Blue-sky thinking. It’s one of those phrases that has come from nowhere to being a buzz-phrase of business. Curiously, it’s used in two ways; its supporters make it synonymous with the positive virtues of being open-minded and finding new ways of progressing. Its detractors, of course, take the opposite view; blue-sky thinking, they complain, is not in touch in the realities of the present – and therefore not worth undertaking.
Without a certain amount of such pondering, of course, no progress would be made. Every invention has an element of it, even if the origins of the innovation are firmly fixed in what has gone before. This column will end with a little blue-sky thinking – but let us first consider the history of shopping.
For millennia people have bought and sold. The transition may have involved swapping or bartering (and perhaps initially a great deal of grunting) but soon became more organised. First stalls and then shops were opened – the remains of Pompeii show how the Romans shopped. And gradually shops came together in town centres and into purpose-built markets; one of the earliest was in the Forum of Trajan in Rome, which had around 150 shops on different levels, selling wine, oil and grain.
By the Middle Ages the market hall had become both a place of practical value and a symbol of civic pride. Often they were built with an open lower floor for trade and an upper floor in which the town council considered its business and where the citizens came together for social occasions. The market hall at Tetbury in Gloucestershire offered generous accommodation. It has impressively-dumpy Tuscan columns around the selling area, and a large and handsome hall above, all of which were copied by the Prince of Wales as the centrepiece of his development at Poundbury in Dorset. The little Town Hall in Whitby is a more local example.
The medieval market crosses at Malmsbury and Salisbury in Wiltshire gave limited shelter to traders, but such structures had additional uses apart from commerce, particularly as a local meeting place. Other market halls
– Pembridge in Herefordshire, Chipping Campden in Gloucestershire and Hexham in Northumberland for example – are essentially simple roofs set on columns.
Some places thought on a grander scale. In the Low Countries huge halls were built, often for a single commodity, like the Cloth Hall at Ypres, started around 1200. Or they could be for a single group of merchants, like the House of the Hansa in Antwerp, built for the transactions of merchants belonging to the Hanseatic League.
In the 18th century Britain developed its own cloth halls – in Leeds and Bradford, for example, and most notably in Halifax, where the impressive Piece Hall was built in 1779 as a centre for weavers to display and sell their wares. By the 19th century, market halls were big business and were built using the latest techniques. Many of them took advantage of the development of cast-iron structures (a technique given impetus by Paxton’s Crystal Palace for the Great Exhibition of 1851). Some of them looked remarkably modern; Hungerford market hall was a very early example, designed by Charles Fowler and built in 1835 with an angular roof that could have been designed last year.
In the way of the Victorians to not notice when they were going over the top, some of their markets were wonderfully impressive but entirely impracticable. The most egregious example was the super-Gothic Columbia Market in London’s Bethnal Green, constructed between 1864 and 1869. Its style was based on the medieval Sainte Chapelle, the royal chapel in the heart of Paris. Called ‘one of the great follies of the Victorian Age’, Columbia Market cost its funder, Baroness Burdett-Coutts £200,000 – more than £10 million at today’s prices – and it totally failed. It was demolished in the early 1960s.
This was, though, an isolated example. Most markets flourished, and Victorian market halls, like those in Leeds and Halifax, and, on a smaller scale, in Richmond, are now valued. And the age of the market hall is by no means over; a new one has recently been built in the centre of the Pennine town of Penistone. It’s a traditional timber-framed structure that would not look out of place in a medieval city, and provides a venue for market traders during the week, for car booters on Sundays and a variety of other local events. It has not been without its problems – it should never have been left open-sided; the town is 750 feet up in the hills. The hall has now had glass panels fitted and has proved a valuable asset.
Which brings us back to blue-sky thinking. If Ripon ever bites the bullet and clears away car parking from the square, could the city have its own market hall occupying the northern half? Ripon could be really adventurous and have a modern structure – perhaps of steel and glass as a nod to the Victorians – designed by an up-and-coming architect.
Such a structure could host the weekly market – and perhaps encourage markets on other days, too. It could host antiques and craft fairs, farmers’ markets and other such events. There could be space for local cafés to have tables, and, with demountable stalls, the space could also be used for public events – concerts of all types, competitions, dances . . . It would provide shelter (when the skies aren’t blue!) and a communal space to bring local people together, and could become a visitor attraction in its own right.
Yes, it’s blue-skies thinking – but not out of this world. It could be done; let’s think more about it!
