You may not know Mrs Cecil Frances Alexander, but you’re likely to know some of her work. Hers was the pen that wrote some of our most popular hymns, including ‘Once in royal David’s city’ and ‘There is a green hill far away’. She was the wife of a Northern Ireland clergyman who became Bishop of Derry (the ‘green hill’ of her hymn is said to have been just outside Derry’s city walls) and then Archbishop of Armagh.
What has Mrs Alexander got to do with the usual subject of this column, Ripon and its architecture? She came to mind because of another of her famous hymns, often sung at weddings – ‘All things bright and beautiful’. You may consider that opening line suitable for Ripon and its surroundings, of course, but it is a verse that’s always left out from that paean to nature that fits this week’s theme:
‘The rich man in his castle
The poor man at his gate;
God made them high and lowly
And ordered their estate.’
In our more egalitarian days Mrs Alexander’s words are considered (appropriately for an Irish writer!) beyond the pale. Even in her day there were people who found them theologically suspect, though many more would have agreed with her; Ripon workhouse and the many others around the country were there to deal with the poor – who were divided into the ‘deserving’ – those who were in poverty through no fault of their own, and whose poverty could be seen as God’s ordering – and the ‘undeserving’, who through idleness and fecklessness had made themselves poor and so were not to receive any sort of sympathy.
Meanwhile the ‘high’ – those with the wealth to indulge in choice – were able to live a good life, surrounded by servants and served by tradesmen who had to wait to be paid at the client’s whim. This is, of course, to ignore the large bulk of the population who were in the middle – neither high nor lowly; the shopkeepers, the local government workers, the railwaymen, for example, who really kept the whole system ticking over. Mrs Alexander had no word for them – they would not fit her rhyme-scheme, anyway.
But the evidence was all around her; she had only to look out from the walls of Derry to see it. Architecture – especially the architecture of our homes, has always reflected the social milieu in which we live and the strata of society to which, as Mrs Alexander would have said, we are ‘ordered’.
We don’t have any evidence in Ripon before medieval times of this social stratification, but we can be sure that the poor lived in hovels and the rich in larger (sometimes stone-built) houses. There may be evidence of a Saxon dwelling at Norton Conyers under the present house – which shows that, as always, the highest levels of society tended to remove themselves from the lower classes into more congenial countryside.
And it’s the homes of that class that have tended to survive form the distant past into the 21st century. If you had money you could build in stone, and stone buildings will last much better that mud huts or even timber buildings. So we have remarkable survivals like Markenfield Hall to show us how the upper classes of the Middle Ages lived. And even where timber does survive – notably in Ripon at the Wakeman’s House and at the Old Courthouse near the Cathedral – it is in buildings of some social status. Even the medieval timbers that hide away inside some of Ripon’s buildings that were later faced in brick were the homes of substantial families.
As the upper classes moved to the peripheries of the city (think of Newby Hall, Copt Hewick Hall, Hollin Hall, Sawley Hall . . .) it was the middle classes who could have city centre homes – many of those in the centre of Ripon are 18th century, like the premises in Westgate now occupied by solicitors Eccles Heddon, and the fine houses along Park Street. Lower down the scale there were modest cottages, such as the ones that survive on St Marygate and Allhallowgate.
By the 19th century industry had begun to creep in, and we find rows of terraced houses for the workers, such as around Lickley Street and Newby and Vyner Streets, and at Ure Bank Top. At the same time the wealthier middle classes were building themselves villas on the city’s edge. The Crescent and Palace Road have many examples, and there were moves southwards, along the road to Harrogate, too.
Twentieth-century expansion occupied much of the land to the south of the city; there was much building of semi-detached houses (definitely middle-class) and then of what today we call ‘social housing’, originally for renting. This brought a bit more equality into the social equation; an equality that we now strive to maintain by the requirement that all new developments have a percentage of ‘affordable’ houses.
Perhaps now we are less straightjacketed by notions of social class than were Mrs Alexander and her contemporaries. Or perhaps not. However subconsciously, we can still recognise, albeit in a rough-and-ready way, how the buildings around us – especially other people’s houses – provide an instant indicator of status. Of course, both time and fashion change; what was once a humble terraced house can become a fashionable bijou pied à terre, especially in property hotspots like London or Cambridge. But the general principle holds.
Mrs Alexander died just less than 120 years ago, in 1895, still secure in her own status as the wife of an Archbishop and sure of her place in the God-ordained class hierarchy. It would be interesting to know just how our own views on such matters will be seen 120 years from now. Will we be found to have been equally rigid in our views? And will our houses be as easily classified? Who knows?
