Here’s this week’s test: what do the following have in common? Jam, Jelling, Kuk, Lord Howe, Mir, Joggins, Omo, My Son. No idea?* Here’s an easier list: Timbuktu, Angkor, Great Wall of China, Statue of Liberty, Taj Mahal, Sydney Opera House, Stonehenge. Got it now? Then how about this group: Durham Castle and Cathedral, City of Bath, Tower of London, Palace of Westminster and Westminster Abbey?
If you said ‘World Heritage Sites’, give yourself a gold star. All those places listed (and they are all places, despite the attempt to mislead you) are on the list of World Heritage Sites compiled by the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO). As of this year, the list comprises 1007 designated sites in 161 countries.
There are three sorts of World Heritage Site: cultural sites, of which there are 779, natural sites (197) and, a late comer to the classifications, the 31 ‘mixed’ properties. In the United Kingdom list there are 28 World Heritage Sites; three of them are dependent territories: Henderson Island in the South Pacific and Gough and Inaccessible Islands in the South Atlantic are both natural designations, while ‘Historic Town of St George and Related Fortifications, Bermuda’ is a cultural site.
All the other UK sites are cultural, too, except for St Kilda, that remote island far off the west coast of Scotland, which is classified as a ‘mixed’ site. An interesting omission in the UK list is the Lake District. In 1986 the agency then charged with the care and conservation of the countryside in England and Wales, the Countryside Commission, submitted a long and detailed nomination to the Secretary of State for the Environment on the claims of the Lake District to be a mixed World Heritage Site – all applications have to go through the national government.
The Lake District’s claim – a sound one you may think – was based on its ‘outstanding international importance for its combination of the works of nature and man.’ So the nomination included information about the Lake District’s geology and scenic value, about its long history of habitation for at least 6,000 years, and its role in inspiring the universally-admired poets of the Romantic movement (Wordsworth in particular) and in developing the modern taste for wild landscape.
The designation document also pointed out that it was in the Lake District that the idea of national parks – a national designation akin to that of World Heritage Site – was first articulated by Wordsworth, who wrote that the area should be considered ‘a sort of national property, in which every man has a right and interest.’ But in 1986 there was no ‘mixed’ designation for World Heritage Sites, and the Lake District was a test case to see if there was a place for such sites. The nomination failed; it was seen to fall between the two stools of ‘natural’ and ‘cultural’ sites, and the Lake District is still not a World Heritage Site. And why is York not a designated site, either?
So what makes a site worthy of the designation? Any site included must be of ‘outstanding universal value’; to help assess that, there are ten criteria for the cultural and natural classes – with mixed being, obviously, a mix of the two. The criteria include the need to: represent a masterpiece of human creative genius; exhibit an important interchange of human values; bear a unique or at least exceptional testimony to a cultural tradition or to a civilization or be an outstanding example of a type of building, architectural or technological ensemble or landscape.
Among other criteria are: to be directly or tangibly associated with events or living traditions, with ideas, or with beliefs, with artistic and literary works of outstanding universal significance; to contain superlative natural phenomena or areas of exceptional natural beauty and to contain the most important and significant natural habitats for in-situ conservation of biological diversity.
Hand in hand with designation goes a long list of requirements to care for the World Heritage Site – and it was to help meet those requirements that a meeting took place last week at our own World Heritage Site, officially designated as ‘Studley Royal Park including the Ruins of Fountains Abbey’ – this title recognising that the site is a culmination of 18th-century landscape that culminates in a majestic ruin, rather than a great ruin with a garden tacked on.
Last week’s meeting, in Fountains Hall (part of the designated site), was for local and regional ‘stakeholders’ to hear about the draft plan to manage the site from 2015 to 2021 – all World Heritage Sites need such plans. As the message from the ‘World Heritage Site Coordinator and Conservation Manager at Fountains Abbey and Studley Royal’ in the summary document for the plan notes, ‘It’s our role to ensure that this exceptional piece of landscape is looked after, so that future generations may also experience this inspirational place.’
The site is designated for its combination of landscape and monastic history – and it also has significance for wildlife conservation. The draft plan sets out how the National Trust’s management team, working with a wide range of ‘stakeholders’, will ensure that the site is protected, monitored, enhanced and opened for greater public understanding and education.
It was suggested at the meeting that the document perhaps needed to be more outward looking, linking with other sites around the world and, closer to home, having more interaction with the local community – not least in encouraging the thousands of visitors the site attracts each year to come into Ripon, too. These comments will be taken on board as the final version of the plan is put together; you can download the full plan and make comments at www.nationaltrust.org.uk/fountainsabbeywhs or complete a comment card if you visit; the National Trust be glad to have your views.
*Jam is an archaeological site in Afghanistan, Jelling a Viking site in Denmark, Kuk an early agricultural site in Papua New Guinea, Lord Howe a group of Australian islands, Mir is a castle in Belarus, Joggins are fossil cliffs in Canada, Omo is a prehistoric site in Ethiopia and My Son a complex of Hundu temples in Vietnam.
