How do you, as a pedestrian, fancy sharing both the pavements and the roads with motor vehicles? Idiocy! you may think. A recipe for injury and mayhem! Keep the traffic and the walkers separate!
You would not be alone in that view. For the last 40 years at least the received wisdom has been that pedestrians and moving traffic should not – must not – mix. Separation has been the rule. And, certainly in the second half of the 20th century, traffic planners have kow-towed to the dominance of the motorcar and the lorry, the bus and the tanker, to given them priority on the streets. In the 60s and 70s many cities – like Birmingham – cut great swathes through their historic fabric to provide ‘expressways’ and ‘through routes’ that sped traffic on its way – leaving the poor pedestrian to weave a complicated way through noisome subways and over vertiginous bridges to get from place to place.
There was bound to be a reaction to the sacrifice of pedestrian safety to the convenience of traffic. That came with the development of pedestrianised areas – places from which traffic was excluded at certain times of the day – or sometimes permanently. Leeds was one of the earliest cities in England to pedestrianise part of its city centre. York soon followed – with the important and bitterly-fought decision not just to remove traffic from some of the city centre streets but also to close Deangate, a much-used through-route passing the Minster.
Dire warnings were issued about the continued viability of the businesses when traffic could no longer pass the door and motorists had to park at some distance and – horror! – walk to their destinations. Yet, once the schemes were in place, the figures showed entirely the opposite. Research showed that 83 per cent of retailers found an increase in trade; only three per cent declined. Restaurants did even better – only 1 per cent lost custom – a third held steady and two-thirds increased. And even hotels (perhaps less likely to affected if pedestrianisation hours are limited) showed that 92 per cent increased trade or at the least noticed no effect.
So pedestrianisation can certainly work, despite the gloom-merchants who are still around and cry ‘Never!’ when anything like it is suggested. Yet there may be another way of balancing the demands of traffic and pedestrians. Shared Spaces is a movement that has been gaining momentum for some years, and has had some impressive successes.
In essence, the concept of Shared Spaces challenges the assumption that using high levels of demarcation – barriers, bollards, benches – to segregate pedestrians from vehicles improves safety. This may well be counter-intuitive; if there’s a barrier to separate pedestrians and moving traffic, it must mean that the pedestrians are safer.
It turns out that this is not so. Traffic on streets that has such barriers moves faster because motorists feel that there can be no hazards in the way. This is true even if there is a low speed limit of 20mph or less; many (a majority of?) motorists believe they can ignore such limits because they have a clearly-defined route. And research shows that the illusion of extra safety provided by physical separation causes pedestrians and cyclists to take risks. Barriers can channel problems to particular areas where the accident rate is increased, not lowered.
So what does Shared Spaces propose? At its simplest this can just be removing guardrails to reduce demarcation. Alternatively, and more positively, it could mean giving pavements and roadways a level surface, taking away conventional kerbs and letting pedestrians share the whole area with cycles and motor vehicles.
The sound of sabres being sharpened to fight any such proposals for Ripon is already audible! But the evidence for the benefits of such a revolutionary proposal is substantial. Where shared space is in operation – in places like Seven Dials and Exhibition Road in South Kensington, both in London, and elsewhere, there has been a decrease in accidents. There have been increased levels of social interaction and leisure activity taking place on the streets, and people spend longer (and spend more money) in the street.
Above all, if drivers have to watch out more for hazards, they drive with much more care and with much more consideration. They are presented with an environment that is different each time, so they need to drive with greater awareness and more cautiously. Drivers and cyclists give way to pedestrians, and pedestrians can cross the street at the places – and at angles – that they choose. There must, of course, be some safeguards for people who have disabilities and, perhaps especially for blind people; with imagination and good will these can be provided.
One shared space may have particular lessons for Ripon. Castle Square in Caernarfon is the largest shared space in Britain. It is an historic area, once the outer bailey of the castle. For decades it was a place of circulating traffic and heavy parking, a place where locals and visitors took their life in their hands to cross. Now it has been repaved and made into a level, shared space. Traffic still uses it, but speeds have dropped and pedestrians now feel they they have at least as much right to use it as do vehicles. Some parking is still allowed – though on the edge, not in the centre, which has been reclaimed for pedestrians.
Caernarfon’s Town Centre Coordinator says, ‘People are strolling about admiring the castle, enjoying a cuppa at one of the outside café tables or watching the children playing in the fountain. It has the feel of a continental piazza (with slightly less sun!)’ It’s a vision Ripon could share – either with all-out pedestrianisation or, perhaps as an interim, with a Shared Spaces policy.
• The Department for Transport has a booklet on Shared Spaces – it can be downloaded at http://assets.dft.gov.uk/publications/ltn-01-11/ltn-1-11.pdf
• The charity Living Streets also has information on Shared Spaces: www.livingstreets.org.uk
