REVISITING PEDESTRIANISATION

Early in 1990 a slim leaflet dropped through the doors of the people of Ripon. Perhaps you remember it. Printed in blue ink, it came from North Yorkshire County Council (NYCC) and was excitingly headed ‘Restoring the heart of Ripon’ – heart was underlined. To emphasise the point, the slogan was repeated down each side of the front page – though this time it was HEART – as if the capital letters were there to add urgency.

What was it all about? It appeared at the time when there were bold plans for Ripon’s traffic management – plans that resulted first in the bypass, opened in 1996 and then, after considerable delay, in the opening of Marshall Way. But ‘Restoring the HEART of Ripon’ was not about new roads. Instead, as the introductory paragraph proclaimed ‘alongside proposals to rid Ripon of some of its traffic, an opportunity has emerged to make plans for restoring some parts of the ancient city centre mainly to pedestrians.’

The leaflet mentions the processes that had already been gone through to put in a planning application to construct the bypass and to improve Skellgarths so that ‘cross-city traffic [can] be rerouted away from Westgate, the Market Place and Kirkgate’. Setting out the details of a public consultation and exhibition, the introduction then says, ‘The proposed bypass, by reducing traffic in the city centre, will provide the chance to consider both ‘pedestrianisation’ as well as the location of ‘pedestrian dominated areas’ in which traffic other than traffic serving premises would be prohibited.’

Five ‘Proposals’ are then put forward, each with a map and explanatory texts. These ‘Proposals’ range from the timid to the visionary. Each of them is aimed at providing a level of traffic removal from some of the city centre streets. Yet, despite the claims to have the opportunity to introduce ‘pedestrianisation’, the only proposals put forward are for ‘pedestrian dominated areas’ – areas that would not be completely traffic free but would still mean pedestrians dodging not only delivery vans but also those private motorists who felt they were entitled to ignore restrictive signs, just as they still today ignore ‘Access Only’ signs with impunity.

The first, most modest, proposal in NYCC’s leaflet was to restrict traffic in Finkle Street – along by the Post Office – and at the western end of Allhallowgate, between the end of Finkle Street and North Street. The measures would possibly include part of the Old Market Place in Front of the Black Bull, too. This was, as the leaflet noted, the only scheme that could be done before the bypass was built and Skellgarths improved. It has never happened.

Second came a scheme which added to Scheme 1 two other ideas – widening the pavement from the Queen Street junction with Moss’s Arcade, along the east side of the Square to the top of Kirkgate; and making the lower half of Kirkgate, from just beyond Duck Hill to Minster Road, a ‘pedestrian dominated area’. Always wary of knock-on effects, the leaflet’s writers say this could be done, ‘without any major change in traffic flows on adjacent roads.’ Kirkgate today is access only (for what that’s worth); we are still talking about proper pedestrianisation.

Now things get bolder. ‘It would be possible,’ the leaflet suggests in Proposal 3, ‘to make Fishergate, Market Place West and Market Place North pedestrian priority areas by introducing two-way traffic on Queen Street’ – which also means on Market Place East. Under this scheme there would, of course, be no widening of the pavement, but it would require traffic lights ‘to allow shuttle working on the Old Market Place area where the road narrows’ – that is, on the corner where Age UK now is. The leaflet says this would slow traffic in the centre down (more than has been achieved by the widely-ignored 20mph limits we now have) but would make crossing the roads more difficult for pedestrians.

Proposal 4 assumes the road that was eventually constructed as Marshall Way is in place. The idea for this proposal is to combine all the elements of plans 1 to 3, but to keep Queen Street one-way, make Westgate one-way going west and Firby Lane one-way going south. Some of this was, of course, implemented – though quite how much traffic is now made to use Marshall Way rather than the traditional route through the Market Square is debatable.

The final proposal envisages an extension of the road that became Marshall Way. It was to cut through from the Westgate end of Blossomgate to the bottom of High Skellgate, making, in effect, a five-way junction at the end of Somerset Row. This would mean that, building on Proposal 4, Westgate would no longer need to carry through traffic. So Westgate, as well as the top end of Kirkgate and the whole of Duck Hill and Bedern Bank, would become a pedestrian dominated area. And though it doesn’t say so, this would effectively close Minster Road to through traffic.

Only tiny parts of any of these proposals have happened. They provide a snapshot of early 90s thinking – note, though, that none of them suggests removing traffic from the Market Square, nor even closing the road in front of the Town Hall.

And what of today? Most of the new roads proposed by the road engineers – the bypass and Marshall Way, chiefly – have happened. Only the Blossomgate to Somerset Row link failed to materialise; it proved to be too destructive to the fabric of the city, and would have increased traffic on Low Skellgate, making it an even more polluted street, as we now realise. But the opportunities, seen more than 20 years on, are still there. It is surely time to wake up to the benefits of pedestrianisation for Ripon.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.