‘Something there is that doesn’t love a wall’, wrote Robert Frost. He meant that walls need constant repair, that there are always forces of nature that try to overturn them; but his final message is that walls are important – that they ‘make good neighbours’ – though we know that, as in Berlin, Israel and Northern Ireland, they can be brutal and divisive.
Such philosophical thoughts were probably far from the youth with the spray can who decorated the concrete wall alongside Bedale Harbour with the message ‘This wall is boring’. But he (or she) had a point to make. It isn’t a wall of much intrinsic interest. The cement render is discoloured and cracked, it blocks any view and is certainly not an object of beauty. And yet, just by decorating the wall with red paint and a (thankfully un-vulgar) message, the graffiti artist has made the wall less boring.
Making walls less boring has been one of the preoccupations of architects and builders since early times. Sometimes interest comes by association – think of the walls of St Wilfrid’s crypt in Ripon Cathedral, where they are covered with a render that is as hard today as it was in the 7th century. These walls are not, perhaps, in themselves fascinating, but their age and historical associations give them a special interest.
Even before Wilfrid’s time, the Romans knew a thing or two about making walls interesting. One of the most interesting Roman survivals in Britain is to be found in York’s Museum Gardens. The Multangular Tower is the only-remaining example of what was once a string of towers around the Roman Walls of York. The top section, built of limestone, was added in the 13th century, but the base survives from the late 3rd century. This was military architecture, and, as we know from the surviving architecture of the First and Second World Wars, the military and aesthetic taste rarely go hand-in-hand.
Yet when the Romans built their York towers they did something interesting; at intervals up the limestone blocks with which they faced the rubble walls they inserted red bands, made up of five courses of thin tiles. There was no structural reason for doing this; it was to link the appearance of the tower and its adjoining walls with the very famous walls of Constantinople, which use the same type of banding. Perhaps an extra incentive was that Constantine was proclaimed Emperor in York. And nearly a millennium after the Multangular Tower, King Edward I used the same technique of inserting a red layer into his walls of Caernarfon Castle, again to emphasise the link with the great defences of Constantinople.
How else can walls be made less boring? In the early Middle Ages walls were painted, either with figures or, more often, with patterns, but soon it was realised that the wall surface itself could be made interesting with mouldings and tracery patterns. Look at the north wall of the eastern arm of Ripon Cathedral, where blank arches, attached columns and (later) double tracery are all used to vary the wall.
If you’re not in stone country, you can do the same with wood; The Feathers Hotel in Ludlow, Shropshire, is a prime example, where the simple wooden frame of the building is decorated with quatrefoils that gave the whole building a festive air. These were always meant to be exposed, unlike some other buildings, including Ripon’s Wakeman’s House, whose beams were meant to be clothed in render, not exposed as the Victorians made them.
It’s not always necessary to go to such lengths to decorate a wall; sometimes the materials themselves and how they are used can provide the interest. A well-laid brick wall in an interesting bond can be a thing of great beauty, or, for your garden, you can make the wall undulate to provide more exposure to the sun or more shelter – these are the so-called ‘crinkle-crankle’ walls. Even the humblest stone wall can be attractive – near the former College in Ripon is a stone wall that is largely constructed from rounded river cobbles, of a wide variety of colours, strengthened by limestone blocks and capped with later shaped stones of millstone grit.
Materials can be used decoratively; in the Home Counties there was a tradition of hanging tiles in decorative patterns on walls – a style that was exported in the late 19th century to the whole of the country; an example is the lodge to Ripon Cemetery. At Lichfield in Staffordshire a potentially-boring wall is enlivened with a portrait of the city’s most famous son, Dr Samuel Johnson, made entirely of different coloured bricks. And tiles, too, could be used to carry pictures – there is a frieze of tiles showing the trades of Birmingham around the Aston Webb buildings at the University of Birmingham, for example.
More recently, attempts (somewhat half-hearted, often) to enliven walls have been made – bricks stick out from a wall’s surface (as on Moss’s Arcade in Ripon) or pre-cast concrete is given ridges, supposedly to encourage the play of light across the surface. New brick buildings are given string-courses of a different shade of brick – a faint echo of the Constantinople walls. These usually seem unconvincing and nugatory – more thought is needed to make them articulate a wall properly.
The Bedale graffiti-sprayer perhaps unconsciously hit on a truth that we should all take to heart – that it is really not necessary that a wall should be boring. Perhaps we should aim higher – to what Shakespeare in ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’ called a ‘sweet and lovely wall’, a ‘courteous wall’ and even ‘the wittiest partition’; then there would be no need to adorn our walls with critical slogans.
