The trouble with most architectural historians is that they specialise too much. It may be all very well knowing almost as much as there is to know about, say, 13th-century French Gothic pinnacles or the use of reinforced concrete in the later works of Le Corbusier (and there may well be people studying just those topics, somewhere!), but do they even fit their researches into a wider context? What do they know of the parallel developments in, say, South America or Japan or India? And if they suddenly feel the urge to find out, where would they go?
The answer today is, probably, to the internet. But even there you need to know what you are looking for before you know where to look. And before the days of the internet, how was it done then? Just how did you know about Indian Saracenic architecture of the 15th century, or, going further back, about the Assyrian palaces of Esarhaddon?
For generations of architects and architectural historians the answer has been ‘Banister Fletcher’. Sir Banister Flight Fletcher trained as an architect under his father (also called Banister). Born in 1866, young Banister joined his father’s practice in 1884 after study in England and in France, taking over the firm on his father’s death in 1899. His architectural style was edging towards the modern – his few buildings include a factory and some schools – but in 1908 he retrained as a barrister, spending the rest of his life in chambers in the Inner Temple dealing with advice and arbitration on property cases.
But neither his architecture nor his legal work are the basis of his fame and why the name ‘Banister Fletcher’ is still remembered. It is for his book – his lifetime’s work – called ‘A History of Architecture on the Comparative Method.’ It first appeared in 1896, co-authored by him and his father, and has since then gone through 20 editions and several revisions, the main one undertaken by Banister Fletcher himself in 1921.
So what does ‘On the Comparative Method’ mean? Banister Fletcher’s preface sets out his purpose: it ‘aims at displaying clearly the characteristic features of the architecture of each country by comparing the buildings of each period and by giving due prominence to the influences – geographical, geological, climatic, religious, social, and historical – which have contributed to the formation of particular styles, and which hitherto have not been emphasised systematically in presenting the story of architectural development.’ It was to be, in short, an architectural ‘Theory of Everything’.
It was an ambitious plan, and one set out with rigorous organisation; each period or style of architecture has its own section of the book (the 1954 edition, brought out in the year after Sir Banister died, runs to 1033 pages). Each section is arranged in the same manner, starting with the ‘influences’ he mentions, then looking at ‘Architectural Character – the general appearance and special features of the buildings of each period’. Then come numerous examples, with copious illustrations, in the later editions photographs as well as, for each edition since 1921, detailed drawings, most by George G Woodward.
Next in each section comes the ‘Comparative Analysis, dealing in turn with ‘Plans, Walls, Openings, Roofs, Columns, Mouldings and Ornaments’. And, just in case the reader needs even more enlightenment than Sir Banister offers, he offers details of appropriate reference books.
The book’s frontispiece is what Fletcher calls ‘The Tree of Architecture’, showing how the art has developed; from its stem branch all the different styles of architecture he deals with; some, like Peruvian and Assyrian, have their own, lower, side branches; European architecture occupies the main ‘trunk’ of the tree, through Greek and Roman and Romanesque, then branching into national styles. At the top are the ‘Revivals’ and the new ’Modern Styles’.
Before Part 1 (‘The Historic Styles’) of the book begins, there is a quick preliminary introduction to ‘Prehistoric Architecture’. Fletcher takes the reader from cave dwellers to beehive huts and to Stonehenge in just three pages. Then we begin the great architectural journey through the succeeding ages; in the first of the sections we learn about the geography and geology of Egypt, its social and religious life and its history, before coming on to Egyptian building styles, which are carefully anatomised through his chosen examples.
Some of this may be familiar – but the next section is on ‘West Asiatic Architecture’ (Babylon, Assyria, Selucid and Jewish), which is not so well known. We’re back on more familiar ground in the long sections on the Greeks and the Romans, before we plunge into ‘Early Christian’ and ‘Byzantine’ architecture. After that it’s the Romanesque (Italian, French, German) and then Gothic, with a long section on ‘English Medieval’, followed by the Gothic of France, Belgium and Holland, Germany, Italy and Spain.
The majestic tide of analysis rolls on through the Renaissance, from the 15th to the 18th centuries (all aspects of the Classical Revival), all around Europe. And then we’re in ‘Modern Architecture’ – that is ‘A.D. 19th cent. to present day’. Fletcher looks at the Gothic versus the Classical revival architects, before analysing ‘modern’ buildings in the USA.
Even then he’s not finished; Part 2 is ‘The Non-Historical Styles’ – Indian, Chinese, Japanese and Saracenic (the last divided into Spanish, Indian, Persian, Turkish, and Indian Saracenic). And, to end, there’s a full-page drawing of ‘Comparative Arches’ – 35 different sorts – as well as a comprehensive glossary.
All this was a mammoth undertaking, and was hailed as a triumph. ‘The Builder’ magazine said it was ‘a complete, trustworthy, and extremely attractive manual. [It] stands in the first rank among text books on architectural history.’ There was a new edition in 1996 (‘Building Design’ called it ‘gloriously and frustratingly invaluable’). And in February this year a new edition was announced, to be published in 2017 – and in 2018 it will all be available on-line, too. So more than 120 years after ‘Banister Fletcher’ first appeared, his magnum opus is still going strong, and a new generation of students might, through its pages – real or virtual – have the chance to escape from a life of narrow specialism.
