A GOTHIC SETTING FOR HALLOWE’EN

Next Thursday is Halloween. What that means to you may, perhaps, depend on your susceptibility to modern marketing as much as to a recognition that it is the eve of All Saints Day – or All Hallows, as our medieval forebears used to say. That may lead you on to think about Allhallowgate, one of Ripon’s oldest streets and once the site of the long-vanished church of All Hallows.

In the pragmatic way of early Christianity had of aligning Christian festivals with pagan feasts celebrated during the year (think of the date of Christmas coinciding with the Roman feast of Saturnalia), Halloween and All Saints Day seem to have been deliberately linked to the pagan Celtic festival of Samhain. Originally a ‘harvest home’ celebration, it came to be associated with the world of the dead who needed to be appeased or they would return to life and cause havoc among the crops.

Once a time of prayer, Halloween is now firmly linked with ghosts and skeletons (and, for better or worse, the mild blackmail of ‘trick or treat’). It conveniently – and successfully – fills the supermarket shelves between the summer barbecues and the Christmas decorations. And it provides amusement for many.

Halloween is essentially a Gothic feast – that is, we automatically assume that these ghosts and spectres that we, half-jokingly, summon up, need to be seen in the context of Gothic ruins and pointed arches. Bram Stoker knew this very well when he set some of the seminal chapters of ‘Dracula’ among the gravestones of Whitby’s Gothic St Mary’s Church and in the shadow of the ruined Whitby Abbey. And that’s why if you are to visit Whitby at Halloween you’ll find the town – and especially the area around the Abbey – thronged with Goths in their often-elegant black attire and with their pale, ghost-like faces.

But the link between ghosts and Gothic goes back well beyond Stoker’s 1897 novel. You could even trace a link back to the 8th-century Anglo-Saxon poem ‘The Ruin’, in which the poet is moved by the ruins of an old civilisation: ‘Wondrous is this masonry shattered by the Fates; the battlements of giants are shattered and broken.’ But this is not a Gothic ruin; it is fairly clear that the poet is in fact lamenting the ruin of the Roman city of Bath.

Today we are unlikely to think of ghosts among Roman ruins – even the Roman ruins of this country (except for the Roman legionaries seen in the cellars of the Treasurer’s House in York, of course). So why are our ghosts so firmly housed in Gothic buildings?

One answer might lie in two particular periods of our history; first, the Black Death, which arrived in this country around 1348 and killed huge swathes of the population, leaving villages deserted and Gothic churches abandoned. The poem ‘Pricke of Conscience’ by Richard Rolle of Hampole near Doncaster tells of the terror the Black Death brought about – and his work is vividly illustrated in a stained glass window at All Saints Church, North Street, in York.

The other impetus to our linking ghosts and Gothic was the Dissolution of the Monasteries. This left the countryside littered with decaying Gothic buildings (Fountains Abbey being the supreme example, perhaps) that were seen by people as the ghosts the past – as Shakespeare noted in Sonnet 73 : ‘Bare ruined choirs, where late the sweet birds sang’. And, only a century after the monasteries were abandoned, many castles suffered the same fate as a result of the Civil War.

Generally, such ruins were either superstitiously avoided or used by the more adventurous (or the less imaginative) as convenient quarries – as did Stephen Proctor when he took the Fountains Abbey stones to build his fine new Fountains Hall at the start of the 17th century. But by the 18th century there was a new way of looking at Gothic ruins – as providing a short-cut to the Sublime. The Sublime was a philosophical stance that accepted ‘delight that is consistent with reason’, but wanted it ‘mingled with Horrours, and sometimes almost with despair’ or, as Joseph Addison put it, ‘an agreeable kind of horror.’

Gothic ruins were ideal for sending a pleasurable shiver down the spine. Robert Blair’s poem ‘The Grave’ is typical of the time: ‘The wind is up: hark how it howls! Methinks / Till now I never hear a sound so dreary. / Doors creak, and windows clap, and night’s foul bird, / Rook’d in the spire, screams loud the gloomy aisles.’ And novelists, too, got in on the act; the first Gothic Novel was Horace Walpole’s ‘The Castle of Otranto’; many others followed, like the still-shocking ‘The Monk’ by Matthew Lewis, the novels of Mrs Radcliffe (mocked in Jane Austen’s ‘Northanger Abbey’) and Mary Shelley’s ‘Frankenstein’.

This linking of ruins with a romantic and ghostly past has become deeply ingrained in our national psyche. The more sober citizens of 19th-century Britain may have thought themselves far too rational to be swayed by such matters, but they undoubtedly were; the number of ghost stories, a large proportion of them with a Gothic setting, that were written for the Victorian public shows they, too, were susceptible to the lure of safe horror. Coming into the 20th century, the masterly ghost stories of M R James often have a Gothic setting – and many films use Gothic backgrounds, too.

So when the little ghosts and ghouls arrive on your doorstop on the 31 October, you may like to reflect on the long and distinguished history that lies behind this tradition – even if it’s difficult to detect a literary, philosophical and religious thread behind the masks of commercialism.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.