In 1965 the man who designed London’s Royal Festival Hall for the Festival of Britain 15 years earlier, was commissioned for a new job. The commission was for nothing less than a whole-scale redevelopment of one of the most iconic streets in the country – Whitehall.
In that decade of, in Prime Minister Harold Wilson’s phrase ‘the white heat of technology’, there was a feeling abroad that the current buildings of Whitehall were grimy, depressing and inefficient. What was wanted was something new and exciting. Away with all this elaborate architecture! Demolish the tedious Treasury building! Remove the Georgian relic of Richmond Terrace! Above all, sweep away that Victorian confection the Foreign Office, with its ridiculous and impractical interiors designed by Sir Gilbert Scott! Clear it all away and replace it with new, functional, clean offices for our civil servants, built in the most modern style!
Such was the thinking in the mid- (or the mod-) Sixties. So the government – initially a Conservative government – called in Sir Leslie Martin, whose work on the South Bank had not been universally admired, to oversee the masterplan for a new Whitehall. Some of the ideas were quite sensible; a road under Parliament Square would have created a Parliamentary Precinct to allow safer and better views of the Houses of Parliament (which, despite being Victorian Gothic and inefficient were never threatened – some things are beyond the ambition even of a government).
But for the rest – for most of the length of Whitehall – buildings would be torn down and replaced by a series of giant office blocks, the upper floors set back in steps so as to avoid Whitehall looking like a canyon. By the time the plans were published, it was a Labour government who tried to take them forward. It is hardly surprising that there was very strong opposition to the plans. The new offices were immediately designated ‘Ziggurats for Bureaucrats’. There were exchanges such as this in the House of Commons:
Mr James Allason (Hemel Hempstead): ‘Would the Minister consider using conservation methods in the most historic conservation area in Britain? Why must we substitute something that looks like Noel Coward’s birthday cake?’ Hon. John Silkin (Deptford – the Minister responsible for the planned redevelopment): ‘I am reminded more and more how, whenever any piece of architecture is designed, it is bound to create a considerable variation of opinion. It is one of the sad things of life. I do not agree with the hon. Gentleman in his birthday cake allusion. Many people like the building; I have no doubt a number of people will not like it. I have promised to consider all these matters together, and I will.’
The considerations by Silkin and his government colleagues, influenced as they were by vociferous and widespread opposition, eventually resulted in the dropping of the planned demolition and rebuilding. There were some who regretted what they saw as a failure to provide ‘a cohesive government centre’; but most people recognised that it was the right decision. And we should probably be thankful: seen from a perspective of nearly half a century later, public building in the 1960s was some of the worst of the last century, and those that were built often cause massive problems today because of their inadequate workmanship.
The story of Whitehall is salutary. To many decision makers of the 1960s it was logical to demolish buildings that were not considered to be right for the time and for the function that they were being used for – in that modern in-phrase, buildings that were not ‘fit for purpose’. It is easy to decide to demolish a building without enough thought; it is less easy to replace a decent building with something equally good.
In Ripon we have perhaps been quite lucky in the amount of demolition that has taken place. The Victorian bank building that was replaced by the current NatWest on the Market Square was a loss; so were the terraces of houses on the south side of Allhallowgate. On the whole, though, the centre of Ripon survives reasonably intact. True, there has not been the pressure for development here as there has been in London, where in some places buildings survive barely 20 years before being replaced.
But we must be ever-vigilant. It is very easy for buildings to get into such a state of disrepair that it is easier to say ‘Demolish it, and get rid of an eyesore’ than to say ‘Yes, it’s a problem at the moment, but beneath the dereliction there is a building that could still have a use – let’s work together to find that use and bring an important building back to life.’
The problems are always more acute when a building is seen as peripheral. In Ripon we have two cases, both, as it happens, of former Maltings buildings. One is behind Sainsbury’s store – a fairly small building that could with imagination be rescued and used for some purpose – commercial, community or even residential. More pressing is the Maltings at Ure Bank, a much larger building with more problems. It is listed Grade II. There is currently an application for Listed Building consent to demolish it lodged with Harrogate Borough Council (HBC).
It is clearly a problem building; the owners say that they have tried and failed to find alternative uses – though that should not have offered an excuse for not keeping it in better reaper, nor for HBC to fail to insist on their doing so. It is, though, a symbol of one of Ripon’s former industries, and an important building. And just as the buildings of Whitehall were once seen as problems but are now valued, so could the Maltings be in Ripon. Demolition should be allowed only when we are convinced that it is the right thing to do.
