IN PRAISE OF LIMESTONE

One of W H Auden’s most characteristic (and more obscure) poems is called ‘In Praise of Limestone’. In it he uses the image of limestone countryside – ‘rounded slopes / With their surface fragrance of thyme and, beneath, / A secret system of caves and conduits’ – as a metaphor for something not clearly defined.

Some critics say it’s about the civilisation of the Mediterranean (he wrote the poem in the late 1940s on Ischia in the Gulf of Naples). The central thought is that, like the underground streams of limestone country, the ideals of classical civilisation still run beneath the veneer of the modern day. No, say others; it’s about the human body and its equal importance to the human spirit.

This is all complicated stuff, and, as literary critics seldom agree, it’s probably best to leave them to it. But Auden’s use of limestone as a metaphor is interesting in itself – especially for anyone, like we in Ripon, who live so close to limestone country. Auden himself believed that Yorkshire had had some influence in his writing about limestone; he was surprised that the limestone scenery of Italy was so similar to that of ‘My Mutterland, the Pennines.’ This was pushing the facts a little – though he was born in York in 1907, his family moved to Birmingham in 1908, and he was educated in Surrey, Norfolk and Oxford.

Yet in limestone Auden recognised something important – that limestone country is a landscape of great beauty, of contrast and of hidden depths. From the point of view of this column, which mostly concentrates on buildings and the environment around them, limestone is one of the most important of the building stones in this country.

Limestone is a sedimentary rock, created by the depositing, over millennia, of the shells of sea creatures on the sea bed. This means that the resulting rocks are formed in layers of shells. These shells may be large enough to be still recognisable with the naked eye; others are microscopically small. The usefulness of the resulting limestone for building can be greatly affected by the shelliness of the rock.

The several varieties of limestone date from different geological periods. From the Cretaceous system (about 70 to 140 million years old) come not true limestones but chalk, which as a building material is of limited value, though there are examples in East Yorkshire. From the Jurassic, about 140 to 195 million years ago, we have what is perhaps the best type of limestone, the oolitic, along with its cousin the liassic. Before them came the magnesium limestones of the Permian system (c 225-280 million years ago), while even older are the final major group, the carboniferous limestones of about 280 to 345 million years.

Oolitic limestone is composed of millions of tiny egg-shaped shells (ooion is Greek for egg) and accepts both carving and weathering very well (Auden called it ‘a stone that responds’). The limestone belt, which stretches from Dorset and the Cotswolds, up through Stamford and Lincoln and into Yorkshire, has excellent deposits of oolitic limestone, including perhaps the most famous of the building stones, Portland, from the quarries in the Isle of Portland in Dorset.

It was the almost pure white Portland stone that Wren specified for St Paul’s Cathedral, and many London buildings (and hundreds elsewhere) are constructed from it, or at least faced with it. The oolitic limestone also appears as Bath stone and as Cotswold stone, both more yellow in colour than the Portland. Further north on the limestone belt there are more colour variations – creamy, even orange. All produce superb stone and, therefore, attractive local buildings.

The other great building stone is the magnesian limestone that runs close to Ripon; the city sits on the edge of the magnesian limestone belt that runs east of Leeds to the north of Ripon, and stretches to the millstone grit between Ripon and Pateley Bridge. In Ripon we are familiar with magnesian limestone; large parts of Ripon Cathedral are built of it, as is Markenfield Hall, for example. It was also used for York Minster (from quarries near Tadcaster) and as far east as Beverley Minster.

Further west, in the Malham area, are the carboniferous limestones that are typical of the Dales – all those drystone walls are characteristic, of course, as are the great Dales set-pieces like Malham Cove and Gordale Scar. These carboniferous limestones also provide the source material for the typical Dales barns and cottages, too, and the layers in which the stone was formed make it easy to split into large stone tiles for the roofs.

The characteristic of much limestone building – especially of the smaller, local buildings – is that the stone was quarried on the spot, or very nearby. Look at the Ordnance Survey’s Explorer maps of a limestone area and you’ll see plenty of ‘Quarry (dis)’ markings – and these are only a small percentage of the total that once existed. Only for the most prestigious buildings, like cathedrals and minsters, was stone transported any distance.

As Auden noted, limestone countryside is of great beauty – and that’s why the Yorkshire Dales is a National Park. Yet, go to its western edge, near Horton-in Ribblesdale, and you’ll see that the landscape is scarred with large, modern quarries. They are mostly quarrying for gritstone, used as a road dressing, and they have been doing so since before the national park was designated in 1954. There has been great debate whether they should be allowed to continue in the park, but their permissions still have some time to run.

All this is some distance from Auden’s metaphor of limestone country, but to many, like him, it is has a particular appeal: ‘ . . . when I try to imagine a faultless love / Or the life to come, what I hear is the murmur / Of underground streams, what I see is a limestone landscape.’

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.