THE YORKSHIRENESS OF YORKSHIRE ART

‘The Englishness of English Art’, a book that began as the Reith Lectures of 1955, has been mentioned in this column before. In the talks and the book, Nikolaus Pevsner draws out the features of art and architecture in England that are specifically English; the love of line over volume, the love of surface decoration, the way in which we compartmentalise our buildings rather than make open, flowing spaces, and, less easy to quantify, ‘reasonableness’, ‘conservatism’ and ‘compromise’.

Whether or not we accept this analysis (which seems, one might say, to be ‘reasonable’) it might raise another question – is there a specific ‘Yorkshireness of Yorkshire Art’? Or, more narrowly, in keeping with the purpose of these columns, is there a ‘Yorkshireness of Yorkshire Architecture’?

Finding characteristics of a county architecture is several degrees harder than deciding on Englishness. Looking at the whole country, it is perhaps easier to see trends and fashions than it is in a smaller area, and Yorkshire’s borders, however we may wish it otherwise, are not defended and sacrosanct but open to new people and new ideas. So, much of what Pevsner says about Englishness will equally apply to Yorkshire. Yet there are features of Yorkshire building that might at least get us part of the way towards our ‘Yorkshireness’

First, we must look at our geography. Poised as we are midway between the seat of power in the south and what for many centuries were the troublesome Scots, Yorkshire has had something of a border mentality, but one which absorbed influences from both directions and, looking north, from Scandinavia, too. So in early farmsteads, for example, we find there are plenty of links with Norse farming in the layout of the houses with attached shippons. The field barns that are so characteristic of the Dales are also, perhaps taken from early Scandinavian farming methods, though most are post-medieval.

The earliest Yorkshire buildings were, of course, built from whatever materials were to hand. There were in the past probably more timber buildings than we would suppose in a county that has some decent building stone. Many old buildings still retain a wooden structure at their heart, however altered they have been over the years. We see it exposed (as it never was in Yorkshire before the Victorians stripped off the covering of render) in, for example, the Wakeman’s House and the Old Court House.

There is plenty of limestone on Yorkshire, some better than others for building. Generally speaking, the Jurassic limestones lie to the east of Ripon and the Carboniferous to the west. Both can be used for building. Ripon itself sits on the eastern edge of a band of Permian limestone, not always ideal for buildings. For many people, though, limestone is the characteristic building material of North Yorkshire – say ‘Yorkshire’ to people from outside the country and they may well think of the Dales and its limestone buildings.

Given its size, there is much more to the county’s buildings: sandstone and millstone grit, which give their own character to parts of West Yorkshire; the glacial clays that provide both cobbles and clay for brick-making; and, in the south-east of the county, the chalk that can, with some difficulty, be used as a building material. This diversity means that we have no one building type in Yorkshire – though there are some shared characteristics of vernacular buildings, including the shallow pitch of roofs to hold stone slates, pantiles or, earlier, heather thatch, and the sliding ‘Yorkshire Lights’, the county’s own version of the sash window.

You may say that all this adds up to a pragmatic, no-nonsense Yorkshire approach to building – but that might be pushing matters a bit far. Another way of looking at how our buildings have developed may be to look at land ownership. After the Viking settlements that gave us some of our traditional styles as well as our place-names, we can look to the great tracts of land owned by the monasteries. Monastic buildings tended to follow a generally set and conservative pattern; interestingly, even though most orders had their origins abroad, they adopted English styles of design for their churches – square east ends instead of the French radiating chapels for example).

Throughout the Middle Ages there were incursions from the Scots to contend with – hence the number of Yorkshire castles and fortified manor houses like Markenfield Hall. Even Ripon Cathedral had a great defensive wall across its east end to deter the Scots; it was removed only in the 19th century.

After the monasteries were suppressed came the age of the large landowners (who sometimes took over medieval deer parks, too, as at Studley Royal). These great estates needed great houses at their heart. Some were intent on the having the latest style – Castle Howard is a good example – while others were content to build in much more conservative and northern styles – in Yorkshire there was some Dutch influence from our neighbours across the North Sea, as in the shaped gables at Norton Conyers.

Humbler buildings maintained their own vernacular style until the development of the railways, when it became possible to ship building materials of all types to all parts of the country. If there had been a certain Yorkshireness to our buildings it quickly became lost when Welsh slate could be married to Portland stone, Ruabon brick to Cornish granite. Local quarries were no longer economic (look at an Ordnance Survey map to see how many there once where, now marked ‘dis’). We have become homogenised – something that is encouraged by our blinkered planning system.

Is there a ‘Yorkshireness of Yorkshire Architecture’? Probably not as a systematic entity, though we can recognise elements as we go around the county. Should there be? That’s another question – what do you think?

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.