JOHN CARR, ARCHITECT OF THE NORTH

Unlike William Kent, the Bridlington-born architect who was the subject of last week’s column, this week’s subject worked to a large extent in his native county. He is John Carr, one of the ablest of the later 18th-century architects – and one of the most successful; he left a fortune of £150,000 at his death in 1807.

Carr came from Horbury in the West Riding, where he was born in 1723. The three generations before him, including his father Robert, were all masons, with Robert also acting as a building contractor and a designer of small architectural works including bridges. He was also one of the county surveyors for the West Riding, a position to which John succeeded him. John’s mother was Rose Lascelles, whom the Carr family believed (it seems wrongly) to be related to the aristocratic family who bought the Harewood estate in 1739; whatever the truth, it cannot have done Carr any harm, for one of the highlights of his later career was his design of Harewood House.

He seems to have been a precocious child who soon showed his skill in design. A story says that craftsmen working at Bretton Hall, now the site of the Yorkshire Sculpture Park, were unable to decide how to construct a new small building. Robert Carr said, ‘Let my lad try!’; John’s skilled solution was immediately adopted, to everyone’s satisfaction. Some years later he found a wife at Bretton; Sarah Hinchcliffe was a servant there. The couple had no children.

It must have been through his father’s contacts with the Yorkshire gentry that John Carr was able to make his way as an architect. Very early works were his interior designs for the now-demolished Kirby Hall at Little Ouseburn, jointly designed by Lord Burlington and Roger Morris. The Palladian style inspired Carr, and he became one of its greatest exponents, though his use of the style matured throughout his career. He was also influenced by Ripon-educated Sir William Chambers.

Soon, Carr’s reputation grew, and by the early 1750s he was established well enough to set up in practice in York, the North’s leading social centre. Here he designed town houses for the gentry (particularly for the Whig gentry, who gave him the bulk of his work throughout his career), as well as other public works. The most influential Whig, and one of the most important of his patrons, was Charles Watson-Wentworth of Wentworth Woodhouse, the Second Marquess of Rockingham and twice Prime Minister. Carr came to Rockingham’s attention with his design for a new stand at York’s Knavesmire racecourse – Rockingham was one of the top racehorse owners in the country.

At much the same time Carr was introduced to the Lascelles at Harewood, and commissioned to design their new house – his first great mansion. Among his later houses are Constable Burton, Denton Park near Ilkley and Basildon Park in Berkshire (for a Yorkshire-born client). His style subtly altered as the century went on; he was influenced by changes in landscape gardening, such as the ones championed by ‘Capability’ Brown, so he designed houses that were best admired not from the front, like Palladian buildings, but were to be viewed from all sides.

Carr did much work for the Marquess of Rockingham’s heir at Wentworth Woodhouse, the 4th Earl Fitzwilliam. As well as adding extra storeys to the wings, Carr was responsible for the 86-horse stables (the country’s largest at the time), the tall, free-standing Keppel’s Column on the estate fringe, and what some consider his masterpiece, the Rockingham Monument, an estate landmark paid for by the 4th Earl Fitzwilliam to commemorate the Marquess. Based on the Roman Tomb of the Julii at St Remy-en-Provence, it holds a life-size marble statue of the Marquess sculpted by Nollekens.

As well as his work for wealthy clients, Carr undertook a number of public works. Many bridges both in the West Riding and the North Riding (for which he became County Surveyor in 1772) were designed by him; they include those at Skipton-on-Swale, Bainbridge, Yarm and, further south, at Ferrybridge. He was also the architect of a number of York buildings, including the Assize Courts, still in use, and the County Lunatic Asylum, now Bootham Park Hospital – there are currently discussions about its future use.

Carr also designed estate housing for clients, including the Earl Fitzwilliam and, at Harewood, for the Lascelles. On a grander scale he designed The Crescent at Buxton for the Duke of Devonshire and the Town Hall at Newark, now part of the Royal Exchange shopping centre. He remodelled Raby Castle and Ribston Hall, among many other houses. One of his quirkiest buildings is on the Holderness coast, where he designed the triangular Grimston Garth, with its central hexagonal room and round corner turrets.

He also built himself a house in Skeldergate in York; he served on the city council and twice served as Lord Mayor of York, in 1770 and in 1785. There is a story about Carr at the visit of the Prince of Wales and the Duke of York to the city in 1789. As a leading citizen he was prominent in the welcoming party, and attended the royal brothers to the races. Between two races he was asked to stand between them and sing ‘Heart of Oak’ ‘with admirable spirit and sweetness’.

When Carr died on 22 February 1804 he was living at Askham Hall, his country estate just outside York. He was buried in Horbury church, built to his own design in memory of his father. The inscription on his memorial says, ‘So diligently did he serve Architecture that he is rightly counted among the most famous masters of this art, bringing honour and distinction to his country.’

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.