Ripon’s two upper tier councils, Harrogate Borough Council and North Yorkshire County Council, are currently consulting all of us about air quality. A leaflet and questionnaire produced jointly by the two councils wants comments on eleven proposals that will help to alleviate the air quality problems in High and Low Skellgate.
Regular readers of this column will know that this consultation has not come out of the blue (or even the murky grey of a polluted street). In 2010 the councils reported on their monitoring, of these streets, and of Westgate, and had identified high levels of nitrogen dioxide levels – higher than is officially approved as being safe for people who live in those streets. This was hardly surprising, because the greatest producer of nitrogen dioxide is the traffic that moves along – and, worse, is stationary in – the narrow streets, and in Low and High Skellgate there is so much traffic, which stays still for so long, that problems are inevitable.
The problems that pollution from such traffic causes is well known. A DEFRA-produced booklet called ‘Air Pollution: what it means for your health’, warns that ‘when air pollution levels are high, some people may feel eye irritation, others may start to cough, and some may find that breathing deeply hurts. Daily changes in air pollution trigger increased admissions to hospital and contribute to the premature death of those who are seriously ill.’
In November 2010 these streets were declared by the two councils as an Air Quality Management Area (AQMA). Of course, labels are one thing – action is another. Having recognised the problem, something needs to be done. The declaration of the AQMA then set the clock going, giving 18 months for the councils to produce an action plan. And that’s what we now have, in the form of a draft for consultation.
The plan offers five keys areas for action – educating us (including incentives to make us change our behaviour); placing restrictions on vehicles on these streets; signposting; and introducing new ‘engineering measures’ and planning controls.
There is much in these plans to be applauded. Action on education will ‘work with key groups, including employers and schools [to] encourage more sustainable travel.’ It will also ‘promote public transport, car share, walkng and cycling [to] reduce car use, congestion and queuing.’ Good – but is this not happening already? If it isn’t, why not? And if it is, what effect has it had? The answer is that the effect is probably minimal.
More encouraging is the action headed ‘Restrictions on polluting vehicles travelling through the AQMA’, which aims to ‘reduce the source of the pollution [by] work with bus companies, HGV operators ad school transport to consider alternative routes and use of ‘greener’ vehicles.’ If this means that buses and lorries – and parents making school runs – are told to use other routes, that will make a great deal of difference. A different route for the buses that currently use Low and High Skellgate would be the most important step that could be taken, and the councils should be encouraged to have the bus companies implement changes as soon as possible. There is also a pledge to ‘investigate introduction of HGV bans/weight restrictions’ – again something that should be done very quickly, preferably coupled with time restrictions on when local deliveries can be made.
Under ‘Signposting’ we have some obvious measures that will ‘direct traffic away from AQMAs’. There is also a suggestion for introducing ‘signs to explain the benefits of turning off engines when in traffic queues’; this has its attractions, but has worrying implications of adding to the plethora of signage under which Ripon already groans.
Then the proposals rather peter out into pious hope rather than in practicalities; traffic lights will be looked at to reduce queuing; buses could have priority at signals (who will that happen in Low Skellgate, one wonders); and planning policy will be developed so that any future development takes air quality into account (probably mot much help as there’s unlikely to be much new development in Low and High Skellgate).
What is significant here is not what the proposals include, but what is not there. However well-intentioned the education, there is going to be no compulsion to use alternative routes or to switch off engines. New signposting may remove some traffic – but locals will not change their routes because of it. New bus routes and HGV restrictions could have an important effect, but they must be swiftly implemented and properly policed.
Tinkering with traffic signals will probably make little difference; what would help would be the removal of traffic lights. As studies on the continent have shown, traffic flows more freely and more carefully when traffic lights are removed. For those who require some comfort-blanket of restriction, a mini-roundabout could be introduced where Low and High Skellgate meet Water Skellgate.
But even these are tinkering at the edges. What is needed, as this column has previously proposed, is a new short length of link road from near KwikFit’s premises to the bottom of Firby Lane, by the Hugh Ripley Hall, with a widening of Firby Lane itself to two way traffic. Such a road would remove all traffic from High and Low Skellgate, turning them from polluted canyons into pleasant streets that would offer both an attractive introduction to the city for pedestrians and a great place to live.
And the benefits don’t stop there; the link road would mean that traffic could be diverted away from the Market Square, which would become much more pedestrian- and shopper-friendly, where people are encouraged to linger, to the great benefit of traders.
Planners will argue that there is no money; we should argue that the benefits of such a road are so great the money can – and must – be found. So when you fill in your questionnaire on air quality, why not urge this better solution?
