THE FUTURE OF HERITAGE

A snapshot of England’s most important at-risk buildings has been published by English Heritage. That statement itself can be rather contentious; what is important in one locality may not raise a flicker of interest in another. Risk, like beauty, is perhaps in the eye of the beholder.

But English Heritage’s ‘Heritage at Risk’ report for 2014 does try to be objective. It looks at those buildings that are listed Grade 1 and Grade II* and are, in the opinion of the compilers, giving cause for concern. England has a total of almost 375,000 listed buildings; 92 per cent of them – so about 345,000 of them – are Grade II listed. If your house has listed status it’s most likely to be Grade II; you will certainly know if its Grade II* or Grade I.

This means that less than a tenth of buildings are looked at by Heritage at Risk. This is true outside London; for some reason Grade II buildings in London are included; English Heritage justifies this imbalance by stating that ‘the state of the majority of our listed heritage, Grade II listed buildings, is still unknown. We are sharing our heritage-at-risk expertise with volunteers, owners and local authorities to tackle this by surveying Grade II buildings. With this information, a national picture can be built to see how many of these buildings are at risk and uncover the underlying causes.’

We may be justified in suggesting that this is too late – especially when English Heritage is due to be split into two, one part to run what’s called the ‘National Heritage Collection’ – that is, all those sites, from standing stones to country houses, via ruined abbeys and crumbling castles, to which your current English Heritage membership card will give you free entry; this will continue to be called ‘English Heritage’.

The other part, to be named ‘Historic England’ (should it not be ‘Historical England’?) will, according to the website message from English Heritage’s chairman, ‘continue to champion England’s historic environment, providing impartial advice to central government, local authorities, other heritage organisations and private owners. We will continue to co-ordinate the National Heritage Protection Plan, to manage the Heritage at Risk Register and to provide access to our expert research and extensive archives’.

It remains to be seen how this will work out; the government is giving £8.5 million to help the transition and to ensure the new English Heritage can begin to stand on its own feet; it is not clear how much of this will go to Historic England; its work is, perhaps, more important, though less easily understood by the public. It needs increased funding if it is to try to fill in the gaps left by the loss of many conservation officers from local authorities, never mind extending its reach to identify all those Grade II buildings at risk. We’ll not hold our breath.

In many ways, this year’s ‘Heritage at Risk’ Register makes grim reading. The English Heritage website tries to sound upbeat by announcing that ‘Excluding places of worship, there has been a reduction in the number of sites on the Register.’ Muted hurrahs! Yet the next sentence says, ‘But more than a third of buildings that were on the Register when it first began in 1999 are still there now.’ Both these sentences call for comment.

For the first time, places of worship in use are included (the rationale for omitting them when they are one of the largest collections of important buildings in England was never clear). There are 82 churches on the list (not all of them in use) and some are in a dire state. And they are only the tip of the ecclesiastical iceberg; there are many Grade II churches and chapels, and many unlisted ones, of which probably the majority is in trouble; parishes, dioceses and other authorities are frequently fighting a losing battle against steady decay or the threat of sudden collapse.

The second sentence from the English Heritage website – that more than a third of buildings have been on the list for the last 15 years – is equally worrying. Why have things not improved for these buildings? The answers are, of course, many: lack of identified owners, or owners who would rather see buildings fall down than spend money; local authorities reluctant to enforce repairs because it might cost them money; the lack of a local group who can mobilise support for the building and, perhaps, apply for funding to improve it; the sometimes-arcane rules of planning and of eligibility for grants. And do we really have – have we ever really had – a government that is interested in our built heritage?

A recent conference on the care of churches heard a suggestion that. to make ends meet, some should just be abandoned – the altars and organs the sold off, the roofs removed and the remains allowed to become attractive, foliage-bedecked ruins. This is, on the face of it, a feasible idea – after all, we all love ruins, especially those looked after with such meticulous care by English Heritage; but that’s just the point – ruined buildings need upkeep almost as much as ones in use or they soon begin to become dangerous eyesores.

Despite the ups and downs of the British economy, we are still a rich country – and proud of our inheritance of buildings of all ages. It’s all too easy for cuts to be made in heritage-related funds, as there are fewer people to complain than if cuts are made elsewhere (the same argument applies to the arts, of course). But if there is the will to keep our important buildings sound and cared for, we could afford it. It is up to us to make sure that the bodies like English Heritage and Historic England – as well as all levels of government, take our built heritage seriously.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.