehicles that depend on non-renewable sources of energy, perhaps, or deafening ourselves in nightclubs.

Taste in architecture changes, too. You have only to look at the different styles of architecture in Ripon Cathedral to see that things changed through the centuries. St Wilfrid’s 7th-century crypt is different from the 13th-century West front, which is again different from the East window in the Geometric Decorated style. Some of this may be put down to technical innovation; but much of it is a matter of taste – taste that becomes the style of the time.

And so through the ages – medieval Gothic gives way to Classical-inspired Renaissance buildings. A taste for purer neo-Classical buildings, like Ripon Town Hall, comes in during the 18th century, only to be largely swept away by the Victorians’ liking for all manner of historical styles, including Gothic Revival – St Wilfrid’s Church, and some of the terraces on North Street, for example.

The earlier 20th century had a neo-Tudor phase, when genuine medieval beams were exposed (the Wakeman’s House) and fake beams were applied (several buildings around the Market Square). It lasted well into the latter part of the century (houses on Kirkby Drive, for example, with their Tudoresque black-and white upper floors). It mixed with neo-Georgian, such as the new houses of the city that have wrought-iron balconies and pretend columns by their front doors – as does the entrance to the Arcade on the Square.

And what of today’s taste? This column was recently taken to task for being critical of some of the new building in the city, including at the former College site, for such things as the smallness of the windows in some of the properties. These are problems that are not restricted to this site – or even this city.

Nevertheless, as was pointed out, the people who live in these properties are happy with them. They see them as comfortable and sustainable homes, and they are proud of them. So perhaps we are, again, back at nuances of taste. If a house suits its occupants, that is excellent; that, after all, is the purpose of a house. And if others perceive drawbacks, they are looking at the matter from a different perspective.

There is a whole poem by Alexander Pope on the subject of taste. It was written to the Yorkshire landowner and dictator of architectural taste at the beginning of the 18th century, Lord Burlington. Although Pope called it ‘Epistle on the Use of Riches’ he uses it to praise the architectural taste of Burlington, whose love of the buildings of the 16th-century Italian architect Palladio meant that he put forward ‘rules of taste’ for others to follow.

Pope saw the danger. He wrote,
‘Yet shall (my Lord) your just, your noble rules
Fill half the land with imitating fools’.
The warning was apt; in Burlington’s day Palladian architecture was the only up-to-date style (however ironic that may seem to us) and many buildings were run up in that style without the knowledge of the style’s underlying principles that was so necessary.

And Pope noted something else:
‘A certain truth, which many buy too dear;
Something there is more needful than expense,
And something previous even to taste – ‘tis sense.’

Are we lacking that prerequisite in our building today? You may look at some of the more advanced modern buildings in this and other countries – the Shard, now going up in London; the Imperial War Museum in Salford, perhaps the Hepworth Gallery in Wakefield – and conclude that modern style is a triumph of style and innovation over sense. It must be said, though, that on the whole the odd-looking museums do their job well, both in displaying their exhibits and in attracting visitors. No doubt the Shard, another iconic building to join London’s Gherkin, will also attract many people to it – especially for the view from its very elevated public galleries.

The architects of these buildings would, perhaps, agree with Dryden that
‘ . . . he who servilely creeps after sense
Is safe, but ne’er will reach an excellence.’

We may have more doubts about some of the far-from-iconic buildings that go up on our streets and in our housing estates. Building as cheaply as possible may be understandable from a commercial standpoint – but it does not often result in good buildings. Taste is not at the top of the list – and sense is not always apparent either.

So although we can’t argue about individual taste – whether what is a home to one is an unattractive box to another – we can say that tastes have always changed. Yet it would be encouraging to think that, as the tastes of the time change, there are, underneath it all, some acknowledged rules of architectural ‘rightness’ on which we might all agree.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.