DISSEMBLING BUILDINGS

Can a building be dishonest? Can it be untruthful?

The idea of truth in architecture has exercised architects and critics – as well as the general public – for centuries. It was at the centre of a debate in the 16th and 17th centuries, when the Renaissance architects revived classical forms. Was this honest? some people asked. Or was it trying to force an alien and outmoded style on the public?
Just think, for example, what Londoners thought in 1619 when Inigo Jones’ startling new Banqueting House went up in Whitehall – a white, severely classical building set in the surrounding acres of medieval stone and Tudor brick. The critics no doubt thought themselves vindicated in 1649 when the building, a symbol of royal hubris, was used as the background for the execution of Charles I.

Yet after the Commonwealth period, it was classical styles that triumphed – the architects Wren and Vanbrugh were leading lights, as was Hawksmoor, designer of Ripon’s obelisk, which was inspired not by Egypt but ancient Rome. These architects, working within a free classical tradition, at least built honestly – walls were of stone, carvings were done with hammer and chisel. Sometimes there was deception; the lantern on top of the dome of St Paul’s Cathedral does not sit on the lead-covered hemisphere beneath it but on a hidden brick cone between the inner and outer domes.

In the 18th century, though, things get more illusory. Buildings were brick-built, then covered with stucco and incised with joints to make them look like stone; Wyatt’s Ripon Town Hall is a good example. Is this dishonesty? Or is it just money-saving – and should saving money be allowed to result in fake architecture? Interestingly, these 18th-century builders had a precedent; when our Norman churches were built, their stone interiors were covered with a coat of white plaster, on to which were lines painted (usually in red) to make the walls look like masonry.

By the late 18th century there came a vogue for Gothic architecture. Much of this, too, was fake – it was just applied decoration rather than an honest part of the structure – and when architects tried to build structural Gothic the results were sometimes disastrous. Wyatt built the great Fonthill Abbey for eccentric William Beckford; it went up in 1796 and fell down in 1825.

Gothic could be used, of course, for garden buildings. At Studley Royal the Octagon Tower has Gothic trimmings, and visitors to Hackfall know Mowbray Castle and Fisher’s Hall, both Gothic. At Hackfall, too, the Ruin is a classical folly, but with Gothic doorways and windows – an interesting mix of styles.

This, the more severe 19th century believed, was wrong – some went so far as to suggest it was sinful. Augustus Pugin, for one, argued that, for Britain we needed to set an honest British style – and that style must be true Gothic. A Roman Catholic convert, he despised the classical style (he wrote about the Greek-style Yorkshire Museum, set in the ruins of St Mary’s Abbey in York, that ‘it would hardly have been possible to erect more offensive objects than these buildings, in the immediate vicinity of one of the purest specimens of Christian architecture in this country’. Christian to Pugin was Gothic – and was the only style in which to build.

He was backed up in his beliefs by the influential critic John Ruskin. His influential work ‘The Seven Lamps of Architecture’, published in 1849, examined architecture from ethical and religious points of view. One of his ‘Lamps’ – by which he implied guiding lights for looking at architecture – was the Lamp of Truth. In this section of his book he argued that structures must be honest and show clearly how they are constructed; that surfaces should show what they are made of (so that condemned stucco hiding brick, for example); and that there should be no ‘use of cast or machine-made ornaments of any kind’ – in other words, everything should be hand-made by craftsmen who took pride in their work.

This last statement resounded with William Morris, who devoted his life to trying to convince people that craftwork was essential – essential both to the people who bought it (his famous saying ‘Have nothing in your houses that you do not know to be useful or believe to be beautiful’ was intended to convey this message) and to the people who made it, who, having created something, would have pride in it. It also made him an opponent of ‘restoration’ of buildings, like the changes Sir George Gilbert Scott brought about in cathedrals like Ripon.

In 1877 Morris founded The Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings (SPAB) to counteract what he called the ‘Scraping’ of buildings. His philosophy was that any necessary repairs to a structure should be undertaken with minimum invasion and show honestly how they were done – so new stone must not be artificially ‘aged’, for example. It is a tribute to Morris’ and SPAB’s influence over the last century that such principles are now widespread; visitors to Mowbray Castle at Hackfall will find obviously new stone set amidst the old, and, at the back, a concrete beam exposed high up – all part of what mathematics exams call ‘show your working.’

And what of today? Are we honest and truthful in our buildings? Building techniques have advanced so far that we can build virtually anything. Walls don’t need to be vertical, curves are simple, overhangs a doddle. But just because we can do this, although this sometimes results in exceptional buildings (think of the Imperial War Museum at Salford, the Gherkin in the City of London) it doesn’t mean we always should.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.