‘All the air a solemn stillness holds,’ wrote Thomas Gray in his ‘Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard’. Stillness of the air outside can be a good thing – in our current period of high winds we would welcome more of it – but still air inside a building is not something we really want.
It’s always a careful balance between sealing our houses so that there are no drafts and allowing the air within a room to change. We are, perhaps, more concerned these days with our comfort than were our forebears; they knew that to keep warm you wrapped up well, huddled by the fire and chose furniture that protects you from the drafts, like a winged armchair, a Knole settee, a high-backed settle or an Orcadian chair.
As life become more complicated, so ventilation became a science that attracted both scientists and charlatans. Careful measurements allowed the former to work out the optimum rate at which air in a room should be changed; and it allowed the latter to peddle their cranky solutions that were ‘guaranteed’ to achieve that rate.
The rate these days is reckoned to be a rate of change equal to three cubic feet of air every minute for every 100 square feet of floor area, plus 7.5 cubic feet a minute for each person. In residential properties the measure is how many times each hour the whole volume of the air in a house is changed. If your house is very well insulated, this may happen only once every two hours; with less insulation, maybe once or one-and-a-half times an hour.
In the 19th century there were many ways the change of air could be achieved, and a host of inventors rose to the challenge of finding the best. One of the most prominent found his niche when the Houses of Parliament burned down in October 1834. Earlier that year an Edinburgh scientist, Dr David Boswell Reid, had given a lecture on ventilation to the British Association, and a number of MPs were invited to his laboratory. They remembered his work when the fire destroyed most of the Palace of Westminster, and Reid was employed to advise on the ventilation of a temporary House of Commons that was erected.
Reid’s work there was very successful, and the temporary House was used for 15 years as the new Palace was built. Sir Benjamin Hawes, Chairman of the Committee on Acoustics and Ventilation, wrote to Reid in 1853 ‘You have facilitated public business and prolonged the lives of public men.’ Perhaps the praise went to his head, as when he was appointed as ventilation engineer to the new building his demands rapidly became unreasonable.
Reid was in conflict from the start with Sir Charles Barry, the architect of the new Palace. Reid tried to dictate to Barry how wide and how high the towers of the building should be to facilitate his ventilation system. Reid’s scheme involved drawing in air through the Victoria Tower and St Stephen’s Tower (now the Elizabeth Tower, or, more commonly, Big Ben) and passing it through the building to escape through the central air tower.
Barry was not prepared to sacrifice his towers in this way; at the height of his powers, Reid had planned that a third of the whole volume of the Palace would have been occupied by his ventilation system. At one point during the construction, the quarrel between Reid and Barry held up building work for four years. Eventually it was decided that Barry would provide ventilation for the House of Lords and Barry for the Commons, using two separate systems. Eventually, ‘Reid the Ventilator’ was dismissed. The fruits of his labours can still be seen in the Houses of Parliament – the 310-foot tall, ornate central tower was his ‘vitiated air’ escape flue.
For lesser buildings there were other ways of ventilation. One of the most popular methods for public buildings and schools was ‘Tobin’s Tubes’; they were invented in 1874 by Mr Tobin, who lived near Leeds, and were first used in Leeds Town Hall’s law courts. You may well have seen them – they usually consist of rectangular-section tubes that emerge into a room from an outside wall and curve upwards to about shoulder height. Victorian and Edwardian churches, schoolrooms and village halls have them. There are some excellent examples in the Masonic Hall in Water Skellgate in Ripon. Sometimes establishments were so proud of their Tobin’s Tubes that they are mentioned in advisements for ladies’ colleges and grand hotels.
The tubes draw in air from near ground level through airbricks, and allow it to pass over the heads of the users of the building, obviating drafts. They could be regulated by means of a rotating baffle plate near the tube’s mouth – the Masonic Hall examples have small hands to grasp to turn the plates. Yet despite their popularity, Tobin’s Tubes had their drawbacks. As one late Victorian writer explained, ‘as usually supplied and fixed they cause so much discomfort, that frequently they are kept closed or quickly removed.’ Another problem was that the airbricks became blocked. Sometimes canvas bags were introduced into the tubes instead of the baffle plates, but these needed frequent removal and cleaning.
Tobin’s Tubes, like Dr Reid’s ventilation system, were the technology of the day. Now we have air conditioning, which requires boxes containing rotating fans to be attached to the outside of buildings. These are often ugly and mar the look of a building, unless they are carefully hidden. Or we have large tubes that protrude – those at the rear of the Curzon cinema should be hidden by raising the brick wall beside them. Are any of these an improvement? Perhaps in airflow, though not necessarily in aesthetics. And, unlike the schemes of Ventilator Reid and Mr Tobin’s Tubes, they require power to work them. There may come a time when we return to simpler methods of ventilation – if not to the settle or the Orcadian chair.
