Three programmes on BBC4, ‘Tales from the National Parks’, have pointed out some of the pitfalls as well as the advantages of designating areas of countryside as having special qualities.
With Ripon strategically placed between our two Yorkshire National Parks, the Dales and the North York Moors, and with other designated areas – the Nidderdale and Howardian Hills Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty, for example – very near, too, we should take an interest in how these areas were chosen and how they are run.
The three parks chosen for the television series were the Lake District and the Peak District in England, and Loch Lomond and the Trossachs in Scotland. It’s a shame that Yorkshire’s two Parks were not part of the series – perhaps next time. We can claim a tiny part of the Peak District, of course (though not the bit where the programme was set). And if the extensions to the Yorkshire Dales’ and the Lake District’s areas are finally approved, we shall have two parks to our west with a common border.
Central to two of the three programmes was the tension between the need for protecting the countryside and allowing sensible and sustainable development, that give local people employment and the local area the chance of income from visitors. Television producers are, of course, always on the lookout for any sort of conflict – a programme where everyone is in agreement and all is sweetness and light would be a dull thing, perhaps. But the series showed that designation brings tension – probably inevitably.
People in other parts of the world would argue that Britain doesn’t really have National Parks at all. The standards are set by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN). They have several categories – ranging from Strict Nature Reserves and Wilderness areas, where the landscape is entirely natural (areas such as deserts and virgin rainforest (Category I) to Managed Resources Protected Areas (Category VI), where ecosystems are protected but there is plenty of human activity.
The designation of National Park is Category 2; but Britain’s 15 National Parks are not in it. Our ‘National Parks’ are actually designated as Category V – Protected Landscapes. They are places where people live and work among stunning scenery, but are not really ‘natural’ landscapes.
Still, Britain can claim to have had a head start. In the very early 19th century Wordsworth wrote that we should see the Lake District as ‘a sort of national property, in which every man has a right and interest who has an eye to perceive and a heart to enjoy.’ Excellent, democratic stuff – except that he went on to say they should be for ‘persons of taste and discrimination’ – that is, for people with the same aesthetic appreciation of nature as he and his friends had.
The first designated National Parks were in the United States, and it wasn’t until after World War 2 that Britain’s Parks were designated – with the Peak District the first in 1951. The North York Moors National Park came into being in 1952 and the Yorkshire Dales Park in 1954. The very latest is the South Downs, in April this year.
The post-war ideals for national parks were very different from what Wordsworth had envisaged. In his day, most land was owned by big landowners, who severely restricted access. By the late 19th century that was being challenged, and there was agitation for some public access. The National Trust, a private charity and entirely separate from the organisation of the National Parks, was set up in 1895. In the 1930s people began to take matters into their own hands, with mass trespasses on private land – most famously on Kinder Scout in the Peak District in 1923.
Post-war ideas for National Parks developed this idea of their being for everyone – but that the land within them remains in private hands. The Dower Report of 1945 defined a National Park in the British context as ‘An extensive area of beautiful and relatively wild country in which, for the nation’s benefit and by appropriate national decision and action, (a) the characteristic landscape beauty is strictly preserved, (b) access and facilities for public open-air enjoyment are amply provided, (c) wild-life and buildings and places of architectural and historical interest are suitably protected, while (d) established farming use is effectively maintained’.
That was probably a reasonable definition then, but, as the BBC4 series showed, strictly preserving landscape, providing access and facilities and maintaining farming are probably harder today. The assumption of the Report that farming would maintain the landscape, and, subliminally, that it was only farming that was found in the countryside, was wide of the mark. Today the pressures are manifold – tourism, second-homes, active sports like motor-boating and abseiling, for example, all take their toll.
There has certainly been a shift in emphasis within the Parks themselves, as well as among the bureaucrats and the politicians, which acknowledges to a much greater extent that the economic well-being of a National Park has a great importance – people must be able to make a living. Some of this is acknowledged in the way farmers in some of the Parks are paid for looking after the landscape, rather than on immediately-profitable crops or livestock.
This balance between preservation and progress is hard – as the television programmes showed. It’s a balance that we need to find in Ripon, too – between people who maintain that Ripon must remain in essence a small market town serving a rural hinterland, and others who have a wider vision for the city, with a prosperous economic and business base and a generous welcome for tourists.
Perhaps a new BBC4 series – Tales from the Market Towns’ – is what we need. Ripon could be number one (in all senses, perhaps!).
