In the 19th century the populations of our cities expanded hugely – London most of all, rising from not quite one million in 1801 to six-and-a-half million by the end of the century. Other industrial cities mirrored this growth, and even small places like Ripon had their share of expansion; Ripon expanded from fewer than 6,000 residents in 1841 to 9,500 by 1951.
To accommodate all these extra people, cities have had to expand. And much of that expansion had to be into what had hitherto been open fields. Readers of history will often come across references to London suburbs as villages distant from the city; travel to Chelsea or Islington was a jaunt into the country. It must have been somewhat the same in Ripon, though the distances are smaller. Just a glance at the Ordnance Survey maps of the city in the 1850s shows that Ripon stretches hardly further north than Allhallowgate, that Holy Trinity Church is on the western edge, that not much has been built east beyond Priest Lane, and that only Bondgate reaches to the south of the River Skell.
So if you live in Ripon but outside that central area, you are living on land that was once what today we’d loosely call ‘greenbelt’. And you can be sure that when your late-19th-century terrace or your 1930s semi, your Edwardian villa or your 1990s estate home was built, there were people who complained bitterly about having their views spoiled and held meetings to complain.
It probably did them no good. It was not until well into the 20th century that planning laws got a grip on what was and what was not allowed to be built, and where. In 1947 the Town and Country Planning Act (which became law the following year) gave retrospective permission for everything that had been built before then. Since then, any new development has had to have planning permission.
One thing that the Town and Country Planning Act and its successors have never included is a right to a view. However much you may value the vista from your house, you have no right to enjoy it. You may be fortunate to live in an area that has special protection – a National Park or an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty, perhaps; but even here planning permission can be granted that may spoil your view. No designation can give you give your view special protection.
Then there are plans that seek to build on what are called ‘brownfield’ sites – areas that have had some previous use but are now standing idle and could be given a new purpose. For the last decade or so brownfield sites have been the preferred places to build, rather than in the countryside – the ‘greenfield’ sites. In general this makes sense; it avoids covering the landscape with new houses or other buildings.
All planning applications are open to public scrutiny, and the local planning authority has to take all opinions into consideration when making a decision on an application. If an application is refused (and it can only be refused on strict planning grounds) the applicant has a right to appeal. If it is approved, there is, at present, no right for the objectors to appeal; such a right was proposed for new legislation before the last election, but the bill was not passed.
One of the largest applications for some years has recently been submitted to Harrogate Borough Council for the former Auction Market site on North Road, and a field adjoining. The plan is to build 96 units (such things are always inaccurately called ‘homes’ – but do not become homes until they have people in them!) on the site.
This column has long suggested that Ripon needs to be bigger – and the Civic Society has also long called for action on the derelict Auction Market site. In the Society’s preliminary response to the application (driven by a short timescale for responses, interrupted by Christmas) the Society has said that it has no objection in principle to the development, but suggests that ‘the number of proposed houses may be an over-development of the site’.
The Society is also concerned that the plans are silent on the provision of pedestrian and cycle access on to North Street, Princess Road and Magdalen’s Road; on retaining views of the cathedral from North Road, enhancing the setting of the Listed Chapel House to the east of the site which should form a landmark and on retaining and developing the east-west hedge across the site (dividing the Auction Market site from the field) as part of the layout, as a boundary between properties.
Given the notoriously-unstable ground conditions here, the result of underlying gypsum, the Society also urges the planning authority not to give permission until the problems have been fully assessed. Local residents are rightly concerned that any development on the site may have a detrimental effect on the stability of their properties.
There is one more matter that should be taken into account; the Society notes that the provision of public space planned for the development is insufficient. And here is an opportunity. The developers should look at reducing the number of houses and providing a facility that would benefit the city as a whole – a well-landscaped park and ride area with a permeable surface to alleviate the flood risk, to serve Ripon and reduce the traffic in the city, including that from the new development. Doing this might not stop the objections, but would show a willingness to offer Ripon something more than just more new ‘homes’.
