It’s fascinating to see how experts can reconstruct the facial and other features of our remote forebears simply by looking at the bones. Programmes like ‘Prehistoric Autopsy’ and, some time ago, ‘Meet the Ancestors’ have used as one of their major attractions this ability to show how the people who lived on earth hundreds or thousands of years really looked.
In some ways it’s an easy win. Out of all those watching, only the very smallest handful of people will have any real idea as to whether the reconstructed face is really that of the person long since dead, with no photographic or other record of their looks with which to compare. We all say how very modern the person’s face is, and how, if dressed in modern clothes they would pass unnoticed in any high street today.
Great skill goes into these reconstructions; they are always fascinating, transforming simple bones into rounded people. Human tissue is essentially perishable; reconstruction is a little easier when it comes to less-perishable remains, the archaeological evidence that can be dug up from the ground.
Here’s another strand that television enjoys. No archaeology programme is these days complete without an artist’s impression of what the site might have looked like. They appear on, for example, ‘Time Team’, where, to let the viewer understand what they are seeing on the ground, 3-D buildings grow before our eyes, complete with roofs provided with chimneys billowing smoke or with soldiers patrolling the walls. Sometimes the programmes go further; the fascinating examination of the Ness of Brodgar excavation on Orkney had presenter Neil Oliver apparently walking though the buildings, even stooping to go through low doorways.
All this is, of course, based on detailed research and is, usually, fully approved by the archaeologists working on site. To the layman, of course, it is something we need to take on trust. Fascinating as it is to see excavations and hear the people on the ground talk of their work, it needs more imagination than most of us possess to see the structures they are dealing with as much more than a jumble of stones.
Basing a reconstruction on a large body of evidence, and not guessing at anything, as far as is possible, is of the essence of these programmes. They are rigorously researched and presented as honestly and straightforwardly as the television medium allows. But there is still debate about how accurate some of these graphic artists’ impressions really are. If we were to look again at the programmes in, say, 20 years’ time, we might find that archaeology and our understanding of the past have moved on so far as to make today’s reconstructions as laughable as Inigo Jones’ ‘reconstruction’ of Stonehenge as a Roman amphitheatre.
In the 19th century, too, reconstruction was all the rage. Church builders and their clients, fired with a revived enthusiasm for Gothic architecture, were keen to reconstruct our ancient buildings along the lines they originally had, sweeping away the ‘unauthentic’ accretions of later centuries and getting back to medieval purity. So a new breed of church restorers set to work, transforming the vast majority of our ancient churches and cathedrals from ramshackle, Georgianised ‘preaching boxes’ into liturgically-correct structures of pure Gothic architecture.
One of the chief restorers of the age was Gilbert Scott, who was called in to deal with Ripon Cathedral between 1862 and 1872. At Ripon his touch was relatively light; in other places he could be much more invasive. But always he looked for precedent for what he did. So, for example, he might change the style and shape of the windows in a church, but he would always claim to have found evidence that what he introduced had been there originally – a piece of tracery or evidence of a cill, for example. He said that if in a church ‘the earlier and later parts – the authentic and the spurious – are all alike decayed . . . I think we are then at liberty to exercise our best judgement on the subject, and if the original parts are found to be ‘precious’ and the later insertions to be ‘vile’, I think we should be quite right in giving perpetuity to one and in removing the other.’
This makes so many assumptions as to taste – what is precious and what is vile – that it is no wonder that a generation later William Morris was fulminating against Scott and his followers. In 1877 he set up the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings (SPAB) as a direct result on hearing that, as he wrote to the newspapers, ‘the minster of Tewkesbury is to be destroyed by Sir Gilbert Scott’. Scott was not alone – St Albans Abbey was one of the worst cases, reconstructed as it was by rich amateur architect Lord Grimthorpe.
SPAB’s influence was immediately felt, and has informed the work of architects ever since, insisting on
conservative repair and the retention of fabric, rather than reconstruction. It doesn’t always happen, even today; there are still cases where conjectural reconstructions take place, rather than sensible repair. But we are much more aware today, perhaps, that historic fabric is important in a building’s history. No doubt when Ripon Cathedral was restored there were people who thought with nostalgia about the way it had looked before. And now, of course, those Victorian interventions are of themselves of historical importance.
So we need to be wary of reconstructions, however much they may be of interest. A television graphic cannot harm; reconstruction of a building can, by removing parts of its real history for ever. That’s why we must be ever vigilant as we try to look after our historic structures.
