At this time of the year English Heritage publishes its annual ‘Heritage Counts’ report about the historic environment. It has a different focus each year; this year it is looking particularly at ‘the value of heritage’.
How do you put a value on the influence of the past on the present? English Heritage’s way of looking at it is, first, to try to quantify ‘the impact of visiting historical sites on wellbeing’. They look at two things; the ‘feel-good factor’ historic properties give to visitors, and how the properties, such as those in the care of English Heritage, the National Trust, member properties of the Historic Houses Association and other attractions, are faring in terms of income from paying customers.
So the latest statistics tell us that there were 58.6 million visits to historic sites in England in 2013 – and the report points out that the population is 53.3 million. We learn that 73 per cent of adults visited at least one heritage site in the UK within the last 12 months; if the reports of the numbers going to see the ceramic poppies at the Tower of London this year are correct, we might expect an increase in these numbers for next year.
England has the fourth highest participation rate in Europe in relation to heritage sites – this seems to mean mostly visiting, though the report does point out that 15 per cent of the public donated money to the heritage sector – presumably over and above their entrance fees or annual memberships. There were around 445,000 people volunteering in the ‘heritage sector’ in 2014 as well, and such volunteers ‘report levels of mental health and wellbeing that are far higher than for the general population, or for the general volunteering population . . . 35 per cent of volunteers report an increase in self-esteem and confidence in their abilities’.
This seems more a subjective that a quantitative measure, though no less valid, perhaps. The ‘Heritage Counts 2014’ report also tells us (in as clumsy a sentence as you are likely to read this year) that ‘the amount of money which provides the same impact of visiting heritage overall is calculated as £1646 per person per year.’ This seems to mean that if you visit an historic property you’ll feel as well off as if you’d been given that amount of money – or as if you’d spent that amount enjoying yourself, perhaps. The report rather smugly points out that ‘Sport is worth £993 per person per year.’
The subjectivity continues: heritage projects in local communities ‘can help people to understand more about themselves and others who are different to (sic) them’ and that ‘people living in a historic area or building are not only more likely to know their neighbours but also to trust people that (sic) live in their area.’ If historic areas are regenerated they become ‘better places to engage in social activities such as visiting restaurants and going shopping.’
This all seems to be good news for people, like the citizens of Ripon, who live with old buildings all around, and have attractions like Fountains Abbey and Newby Hall on our doorstep; but all is not sweetness and light. ‘Heritage Counts 2014’ also sounds some warning bells.
Two factors are at work in the realm of planning that seem to be having a worrying effect. One is the changes in planning policy introduced in March 2012 by the coalition government to ‘streamline’ planning decisions; the other is the severe restriction on the amount of money available to local authorities whose role it is to care for the historic environment. To look at just one area, that of listed building consent (planning applications affecting listed buildings need a special planning consent process), the number of decisions fell last year by 2 per cent nationally; that may not seem much, but the fall would have been greater but for an unusually-active London property market; the fall outside London was considerably steeper.
One reason for this may be found in the decreasing ability of local authorities to cope with the applications reaching them. Nationally almost a third of people employed by local authorities to look after the historic environment (mainly conservation officers and planners) have been lost since 2006. Some local authorities have lost a greater percentage.
The report’s detailed breakdown of Harrogate’s Borough Council’s figures tells us that the authority has no ‘Local List’. A Local List, according to English Heritage, should ‘play an essential role in building and reinforcing a sense of local character and distinctiveness in the historic environment. Local Lists can be used to identify significant local heritage assets to support the development of Local Plans [and] will strengthen the role of local heritage assets as a material consideration in the planning process’. There is a strong case for Ripon having its own Local List of buildings that, if not meriting individual statutory listing, are important to the locality.
In the ‘Heritage Counts’ report there is also a box asking if the local authority has a ‘Heritage Champion’; HBC replies ‘Yes’. The authority certainly used to have one, but a search of its website doesn’t seem to recognise the role; none of the council’s elected members seems now to be so designated. The role of a Heritage Champion is, unsurprisingly, ‘to act as the elected representative championing the historic environment, working alongside local conservation staff’. If the role has been lost, along with many of those conservation officers, this is another blow to looking after our historic buildings.
There is, therefore, both good and bad news in ‘Heritage Counts 2014’; let us hope that when the 2015 report appears the bad news (particularly the numbers of local authority jobs) has been turned around – though, realistically, it seems unlikely.
