When the planners of New York set about laying down the grid plan of the city, there were people who said they were mad. It was too grandiose a vision to plan streets that would one day encompass the width of Manhattan, and idiocy to have the avenues run the length of it. There would never be enough people to occupy more than a small fraction of it.
In Washington, too, there was suggestion of hubris in the laying out of grandiose avenues and circles that stretched for miles across the countryside – especially as, in around 1800 when the pattern was laid out, there were fewer than 120 Federal staff in the capital.
In both cases, of course, the sceptics were entirely wrong, and those two cities have fully justified (in planning terms, if in no other) the vision of their planners. Of course, it was easy for them – a virgin site with not a great deal in the way of natural obstacles, meant that straight lines drawn on a map could easily be translated into real roads on the ground. And there is no denying that there is something grand – if grandiose – about such streets. You have only to look down one of New York’s avenues in central (sorry, downtown) Manhattan to be impressed by the sheer scale and straightness that the early planners foresaw.
American cities were not, of course, the first to plan on a grid pattern. Even in ancient Greece planners were at work, dividing up cities into rectangular blocks. The city of Miletus in Ionia was laid out on just such a plan, within an irregular city wall, around 475 BC. Ancient Rome has its grid plan, too, with insulae – what we’d call blocks of flats and the Americans just blocks – separated by straight streets. In 1606 the German city of Mannheim was laid out with rectangular blocks; they don’t have names but numbers – so you will live not in, say, Mannheim Strasse but in C4 or Q8.
Even Britain has old examples. Salisbury, for example, was laid out in a grid pattern in the very early 13th century when the bishop moved his cathedral from nearby Old Sarum. Four hundred years later the coastal town of Whitehaven in Cumbria was given a grid pattern layout. And, of course, many of our industrial cities had grids of terraced housing added to them in the 19th century to cope with the influx of workers for mills and factories; Saltaire, near Bradford, is one such grid pattern, though Sir Titus Salt’s benevolent (though financially astute) rule of the village raised it above the often-squalid norm.
So the grid layout of a town has a long and sometimes distinguished history, and has always had its supporters. After the Great Fire of London Sir Christopher Wren was quick off the mark with a plan for rebuilding that had long avenues and criss-crossing streets. And in Paris in the 1860s and 1870s Georges-Eugène Haussmann – usually called Baron Haussmann – was commissioned by Napoleon III to get rid of much of what remained of the medieval layout and buildings of central Paris and transform it with boulevards and avenues.
That Haussmann succeeded and Wren failed says a great deal about how the French and the English view their cities – and, perhaps, their governments. Haussmann’s plans, backed by imperial authority, were carried out; Wren’s in London, though approved by the King, were defeated. A combination of a tenacious hold on property, which meant that landowners insisted on their right to rebuild on their own land and refused to make way for new avenues, and an English love of the irregular and small-scale scuppered this new vision of London.
Grand planning has never really been an English thing. Even in the 18th century, when the nobility were building themselves classical houses, they surrounded them with informal landscapes. And while speculators may have laid out formal squares of houses, there were often irregular gardens at the centre of them. For many people, it was irregularity that they liked, and they shunned regularity of architecture and planning.
Some people have seen this as a fundamental characteristic of the English people – they have always preferred the smaller scale and the less-formal aspects of life, as if they are happiest not being pushed around and intimidated by authorities, whether through their politics or their architecture.
Yet when we do get formality, it can be impressive. When John Aislabie commissioned Nicholas Hawksmoor to put up the obelisk in the centre of the market square in Ripon, he was doing more than just giving the city a new ornament. Hawksmoor saw the obelisk as a symbol of power – even a sort of imperial Roman power – and Aislabie would have approved, as it showed him as a powerful man. And Hawksmoor went further – he saw the square as being the Yorkshire equivalent of a Roman Forum, with, no doubt, Aislabie as the Emperor.
Riponians seem to have accepted the changes with good grace – probably it meant little to them except a tidying up of the marketplace they and their forebears had known since it was laid out in the 13th century. Yet in some ways it was a revolutionary change, and may have had a psychological effect – certainly the Aislabie family and their descendants held near-imperial sway over the city for nearly two centuries.
Ripon’s Square gets much of its power because it is surrounded not by the ruler-straight avenues of the Americans, nor by the boulevards of Paris, but by a jumble of small, twisting medieval streets. These streets are very English; in some way the Market Square is not – it’s an alien but remarkable presence in the heart of this small city. We should celebrate its formality in the midst of so much English informality.
