NORTHERN DESLOATION – OR SOUTHERN BIAS?

You will no doubt recognise this quotation: ‘There are large, uninhabited and desolate areas, certainly in parts of the North East, where there is plenty of room for fracking, well away from anybody’s residence, and where it could be conducted without any threat to the rural environment’.

There was, understandably, a degree of uproar, both in the House of Lords, where these words were spoken, and in the country at large – particularly in the North East of England. It did not help matters when the man who uttered these ill-judged sentiments, the former Minister for Energy David Howell, now Lord Howell of Guildford, tried to correct himself. Of course he didn’t mean the North East; certainly not. He meant the North West, particularly the Lancashire coast – where fracking could take place offshore.

Having doubled the offence, Lord Howell was forced to retract. He wanted fracking to take place, and its infrastructure erected, in ‘unloved places’. This probably was not much help in smoothing ruffled feathers. Certainly the North East’s daily newspaper, the Northern Echo, was not appeased. But as well as being critical, it published a supplement with plenty of photographs of beautiful landscapes in the area – a supplement which it sent to the noble Lord to underline the fatuity of his words.

Uninhabited and desolate. Two words that are rarely applicable to most of England and Wales – and even Scotland has few completely empty areas. In an effort to find such an uninhabited and desolate landscape, BBC Radio 4’s Sunday morning ‘Broadcasting House’ programme went to the Lake District. The presenter ended up at Wast Water with Eric Robson, fellow BBC presenter and president of the Wainwright Society. This was, conceded Robson, a largely uninhabited area, but he utterly rejected the idea that it was a wilderness.

It may seem odd that the BBC chose to look for desolation in one of the most scenic parts of the country, a national park that, according to the latest (2012) figures, receives 15.8 visitors each year – 6.3 million more than its nearest rival, the Yorkshire Dales National Park. Alfred Wainwright may have played some part in the popularity of the Lake District, though his own preference was for the fells to be completely empty.

In reality, England has no wilderness. Wherever you look, the landscape has been subject to human intervention. Areas bare of trees today are likely to have been well-wooded before the blades of axes – stone, bronze, iron, steel – got at them and denuded them. Upland pastures are grazed by at least semi-domesticated, hefted sheep. The heather moors, like the North York Moors (a national park that gets 7 million visits a year) are carefully managed as a habitat for game birds.

Ironically, some of the wildest places left in England are the very ones you might expect to be most damaged – the military training areas like parts of Northumberland, the Brecon Beacons and north Dartmoor – all, of course, national parks – as well as Salisbury Plain. Lack of public access means that animal and plant species maintain their diversity, and the military authorities have a special duty to protect them.

The International Union for Conservation of Nature has decreed that a national park should be an area of not less than 1,000 hectares that has ecosystems that have not been materially altered by human exploitation and occupation; where plant and animal species, geomorphological sites and habitats are of special scientific value; and where ‘visitors are allowed to enter, under special conditions, for inspirational, educative, cultural, and recreative purposes.’

None of Britain’s national parks can fulfill all these conditions. Internationally, protected areas are divided into six categories. The highest, Class 1, are strictly preserved nature reserves and proper wilderness areas – like Australia’s Great Victoria Desert. Then comes the ‘National Park’ category, a protected area managed mainly for ecosystem protection and recreation – the US’s Yellowstone is a good example here. Class 3 is ‘Natural Monuments’ – managed to conserve specific, unique natural features, and Class 4 is Habitat/Species Management Areas, kept to preserve specific species and to maintain habitats.

Its only when we get to Class 5 that we reach the British ‘national parks’ – classified as ‘protected landscape’. This is a landscape ‘managed mainly for landscape/seascape protection and recreation’. They were established after a report in 1945, and their purpose was redefined in 1995 as being ‘to conserve and enhance the natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage and to promote opportunities for the understanding and enjoyment of the special qualities of National Parks by the public’.

So national parks in this country are recognised for their scenery and for their value in recreation. They are not wilderness, and are certainly not desolate. Nor are they ‘unloved places’. Of course, Lord Howell was, we must assume, not thinking of national parks, but of the areas outside them. But it would be a challenge to find any area of the country entirely ‘unloved’. A landscape may not appeal to our own sense – we may dislike flat, fenland country, or bare, rugged hills – but you can be sure that wherever you go there will be people who do love their particular spot.

The current controversy over fracking, like that over the proposed potash mining on the North York Moors, is not insoluble, but certainly raises the hackles of those who want to protect their own landscapes. The people who have to make the final decisions have a hard task – one made no easier by ill-judged and careless comments made by members of a legislature hundreds of miles away.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.