18th-CENTURY ARCHITECTURAL DNA

The strands of DNA that were traced in last week’s column took us as far as the death of Charles II in 1660. This was the age in architecture of Christopher Wren and the earlier works of Vanbrugh and Hawksmoor. Now political matters began to have some influence on architecture. When Charles’s successor James II was pushed off the throne because of, among other things, his Catholic faith, in came his Protestant daughter Mary and her husband William of Orange.

With them came the influence of the Dutch style of architecture – urbane brick structures with large windows and, often, generous roofs with domed lanterns. This was the style practised by architects like Hugh May and Roger Pratt – names perhaps little known today, but once influential. The Dutch style permeated widely, from Wren’s massive additions to Hampton Court Palace for William and Mary to tiny buildings such as the Dutch pavilion at the end of the Dutch-style canal at the garden at Westbury in Gloucestershire, now in the care of the National Trust.

The Baroque still continued to make its influence felt as the 17th century turned into the 18th. Vanbrugh’s great buildings, like Castle Howard and Blenheim Palace, were designed at this time. After William III’s death the crown passed to Queen Anne, and then to the House of Hanover. But there were, throughout these decades, supporters of the exiled James II and his successors. In an odd way, Jacobite sympathies began to be associated with the Baroque style; so there was a need for a new style that could be associated with the new royal house and its supporters.

As so often in the complex DNA of architecture, a ‘new style’ meant a revived style. This time it was the architecture of Inigo Jones, and through him of Palladio, that became popular. In some ways this was odd; Jones had worked for James I and Charles I, both Stewart Kings, and here was their architectural style being appropriated for the opposition. As with all these matters, it was never quite so straightforward, but there was certainly an identification between the Palladian style and the supporters of the Hanoverians – the Whigs – while the other side – the Tories – favoured something more elaborate.

Pushing forward the claims of Palladianism was Lord Burlington, Yorkshire landowner and amateur architect, whose own Assembly Rooms in York show how rich the Palladian style could be. He was the patron of another Yorkshireman, William Kent, whose interior style was if anything even richer. But for Burlington and Kent it was the order and regularity, the adherence to ‘just and noble rules’, that counted, and that mirrored an ordered society.
Eventually even the Tories adopted the Palladian style, but they also had a useful alternative, the Greek style that was popularised by James ‘Athenian’ Stuart in the mid-18th-century. Greek-style houses began appearing in the countryside from the 1780s.

But there was another strand of architectural DNA that was waiting its turn to re-emerge. And the wars and revolutions at the end of the 18th century – the American War of Independence, the French Revolution and the subsequent wars with France – fuelled that revival. This was the Gothic, seen as a patriotic British style that could be exploited to rally the nation. This trend started mid-century; the trendsetter was author Horace Walpole, whose Gothic-style mansion, Strawberry Hill at Twickenham, was begun in 1749. Two years later Frederick Prince of Wales died; he, too had wanted to look back to British history for inspiration. ‘Rule Britannia’ was written as part of a masque he commissioned on the exploits of King Alfred.

Some architects adopted more than one style, and one of the best exponents of the Palladian, Greek and Gothic styles was James Wyatt, who we know as the architect of Ripon’s classical-style Town Hall, but was also the designer of the great Gothic house of Fonthill in Wiltshire (though as the foundations were skimped, it fell down) and, towards the end of the 18th century he began rebuilding Windsor Castle in the Gothic style for Frederick’s son, King George III. George wrote, ‘I never thought I should have adopted Gothic instead of Grecian architecture, but the bad taste of the last forty years has so entirely corrupted the professors of the latter, I have taken to the former from thinking Wyatt perfect in that style’.

At the start of the 19th century came in one of those odd infusions of DNA that are always valuable in preventing too much ‘in-breeding’; there was a brief vogue for the Egyptian style, stimulated particularly by Napoleon’s invasion of Egypt in 1798; the book he sponsored about the archaeology and architecture of the country, by Baron Denon, was a best-seller in England as well as in France. This resulted in some British pyramids and in a number of Egyptian-style buildings, including the extraordinary Temple Mills at Holbeck in Leeds. The Egyptian style’s longer-lasting effects were perhaps its emphasis on solidity and clearness of line – factors that became important almost a century later.

As architecture moved into the 19th century, therefore, there was a profusion of styles that the British had tried out for their buildings, and hopes were expressed that, inspired by the Industrial Revolution, a new architecture that mirrored the new times might be achieved. There were some indications that it might; the mills that sprang up in the industrial towns of the north, while not in themselves always attractive, were an expression of utilitarian need and were pared down to the essentials.

But, as the evidence around us points out, that’s not quite the direction the 19th-century architects took. For much of the century the opposite happened, and the DNA of British architecture seemed to get hopelessly confused. In next week‘s column we’ll look at what this meant, and how it was sorted out – if indeed we can claim that it was.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.