A LIST IS NOT JUST FOR CHRISTMAS

You must have made your Christmas lists by now, surely. If you haven’t, you’re obviously a last-minute person! Children will, weeks ago, have written and posted their letters to Father Christmas with a list of those things they hope he will be able to deliver while they sleep between Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. You should certainly have already ticked off everyone on your Christmas card list!

And then there’s the list of what to buy for whom, and the lists for the mammoth food-shopping trip that seems to be inevitable if you have Christmas visitors. Then, if the supplements in magazines and newspapers are to be believed, we’re all busy, too, with making lists of where we’d like to go for our 2013 summer holidays.

List making is, it seems, a basic human trait. Some of the world’s earliest writing, Babylonian cuneiform, first emerged about 3,000 BC, but was not translated by modern scholars until the 19th century. The vast majority of the extant writing was not the exciting and turbulent history of the times, but lists – lists of taxes, of goods, of imports and exports, of household expenditure and of the movement of people. These, of course, have their own fascination – just as the Roman tablets unearthed at Vindolanda near Hadrian’s Wall, many of them lists, too, tell us a great deal about life at that time.

Lists govern all our lives. If we’re not on a list, you may miss out. We can’t vote if you’re not on the electoral list. We may not get benefits to which we are entitled if we are not on an official list. And, on a personal scale, those Christmas lists help us to ensure that nothing – and no-one – is forgotten.

There are lists for awards – whether it’s the recent rather long short-list for the BBC Sports Personality, or the Civic Society’s own list of those up for our Annual Awards, which we presented in October. In a few days’ time we shall be told of the great and the good whose achievements (or longevity, or popularity) have been deemed worthy of recognition in the Honours List. We can be sure that the BBC Sports Personality list and the Honours List will largely coincide . . .

For our work in the Civic Society we, too, have other lists to use. Much of the Society’s work is taken up with looking at the lists of planning applications in and around Ripon, to see what is proposed for our built heritage. Contrary to the belief in some reactionary minds, the Society is not here to say no to every development; on the contrary, we are keen to encourage good development – and modern style – as long as it’s in the right place and is carefully done.

And, of course, much of our response to planning applications concerns changes to listed buildings. The Listings system – which divides structures into three Grades, I, II* and II, depending on their architectural or historic importance – is a very useful tool, and one that helps to define how we look at our built environment.

Harrogate Borough Council (HBC) is about to begin consultation on another layer of lists, the local list. This will encompass buildings that are of local importance, but which may not merit – or perhaps not yet merit – inclusion in the national lists. They may be buildings that give character to a street, or which include well-loved features, the loss of which would be regrettable. The initial task, in which the Civic Society will be involved, will be to look at the scope of any such local list, to see how it works, and what protection it might give. This column called some time ago for local lists – it is good to see that HBC, spurred on by the new National Planning Policy Framework, is now grasping this particular nettle.

But we must beware lists, too. In 1948 Sir Stafford Cripps asked the National Trust to come up with a list – a list of the 100 most-important great houses in England. The idea was that such a list would be useful to the government at a time when country houses were being closed, sold or demolished at an alarming rate. If a house appeared on the ‘official’ list, the government could step in to save it.

As the National Trust’s houses’ guru James Lees-Milne wrote in his diary at the time. ‘A limitation of great houses, with contents, to 100 is going to cause trouble in the future. What is considered bad architecture and bad art today may be considered good tomorrow. Besides, how many experts will agree on what is best today?’ In other words, what we set down in a list of what we like today might store up difficulty for the future.

So our lists need to be flexible; tastes and opinions change, and our lists need to keep up with them. That may mean that our lists grow, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing, as long as it’s not a question of having so much listed that the listing itself becomes meaningless.

So as we tick off the items on our Christmas lists, remember that the presents we bought last year for our loved ones are probably not identical to those we bought last year. And even if the food list has a certain inevitability about it, there will probably be additions or deletions this year. In the same way, our lists of what is good in Ripon and the surrounding area will have many basic items on which all are agreed; and as we get into the local lists, we may surprise ourselves with what else we would like to add. But we must beware of making the compilation of a list an end in itself. It’s what happens after that that is important.

Ripon Civic Society wishes everyone a very happy Christmas!

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.