MAKING NEW FROM OLD BUILDINGS

Something that may be considered remarkable happened last week; architects and the general public agreed about modern architecture.

The occasion was the award of the RIBA Stirling Prize for Architecture – one of the world’s most prestigious prizes for new architecture. It is given ‘to the architects of the building that has made the greatest contribution to the evolution of architecture over the past year’ – so it aims to show the direction of modern architecture. Previous winners have included the Gateshead Millennium Bridge, designed by architects Wilkinson Eyre and structural engineers Gifford; the Barajas Airport Terminal 4 in Madrid by the Richard Rogers Partnership; and MAXXI, the National Museum of 21st Century Art in Rome, by Zaha Hadid.

All the previous winning buildings have been uncompromisingly – and excitingly – modern. But this year’s winner is something different – and not only did it win the main Stirling Prize, it also was the favourite of voters on the BBC News website, suggesting that it captured the public’s imagination, too.

And why is it different? Astley Castle in Warwickshire is not really a new building at all. It has its origins in the 12th century and was largely complete in the 17th; it then went downhill until it was gutted by fire and left a ruin in 1978. It is listed Grade II*, but no use was found for it until the Landmark Trust took it over in 2005.

The Landmark Trust repairs interesting and architecturally-fascinating old buildings and gives them a new lease of life as holiday lets – The Ruin at Hackfall is one of its projects. But Astley Castle needed more than repair; in the state the Trust received it, it was uninhabitable. So it – and the planning authorities – took a bold step; it commissioned architects Witherford Watson Munn to put a new building within the old walls. The ruins have been stabilised, and the architects’ interventions have provided unmistakably modern interiors that still retain the features – and the atmosphere – of the past. The work was undertaken by York builders William Anelay, whose Director Charles Anelay has spoken to the Civic Society about the company’s conservation and restoration work. The result is a triumph. No wonder it won the Stirling Prize – or that its accommodation is already fully booked until 2015.

The success of Astley Castle raises a wider question, of course; how should we treat old buildings that can no longer be used for their original purpose? The listing system takes no account of usefulness; if a building is worthy of listing, it is (usually) listed. This column has argued that a listed building should be worthy of preservation for its own sake, irrespective of a current use; just because we cannot see what to do with it now is no argument for its demolition.

But, of course, if there is a way to find a use, it would be foolish to let too many rules stand in its way. This is why Astley Castle is important; it shows that taking a fresh look at an old building, and adapting it in a modern yet respectful way, can be the best way forward.

This is the approach taken nearer to home, at Hellifield Peel, west of Skipton – Ripon Civic Society members visited it in May 2011. This was a ruined medieval fortified tower and, thanks to the vision of its owner, architect Francis Shaw, is now a comfortable home and bed-and-breakfast establishment. Francis had the vision to see that this heap of stone could be transformed, and he persuaded the local planning authority – and English Heritage – that it could be done. Kevin McCloud, who featured it on ‘Grand Designs’, says it is among his favourite projects.

There are, of course, other examples we could quote – Bankside Power Station on the south bank of the River Thames, which has become Tate Modern, is one of the most recognizable. And there are a myriad adaptations of former churches and large houses to new uses – we have only to think of the Bishop’s Palace and chapel in Ripon, and the Victorian St Mary Magdalen’s Chapel on Magdalen’s Road, to see what can be done simply.

There are other possible candidates in Ripon, too, of course. Though the chapel in Coltsgate Hill is about to come partially back into use as offices, this is perhaps not a permanent, nor an ideal, solution. And we have yet to find a role for the Maltings at Ure Bank – here, if anywhere in Ripon, a radical solution, which respects the building but is not afraid to intervene in a contemporary way, needs to be found.

There are some buildings, though, that probably should not be touched. St Anne’s Chapel in High St Agnesgate is best left as an attractive ruin. And, on a larger scale, who would think of touching Fountains Abbey? These days, probably no one – and permission would not be forthcoming even if they tried. Yet in 1946 it was proposed to ‘restore’ at least part of the abbey; the owner, Clare Vyner, had been approached by members of the Roman Catholic Church, including the Duke of Norfolk and the Marchioness of Lothian, with an offer to buy the ruins and install Benedictine monks from Buckfast Abbey. The Chapel of the Nine Altars would have been restored, with altars where the monks would pray for the souls of people killed in the two world wars. Fountains Hall would have been taken over, but public access would have been maintained to the rest of the abbey and the estate.

Not surprisingly, this caused much dissention. Letters to newspapers were, on the whole, against the idea; it was even the subject of a leader in The Times, which, though it warned that its opponents ‘have to be on their guard against the romantic extravagance of cherishing ruins as such’, was rather anti than pro.

As we know, the proposal did not come to fruition; had it done so, our experience of Fountains Abbey would be rather different. Perhaps such interventions – whether for good or bad – are something to consider on your next visit to our neighbouring World Heritage Site.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.