CELEBRATING BUTTERFIELD’S 200th BIRTHDAY

Over the summer this column looked at the work of a number of Yorkshire-born architects – but there’s another architect with a substantial body of work in the country who, though not born here, deserves mention – not least because the bi-centenary of his birth falls next Sunday.

You will probably know at least one work by William Butterfield, if only from a distance as you travel up or down the A1 near Ripon. It’s the church at Baldersby St James, whose square-profiled spire is a prominent feature of the landscape. And if you travel either through Baldersby St James or neighbouring Baldersby you’ll see more of Butterfield’s work – the school at the former, and cottages in both villages. The cottages are very characteristic of his work – brick, sometimes with diaper patterns on the brickwork, and tiled roofs with half-hips – tilted ends to the ridges.

William Butterfield was born on 7 September 1814 in the parish of St Clement Danes, the church on the Strand in London. Although his father, also William, a chemist and druggist, was a nonconformist, young William, their first son and second child, was baptised in the parish church. The family was related to the Wills family of Bristol; William’s uncles by marriage were W D and H O Wills, who gave their name to the famous tobacco company.

Nothing is known of William’s early life, but his father eventually apprenticed him to a builder in Pimlico. But young William had ambitions, and after two years he cancelled his indenture with the builder and studied architecture, first with E. L. Blackburne, and then, briefly, with William and Henry Inwood, Greek Revival architects who cannot have been in sympathy with his Gothic tastes. After a time spent working for Harvey Eginton in Worcester Butterfield set up his own architectural practice in London.

His first work, completed in 1843, was a Congregational chapel for his uncle W D Wills – a fact that William didn’t mention when he began his links with the Cambridge Camden Society. The Society, which later became the Ecclesiological Society, was founded by two Cambridge undergraduates to promote good Anglican church design based on the high-church principles of the Oxford Movement – so, decently ordered, with a full-length chancel and room for liturgical movement.

Butterfield positioned himself so that the Society acknowledged him as its chief architectural adviser – even though he had not, as yet, built anything much. Soon, however, with the Society’s help, commissions began to flow. His first work was rebuilding St Augustine’s Church, Canterbury; his first original commission was a church and parsonage at Coalpit Heath near Bristol, which was closely followed by a new church at Cautley, near Sedburgh.

In 1846 he began to work for Viscount Downe, who employed him to work at Baldersby. The Baldersby church is in many ways typical of Butterfield’s work. It is, perhaps, more suitable to a town than to a Yorkshire village, but it is an impressive monument to the architect’s talent. The tall spire, with its fish-scale decoration, has a close resemblance to the spire at Butterfield’s most famous church, All Saints, Margaret Street, in London, which was, and remains, one of the most famous High Anglican churches. Inside, Baldersby church is not as elaborately decorated as some of Butterfield’s churches, though it has some of his characteristic striped effects in the contrast of brick and stone banding. It also contains many Butterfield furnishings, including ironwork and simple chairs.

Butterfield’s schools and parsonages are usually easily recognised. As well as having hipped roofs like the cottages, they often have paired, square-topped windows and huge chimneys. His school at Snainton near Scarborough and the parsonage and school at Pollington, near Snaith, are typical. These and his cottages were influential; William Morris’s Red House, designed by Philip Webb, a friend of Butterfield’s, shows their influence.

Butterfield was long regarded as an architect of ugliness; some of his buildings, like the chapels at Keble College, Oxford, and Rugby School were considered to be unfortunate jokes. Certainly he was an uncompromising architect, and was often difficult with his clients. To one woman, who complained that the design of her house was not practical, he replied, ‘But does your chimney smoke?’ – that was the most important consideration for him.

Butterfield was adept at three-dimensional thinking, something not all architects can achieve. This can be seen on a small scale in the many different sorts of baptismal fonts that he designed for his churches. Some, like those at Baldersby and Margaret Street, are octagonal and stand on columns; others are pure geometry, like the almost- Art-Deco example at Latton near Swindon. Yet others are elaborate confections of receding arches and lavish marble decoration, as at Babbacombe near Torquay.

Most of Butterfield’s work can be seen in Britain, but there are examples elsewhere. He designed two cathedrals in Australia. One is in Adelaide, where his design was intended to be built of brick, but where the bishop insisted on stone; the finished building was completed by others after he resigned as architect. The other is St Paul’s Cathedral in Melbourne, where his plan was largely carried out. It is an impressive building (though small by the standards of most British cathedrals), with characteristic striped walls and flooring of encaustic tiles.

Butterfield never visited Australia. He lived most of his life in The Aldephi, off the Strand, or at his club, the Athenaeum. He never married, but was close to his elder sister and her family. Considered cantankerous by many (if he didn’t like work done in a stained glass workshop, he would break it with his umbrella), he could also be warm and compassionate with his close friends. He lived until 1900, having spent the last 14 years of his life in a house in Bedford Square. He is buried in Tottenham cemetery, but his real monument exists in the many, highly-individual buildings, that he has left us.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.