Names are important. When the names George Alexander Louis were announced for the new royal baby, the world, it seems, was pleased to hear the news. And Prince George of Cambridge will no doubt go on to shine in royal circles under that name, and under any subsequent titles that are bestowed upon him – perhaps a royal dukedom of his own upon his marriage, and, no doubt, the appointment as Prince of Wales when his father succeeds as king.
There has been some discussion about whether Prince George has – or needs – a surname. Most of the time, of course, he won’t need to sign anything but his first name. If he needs a second name, as his father and his Uncle Harry have as part of their military service, he could be George Cambridge. His grandfather, the Prince of Wales, it is said, used to sign himself into clubs as ‘Charlie Chester’ – perfectly properly, as one of his titles is the Earl of Chester. It seems that, officially, though, George’s surname, like all the family members descended from the Queen and the Duke of Edinburgh, is ‘Mountbatten-Windsor’.
But it’s not just with royalty that names are important. All of us are called something, and in general we are quite protective of our names; we insist that they are spelled correctly on forms and on our post, we get upset when we’re incorrectly addressed and it’s sometimes odd when we find that there’s someone else with our name, too. The cult television show ‘The Prisoner’ assigned numbers instead of names to the inhabitants of ‘The Village’ (which itself was unnamed). This was intended to seem disquieting and disorientating.
In our villages, towns and cities, too, we rely on the constancy of names. If a decree was to change the name of Ripon to, say, ‘Skelltown’, there would be uproar. We need names to stay the same. If change comes, it comes over the centuries; Ripon has evolved from Hrypis or Inhrypum in the 8th century, though Onhripun, Hryopan, Rypum, Ripum and Rippon to where we are today.
Street names also usually change little once they’re fixed. Kirkgate has been such for centuries, as has Westgate and the Skellgates. And it’s often possible to tell when streets were constructed by their names – King Edward Road, King George Road and Princess Royal Road suggest an inter-war origin. In other towns and cities you’ll find Gladstone Terraces (and sometimes, though less often, Disraeli Streets), named after prominent politicians, and others after historical events like Jubilee Gardens.
Then there are the battles that provide street names – Balaclava and Inkerman, for example – and sometimes whole districts, like Waterloo. Ripon, too, has at least one such, at Alma Gardens, after the Battle of the Alma in the Crimean War. Not far from it is Alma Bridge, which formerly led to the Alma pub. But the Alma is no longer the Alma – it’s been the Water Rat for some years. It’s a nice enough name, but it’s lost the historic link with the past by its change of name. Other Ripon pubs have also had changes of name. Some of the new names have become part of the city of today – like the One Eyed Rat, formerly the Lord Nelson. And, of course, pubs close all the time these days. But such changes are often upsetting when they happen.
It’s not just in Ripon that this goes on. In 1999 the argument about changes of pub names reached the House of Commons. MP Anne Winterton introduced the ‘Public House Names Bill’ to try to regulate the matter. Her Bill would have meant that pub owners would need to apply to the local planning authority to change the name of any pub – thus opening the matter to local democracy and allowing members of the public to make representations if they wished to comment on the loss of a traditional name. The Bill failed in its parliamentary journey, so there is currently nothing to prevent pub owners changing a name on a whim – or, as they would perhaps argue, in response to a carefully-researched marketing plan that provides a new and modern look that will refresh and reinvigorate formerly run-down premises.
Such, no doubt, will have been the argument over the latest of Ripon’ pubs to have lost its old name. The Black Bull is no more. A pub that has had that name for at least 160 years (and probably much longer) is now called – SO!. It may be part of a chain – but then, so is Wetherspoons, which at least kept the traditional name of the Unicorn when it undertook its refurbishment. But SO! (with its perky exclamation mark) is a trendy newcomer that has swept away one of the city’s landmarks.
There is no doubt that the refurbishment of the Black Bull was long overdue; it had become tatty and very run-down. The Civic Society looked carefully at the plans for the upgrade and supported them. What the Society did not support was the signage for the building – and urged the planning authority to try to prevent the change of name.
The owners of pubs, just like the owners of private houses, have the legal right to call them whatever they wish. We may not like our neighbours calling their house ‘Dunromin’ or ‘Ellinside’, but we can do little about it. In the absence of Anne Winterton’s legislation, it’s the same with pub names. But in many ways pubs, being at least semi-public buildings, are more important. The loss of an historic name cannot do other than diminish, in a small way, the links with the past, which, certainly in Ripon, are important. Calling a pub ‘SO!’ cannot seem other than a bow to a trendiness that in a year or two will seem passé.
