Mozart’s ‘Requiem’. ‘The Mystery of Edwin Drood’. ‘Lulu’. Orson Welles’ ‘Don Quixote’. Thomas Aquinas’ ‘Summa Theologica’. ‘The Faerie Queen’. ‘Turandot’. The crossing of Ripon Cathedral.
What is this list? We could add Schubert’s 8th symphony, Bach’s ‘Art of Fugue’, Michelangelo’s ‘Slaves’, Elgar’s 3rd Symphony, Jimi Hendrix’s ‘First Rays of the New Rising Sun’. You’ve probably worked out the link; they are all unfinished works.
History, of course, is littered with things that are unfinished, from the proverbial ‘a woman’s work’, through children’s homework to the fight against climate change (though that usual example of a never-ending task, the painting of the Forth Bridge, can no longer be used, thanks to modern, long-lasting paints and new techniques; the Forth Bridge is now, officially, painted).
In architecture, too, there are many examples of things left unfinished – some more so than others. We have a very obvious example in Ripon, where the crossing of the Cathedral – the space under the central tower – offers us the odd spectacle of two different types of arches, round ones on the west and north sides, pointed ones on the east and south sides. The reason for this discrepancy is that in 1450 the south-east corner of the central tower collapsed (it is said because of an earthquake). Some viewed this as, literally, a god-send, as they could now rebuild their semi-ruinous cathedral in the new, fashionable, Perpendicular style – and add aisles to the nave at the same time.
That was fine; money was found, and building began with great enthusiasm. The authorities began to enclose the crossing pillars – Norman work, in sandstone – with new limestone columns with deep mouldings; very modern and elegant. Work was completed on the eastern and southern sides of the crossing, with soaring new pointed arches. And the southern side of the western arch received its new column, enclosing the original – and then work stopped, probably around 1500.
It’s not entirely clear why that should have happened – it may be that the money, or the enthusiasm, ran out; perhaps there were arguments among the clergy and laity. Perhaps the one person who had pushed the project forward suddenly died. Whatever happened, it left the crossing’s western-facing arch in its characteristic lopsided state.
We should, perhaps, be thankful that Gilbert Scott left this oddity alone in his restoration of 1862 -1872. In his report on the state of the cathedral’s fabric before he started work he wrote, ‘The crossing was and is a curious union of 12th and 15th century work, two sides of each date. It had given way from this strange union, the older work falling away from the later. It was in a dangerous state.’ His solution was to insert two big girders to hold it together; but he might have suggested rebuilding the whole thing.
There was something in the cathedral, however, that Scott did finish, something that had been contemplated by the 15th century reconstructors of the nave but never completed – the stone vaults on the nave aisles. Scott could tell that stone vaults were intended, so he had his workmen provide them. The work was done so well that 99 out of 100 visitors – including some expert architectural historians – have been fooled into thinking them genuine medieval work.
Before we leave Ripon and look at a few other unfinished works, spare a glance, next time you visit Morrison’s store, at the odd little section of road that juts towards the field as you bend right, round the filling station. This is certainly unfinished work – and it’s there to prove that, in accordance with planning law, work had to begin on the site of a new development on the field beyond within five years of planning permission being granted, or the permission would lapse. We still await the development; meanwhile the road goes nowhere.
Some plans do, of course, take a long time to come to fruition. Barcelona’s Sagrada Familia basilica is a case in point; it was started in 1882 – Antoni Gaudi took over the following year – and is still unfinished. Other ecclesiastical projects that were held up – and indeed had long periods of inactivity – include King’s College Chapel in Cambridge, where the two building phases are easily distinguished by a change in stone.
At Westminster Abbey the construction of a new nave stopped in 1272 and wasn’t continued until more than a century later. The Abbey’s famous western towers weren’t added until the mid-18th century, to designs by Nicholas Hawksmoor. And the western towers of Cologne Cathedral didn’t go up until the mid-19th century – though they were built using the surviving medieval plans.
Liverpool’s Roman Catholic Cathedral, now familiar for its circular, wigwam-like structure, was also an unfinished work – in fact, a lost masterpiece. In 1933 work began to a design by Sir Edwin Lutyens for a cathedral so huge it would have been the second largest in the world. The crypt was built (you may have seen it in a recent ‘Antiques Roadshow’) but it was the wrong time; war intervened and the plan was abandoned. Sir Frederick Gibberd’s modern structure was plonked on top of Lutyens’ crypt, instead.
One oddity in Yorkshire that is definitely unfinished is the ‘seaside’ (or more accurately ‘clifftop’) resort of Ravenscar. In the late 19th century a visionary group decided to make this windy place, on the Whitby to Scarborough railway line, into ‘the most bracing health resort on the East Coast’. They overlooked the fact that, unlike Scarborough’s accessible, sandy beaches, Ravenscar’s coast is unrelievedly rocky. Nevertheless a grid of roads and sewers was laid and some houses were built. Predictably, the scheme flopped and the company was declared bankrupt in 1911. You can still trace the outline of the streets and see a single block of buildings.
Unfinished Ravenscar is a fascinating place – just as Ripon’s lopsided arches provide a talking point to visitors, and the building of the Sagrada Familia attracts tourists. So perhaps after all, there is something to be said for not quite getting to the . . .
