‘Amusing, awful, artificial’. What would you think if you heard a building being described in these terms? What would you expect to see? Would it be a large and imposing edifice, or a small and quirky frippery of a structure, with not much substance or architectural merit? Can you, perhaps, guess which building was being described?
The architectural critic who came out with these three words, which to us seem so dismissive, was King James II. And, far from being censorious, he was praising the building – a building that was then, as it is now, one of the most famous in Britain. He was talking about St Paul’s Cathedral. He meant that it was pleasing to the eye, it inspired feelings of awe, and that it was a work of artifice – a wonderful example of the ingenuity of human beings.
What was it particularly about St Paul’s that he admired? We don’t know for sure, but we do know that it wasn’t the dome, for although Sir Christopher Wren’s plans had always included a dome, and one was shown on the Great Model that he had had made, what we see today had not been started by the time James II fled the country at the Glorious Revolution. But once it went up, the dome was widely admired – and imitated.
It was the first major dome in England, but it followed in a long line of others in western and eastern Europe. The Romans knew how to construct domes – the Pantheon, built in Rome by Marcus Aurelius in 27 BC, is the most impressive to survive. Like most early domes, it was built over a circular structure; this made its construction easier, of course. Elsewhere, the Romans sometimes used several small saucer domes – in other words, not complete hemispheres but curved shapes like, as you would expect, our modern saucers; a row of them could easily cover a small rectangular building.
But what if you wanted a large building, and one that was square rather than round? The problem was how to square the circle where the dome met the walls. There were conflicting forces of weight and gravity that had to be overcome before you could successfully marry the two. The solution came in 6th-century Constantinople, where the dome of the great church of Hagia Sophia, more than 100 feet across, is supported on four curved triangles, called ‘pendetives’, which transfer the weight from the circle of the dome to the square at the heart of the building.
The Hagia Sophia dome was not exceeded in size until the early 15th century when the architect Brunelleschi designed the dome of the Duomo in Florence (both ‘dome’ and ‘duomo’ come from the Latin word ‘domus’, meaning house). Unlike earlier domes, his is more pointed in profile – like a Gothic arch – and is eight-sided rather than curved. In the 16th century a succession of architects, including Bramante and Michelangelo, gave another great dome, that of St Peter’s Basilica in Rome, its final form.
Wren, designing St Paul’s, was certainly influenced by St Peter’s, though his solution was different – what we see from the outside today is a wood and lead dome, with the stone lantern on top supported by a hidden brick cone; when we look up from inside the building, we see another, decorated dome, that gives us the impression that we looking right to the outer skin but is there to deceive the eye – ‘amusing’ and ‘artificial’, indeed.
After the baroque of Wren came the Palladian style, which again favoured domes – Lord Burlington’s Chiswick house has an octagonal one, as does Thomas Jefferson’s Monticello. With advancing technical prowess in the building trade, architects could now design domes to cover a wide variety of buildings – domes often appear over staircase halls in 18th-century houses, like Castle Howard, for example.
The 19th and early 20th centuries saw the heyday of the dome, especially in public buildings – think of the Old Bailey in London, the Capitol in Washington or the impressive interior of the council chamber of Hull’s Guildhall. In the 19th century, too, churches had domes, either as their main structural feature or as dramatic decoration; at the church at Studley Royal the architect William Burges provided a gothic dome over the chancel, gilded and painted with angels, while in the Catholic church of St Charles Borromeo in Hull a painted dome floods light on to the high altar in a very theatrical manner.
In the 20th century the dome was adapted to new uses, including for cinemas, railway stations and hotels, where sometimes they were made of stained glass to add elegance as one took afternoon tea. New technology came in – domes were made of cast-iron (Britain’s best example, the Coal Exchange in London, was demolished in the face of fierce opposition in the 1960s) or of reinforced concrete. In the 1951 Festival of Britain the Dome of Discovery had a diameter of 365 feet and was made of concrete and aluminium.
Optical telescopes are frequently housed in domes, and the first geodesic dome, a shell of triangles that form a hemisphere, was invented in 1926 as the home to a German telescope. In the 1950s the geodesic dome was popularised by Buckminster Fuller. Such domes are now popular not just among the scientific community but also among gardeners, as they make good greenhouses; the Eden Project in Cornwall uses something similar.
Domes always look impressive – though attempts to use modern techniques to make cheap, dome-shaped homes have proved something of a failure; as the Romans found, a circular building is not always convenient. And modern house-building is geared up for straight lines, not for curves. Nevertheless, where something impressive is called for – in law courts or in hotels, for example –domes are still popular, even if we may not describe them as ‘amusing, awful and artificial’.
