Every so often a book appears that immediately becomes a classic. It’s easy to make your own list of seminal novels – Robinson Crusoe, Tom Jones, Tristram Shandy, Great Expectations, Tess of the D’Urbervilles – even Harry Potter might be included.
For anyone interested in buildings, too, there are classic books. Most famous of all, because it influenced so many later architects in Britain and abroad, was ‘I quattro libri dell’architettura’ – the Four books of Architecture – by Palladio, first published in 1570. Another important work was ‘Vitruvius Britannicus’, edited by the architect Colen Campbell, which appeared in successive volumes from 1725 and contained containing engravings of English buildings by Inigo Jones and Sir Christopher Wren. In the 19th century no book was more influential than ‘Contrasts’ by Pugin, published in 1836, in which the great Gothic architect showed how much better Gothic buildings were than the poor structures of his own day.
Each age has had its own architectural polemicists, some with enduring influence, some that flared briefly and then vanished: who now reads Batty Langley or James Fergusson, John Claudius Loudon or even Ruskin? And of more recent writers on architecture, everyone knows for the work of Pevsner, whose name is now a synonym for the invaluable ‘Buildings of England’ series of county guides to architecture. But there’s another name that’s frequently on the lips of people interested in architecture – Alec Clifton-Taylor.
You may recall Clifton-Taylor’s three television series of the late 1970s and early 1980s – Six English Towns, Six More English Towns and Another Six English Towns. Though the titles would hardly win prizes for originality, the programmes themselves were gems, taking viewers on careful tours of the 18 towns, looking at the buildings, discussing styles and developments, and gently informing, educating and entertaining. The nearest he came to Ripon were his programmes on Richmond and Whitby, but anyone watching would soon be able to apply the lessons he taught to their own locality.
But it’s not for those that Clifton-Taylor is mostly remembered today. There is one book that, appearing in 1972, immediately established itself as a classic, and has remained the standard work of reference to today. It is his magisterial survey called ‘The Pattern of English Building’.
Perhaps the title doesn’t give away the substance. In more than 450 pages, Clifton-Taylor looks at how the great variety of building materials in England has affected the look of the buildings themselves – how styles vary between regions, how different stones create different buildings, how lack of stone led to timber structures, or to the development of a local brick industry.
It could have been a dry catalogue – one is almost tempted to say a Pevsner-like analysis – that was heavy on lists but light on real insight. But Clifton-Taylor’s style is relaxed, conversational and lightly informative – we learn a lot with ease, because he makes it so interesting. His wide-ranging introduction surveys the whole landscape, and looks at the problems caused when easy transport means we can get any materials to build anywhere; ‘Nowadays local building traditions are all to liable to be ignored . . . [there are] intrusions of red brick and tile into places where visually they can win no possible acceptance.’
His gripe over, he deals first with the many and varied building stones that form the underlying geology of England. His first love is limestone, which has produced some of the greatest of all English buildings, from Dorset and the Cotswolds, up through Stamford and Lincoln and into Yorkshire. Ripon is on the edge of this limestone belt, so we have limestone buildings in the city – both the Cathedral and St Mary Magdalen’s Chapel, for instance, use limestone.
Next come the sandstones – usually not quite as good for buildings because they weather less well. Nevertheless, there are great sandstone buildings, not least some of our cathedrals, from Worcester to Carlisle. Ripon has sandstones close by, too, and they appear in the city and the area around. Clifton-Taylor then looks at other stones – granite, slate and marble. There are no true marbles in this country, but in some places limestones have been transformed into a dark, hard, crystalline substance that can be polished. Most famous is Purbeck marble from Dorset, but we have marbles in the north – Frosterley marble, much used in Durham Cathedral, and, even nearer, the Nidderdale marbles that appear in Fountains Abbey.
Then comes brick. The Romans made thin bricks in England, but when they left the skill vanished for nearly 1000 years. Only in the 14th cenury did English buildings of brick start to appear. By the 15th century it was becoming a popular building material, especially in those eastern counties where stone was less available and experts from the continent, who had long built in brick, were more easily accessible. Holy Trinity Church in Hull is a prime example of 15th-century brick structure. And soon brick became widespread; again, Ripon was well placed to take advantage, with suitable clays nearby – Newby Hall is perhaps our best local example.
Wood comes next, looking especially how, in the Midlands, the west and south-west, timber-framed houses became more and more elaborate – though the frames were not always exposed but covered in lime plaster and whitewash. Even in Ripon many houses had timber frames, now mostly hidden in later fronts, except, for example, at the Wakeman’s House and the Old Court House.
In Ripon we don’t know much of chalk, cob and clunch, of tile-hanging or of pargeting, but Clifton Taylor covers these, as well as roof-tiles and thatch, stucco and lead, cast and wrought iron and even glass. Whatever you need to know about what English buildings are made of, Clifton-Taylor is sure to tell you. That’s why ‘The Pattern of English Building’ instantly became – and remains – a classic.
