Congratulations to Skipton. It has come first in The Sunday Times’ ‘101 Best Places to Live in Britain’, not long after having its High Street named by something known as ‘The Academy of Urbanism’ as having the country’s best high street. Skipton is clearly doing something right.
It is interesting to note what came second in each of those awards. Skipton’s High Street pushed London’s Portobello Road in to second place. In the ‘101 Best Places’ the runner up was Newnham. Neither can be described as direct competitors to somewhere like Skipton – one a street in London, the other a suburb of Cambridge. Both are no doubt worthy of their status, but it does raise the question of the value of such comparisons.
There were more comparisons recently when the BBC’s Evan Davis presented two programmes on the North-South divide, tellingly called ‘Mind the Gap’. To northern viewers his standpoint may have seemed essentially biased; on the right, here ‘s London, the white-hatted hero, quick-firing and attracting all the best people to its cause, while, on the left, we have ‘The North’, its black-hatted opposite number, resentful that London produces a fifth of all wealth in the nation, full of the remnants of a once-great but now crumbling industrial past and without the nous to come together in a great north conurbation that stretches from Leeds to Liverpool.
Of course, Davis’ programmes were more subtle than this bare outline, but his general thrust was that London deserves it rank and that the North could try harder – though even then, he seemed to suggest, it would not make a lot of difference. London will continue to suck in money and talent from the rest of the nation, and the amount of taxes that goes to the capital will continue to be hugely out of kilter with resources given to the rest of the country.
Now we have the new Chairman of HS2 telling us that the construction of this vastly-expensive new rail line should be speeded up. Describing HS2 as ‘vital for the future of the country’, he said it could be ‘a catalyst for fundamental change’ and that hastening its construction will ‘deliver the benefits of HS2 – in terms of better services to the north – much sooner’. His solution is to extend the first phase beyond Birmingham to Crewe, with the argument that it can then tap into the network of the North West. The alternative argument that it could go to the North East is not made, it seems.
Note ‘better services to the North’. What does this mean? That lots of happy Londoners will be catching HS2 to the North to invest their vast wealth in our poverty-stricken (as they think) acres? That the imbalance between North and South in taxation spending will be magically levelled by this steel umbilical cord from the Mother Capital to the dependent child 200 miles or so up country? The proponents of HS2 would certainly have us believe that.
And there are, of course, many such proponents in the North as well as in the South. Read some of the regional newspapers and you would believe that ‘The North’ speaks with one voice, that of the businessmen in Leeds and Manchester who have convinced themselves that HS2 will help them to increase the size of business in the North.
But, as Evan Davis pointed out, London will continue to be the huge whirlpool into which the talents and money of the country will continue to sink. It may well be that HS2 does not bring ‘better services to the North’ – rather, that it gives even easier access to London, that ‘Great Wen’ which William Cobbett described as long ago as the 1820; a wen is a sebaceous cyst – in this case, a pathological swelling on the face of the nation. If people with businesses in the North can reach London even more quickly, what incentive is there for the Londoners to come here? ‘Let’s have a quick meeting in London’ will be even easier to say.
And if, by some chance, the Great Northern City, a linear metropolis bringing together Yorkshire and Lancashire, should happen (and given both current county and inter-city rivalries that seems unlikely), is there going to be funding equal to that proposed for HS2 to get this new super-city connected efficiently? Can we expect a CrossPennine project equal to London’s CrossRail? Not, it would appear, without a huge shift in political thinking – and most political thinking happens, of course, in London.
There are already moves, of course, to create the Leeds City Region. Harrogate is already signed up. York is considering it. There may, indeed, be benefits for settlements within that broad central swathe of the county; Skipton has benefitted from its position in the Aire Valley and its quick and easy links to both east and west – not least by rail.
For Ripon the benefits of HS2, of a Great Northern City and even of the Leeds City Region are much less obvious. Without a railway link the city is already hobbled and will find its ability to stride out is limited. Should we leave the future to be what it will, once some or all (or even none) of these grandiose proposals come to fruition? Or should Ripon be seeking a new role in this possible brave new world?
These are questions with which some are already grappling, despite sniping from the edges by those who will not properly engage in the debate. Yes, there are problems ahead, problems that HS2 and more urbanism will not solve. Yet they are not insoluble – we just need the will to overcome them. And then, perhaps, Ripon might feature in a list of ‘best places’; it’s something to aim for.
