AFTER A FIRE- RESTORE OR STRIKE OUT ANEW?

One of the greatest of Britain’s buildings was damaged by fire at the end of last week. Charles Rennie Mackintosh’s Glasgow School of Art was initially feared to be a write-off, with the fabric unsafe and the interiors totally destroyed. At the time of writing things look more hopeful; experts say that 90 per cent of the fabric and 70 per cent of the interiors are safe – but the greatest of its spaces, the library, has been assessed as being ‘irretrievably lost’.

Glasgow School of Art, designed by Mackintosh in 1897 and built in phases (with revised plans from 1906) until its full opening in 1909, is a remarkable building. It has elements of the Arts and Crafts movement in its honesty in the use of its materials, including hand-wrought ironwork and carefully-detailed interior woodwork (especially in the wonderful and now-destroyed library). There is something of the Art Nouveau, too, with sinuous curves taken from nature throughout. There are echoes from the past, with Tudor-like and Baroque details. And there is also a foretaste of what is to come in architectural style, with grid-like windows and exposed concrete.

As the ‘Buildings of Scotland’ volume on Glasgow, published in 1990, noted, it was ‘for many years revered as a pioneering work of the Modern Movement, but [is] now correctly appreciated as a brilliant eclectic design.’ Both externally and internally (its inside spaces constantly reveal new vistas, innovative ideas and clever spatial tricks) the School of Art is a masterpiece, and its total loss would have been a tragedy.

Now there is the problem of what to do with the building. It is a question faced by the owners and guardians of any structure of historic worth that is badly damaged, either by fire or by any other agency – and though the Westminster government has vowed to fund a restoration, estimated at up to £20 million, there are still very important decisions to be made. Is it best to restore what has been lost, so that it looks exactly as it was before and post-restoration visitors will not be able to tell what is new? Or should any restoration frankly acknowledge that some historic fabric or fittings have been irreparably lost and replace them with something new and innovative?

One of the most celebrated recent debates about restoration or modern replacement took place after the fire in 1989 at Uppark House in West Sussex. The house is in the care of the National Trust, and was badly damaged; the fire gutted the upper floors, which then collapsed on the lower storeys. There was immediate and, inevitably, heated debate about whether the lost interiors should be recreated or the opportunity taken to introduce new work. The same arguments rehearsed after other famous fires, at York Minster in 1984, at Hampton Court in 1986 and at Windsor Castle in 1992. In all these cases the decision was taken to restore – though in some of them, notably in Windsor Castle, the chance was taken to improve the look of the burned-out rooms and to introduce modern style and craftsmanship.

Such fires in important historic buildings in Britain are rare, thank goodness, and these decisions do not have to be taken too often. There were many more decisions to take – and more urgency to take them – in the aftermath of the last War, when cities had been devastated by bombing. Sometimes, as in restoring the bomb damage of iconic buildings like St Paul’s Cathedral, Buckingham Palace and York’s Guildhall, the decision was taken to restore to their former look. A slightly different decision was taken when the House of Commons was restored; instead of the great Pugin interior a less-gothic interior was provided by Sir Giles Gilbert Scott – the style was nicknamed ‘Neon-Gothic’.

When it came to restoring bombed city centres, there were contrasting attitudes in different countries. In cities like Dresden and Warsaw it was seen as a mark of pride to restore the historic centres to their pre-war look; in Britain war damage was seen, in the post-war ‘Brave New World’, as the opportunity to clear away the clutter of the past and to build new, modern cities for the future.

Nowhere illustrated the British attitude better than the centre of Coventry, where the medieval heart of the city had suffered badly. Much of the bombing (including that of the cathedral) took place in 1940. By 1941 there was already a plan in place for post-war rebuilding. By 1952 the plan had grown to encompass the whole of the city centre. Ignoring the medieval plan, the planners laid out a series of pedestrianised squares, some surrounded by two-level walkways. Pevsner in 1966 called it ‘Coventry’s justifiable pride’; we may see it as a rather dated experiment, but one which gave pointers to the future of our city centres, not least in the exclusion of traffic from the main shopping areas.

So what should happen to today’s damaged buildings, like the Glasgow School of Art? Should we restore like-for-like or introduce new, obviously-contemporary work? To men like William Morris the answer would have been obvious – no pastiche, but modern hand-craftsmanship should replace what has been lost. The argument used at Uppark was that replacement of what was lost enabled the National Trust to keep alive crafts that were in danger of disappearing. Both attitudes have their virtue and their drawbacks – and both rely on a traditional attitude to workmanship. The task that will face the Glasgow School of Art – long one of the leaders in modern design ideas – will be to find a 21st century answer to the vital question: restore or strike out anew?

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.