PUGIN AND THE GOTHIC REVIVAL

Why are churches Gothic? The answer is, of course, that they’re not – or not all of them, by any means. We only need to look at St Paul’s Cathedral or St Martin-in-the-Fields in London, or any number of churches built between about 1600 and 1800, to show that for many congregations the classical style was their choice.

But ask any child to draw a church today and they are much more likely to draw something that is meant to be Gothic – probably complete with tower and spire – than a classical box. And in one of those word-association games so beloved of psychiatrists, just to say the word ‘church’ will conjure up a picture in most people’s minds of a building with pointed windows and, yes, a tower and spire.

How did we come to this? Why do we equate Gothic with churches? Who was responsible for our way of looking at ecclesiastical architecture? The answer – for us as much as for many of his contemporaries, was Augustus Welby Northmore Pugin. Pugin was as much responsible for the revival of Gothic as Inigo Jones was influential in the propagation of the classical style 200 years earlier. And unlike Jones, Pugin was as much a writer and polemicist as an architect.

He nailed his architectural and religious colours to the mast in 1836, when he was just 24, with the publication of ‘Contrasts’, one of the most influential books in the 19th century. Its subtitle was ‘a parrallel [sic] between the architecture of the 15th and 19th centuries’ – which seems simple enough, though even from that you might expect the 19th to come off worse. And, of course, it does.

These days ‘Contrasts’ is known mainly through its illustrations – and very telling they are. Pugin takes a number of different types of buildings – town halls, market crosses, public conduits, houses and inns, as well, of course, as churches, to point out the meanness and lack of imagination of the 19th century examples as compared with their 15th century counterparts. So we are shown, side by side on one plate, the 15th-century Angel Inn in Grantham, with its Gothic windows, arched gateway and carved decoration, with the Angel Inn in Oxford, which occupies three unmatched Georgian boxes of no architectural merit.

When it comes to churches he is even more pointed. Not one to shrink from exaggeration by taking the worst of one and the best of the other, he contrasts All Souls Church in Langham Place (which these days stands next to Broadcasting House in London) with the great Gothic church of St Mary Redcliffe in Bristol. Redcliffe is all soaring spire and Gothic panels, with pinnacles and traceried windows; All Souls is a classical box with a circular, columned porch attached, crowned with a starved, needle-like spire.

Today, we admire the drawing and appreciate the cleverness of the way he was making his points. But to the 19th-century the book was an eye-opener, and not just in the plates. Pugin was a great one for invective in his prose. In the church buildings of the Middle Ages, he argues, ‘every portion of the sacred fabric bespeaks its origin; the very plan of the edifice is the emblem of human redemption.’ As for classical churches, ‘St Paul’s Cathedral, London, and many other buildings of the same class, are utter departures from Catholic architecture, and meagre imitations of Italian paganism.’

For Pugin, Gothic was the same as Christian – and English medieval Gothic was a reflection of the true English Catholic Church. As a Catholic convert, Pugin would be looked on with deep suspicion in the first half of the 19th century – and yet his message struck home. There were already some buildings in a sparse Gothic style – Holy Trinity in Ripon is one such, opened in 1828 – but it was Pugin who really got architects to think in true Gothic terms.

Sir Gilbert Scott, who restored Ripon Cathedral from 1862, wrote ‘Pugin’s articles excited me almost to fury’ – fury because he had so little understood what Gothic architecture really meant. ‘I was awakened from my slumbers by the thunder of Pugin’s writings. I well remember the enthusiasm to which one of them excited me, one night when travelling by railway, in the first years of their existence.’

Scott was not the only one. Over the next half century Gothic became for many the only style in which to build a new church. And, despite Pugin’s wish to reconvert England, it was the Church of England that took up the Gothic cause with most enthusiasm. Many of the Roman Catholics stuck with Renaissance forms for their churches, or, late in the century, used the Byzantine style as at Westminster Cathedral. There were exceptions – St Wilfrid’s in Ripon and its namesake in York are two in the Gothic style – and often, as in Ripon, make a nice contrast with classical-style chapels of the nonconformists nearby.

Pugin died young, at the age of just 40 in 1852. He exhausted himself both in his campaign for good, Christian Gothic architecture and by producing thousands of highly-detailed drawings for the new Houses of Parliament. He did not live to see the great triumph of his campaign, even if that triumph was more Anglican than Catholic.

And it all started with a book. It’s still worth reading the text of ‘Contrasts’ as well as looking at the plates. Pugin could certainly write with effect. We may not agree with his opinions – nor may we appreciate the results of his campaign. But we should certainly recognise his influence; the results are still around us and colour our thoughts.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.