Steeple or spire? Are they synonyms? Or is there a difference?
Strictly speaking, there is. A steeple is any church tower, whether with a spire or without. So a steeplechase was originally a race that used church towers as its landmarks as the races chased over hedges and ditches through the countryside. A spire, on the other hand, is an ornament to a steeple – defined in the Oxford English Dictionary as ‘A tapering conical or pyramidal structure on the top of a building, typically a church tower.’ It appears to come from the Greek word speira, meaning a coil – or, alternatively (and more picturesquely) from the Old English spir, meaning a green shoot, a stalk of grass.
And what, if you’ll forgive the question, is the point of a spire? It has been suggested that it has a three-fold role in church architecture: through its resemblance to a spear-point, it is a symbol of the church militant on earth; because it climbs up into heaven it connects man and God (who is, of course ‘up there’); and, more prosaically, it makes it easy to spot just where the church is – though that may be a rather modern way of looking at things. In the Middle Ages, when spires were first built, churches were easy to spot as there were no high-rise buildings to obscure the view.
The spire probably developed from the smaller, pyramid-shaped pinnacles that sometimes adorned the tops of buttresses in Norman cathedrals – there are good examples on Ripon cathedral’s north transept. One of the earliest spires was built at Chartres Cathedral in the 12th century. The idea soon caught on, with churches vying with each other to build the most beautiful, as well as the highest spires.
In England, the earliest spires were of the type now called ‘broach’. This is the sort of spire that rises straight from the tower walls, with a tall, often octagonal, spire surrounded by four sloping supports – easier to recognise than to describe. It’s the sort of spire that can be seen on Ripon’s Holy Trinity Church, where the spire is decorated with another common feature. These are lucarnes – they look rather like tall, thin dormer windows with gabled tops.
The broach was soon followed by what many regard as the true spire – a tall construction, again often octagonal, that sits inside a parapet on top of a tower, so that it’s possible to walk around the base and to set up ladders for maintenance. These spires are largely an English speciality. They occur frequently in areas of good building stone, particularly in the great belt of limestone that stretches diagonally from south west to north east across England. Northamptonshire and its neighbouring counties have many such stone spires.
And the tallest of Britain’s spires, that of Salisbury Cathedral, which rises 404 feet above the surrounding landscape, is another of the genre. The spire itself is 180 feet high, and, for most of its height, only eight inches thick. It was built between 1310 and 1330, though after a storm in 1362 it seems to have been strengthened by a spider’s web of internal timbers. It is decorated externally with bands of carved quatrefoils.
A slightly later way of decorating a spire was to add crockets – small protrusions, carved into clusters of foliage along the edges of each face of an octagonal spire – giving the spire a ‘bobbly’ appearance. The spire of Wakefield Cathedral is a good example in Yorkshire.
Not all spires were of stone, of course. The spires of old St Paul’s Cathedral in London (the building severely damaged by the Great Fire of 1666) and of Lincoln Cathedral were both higher than Salisbury’s, but did not last so long. St Paul’s spire was reckoned to be about 460 feet high (estimates vary – it may have reached 489 feet, but was destroyed in a fire in 1561. Lincoln’s spire, on its central tower, was even taller; at 524 feet it was for centuries the world’s tallest building; it collapsed in 1549.
Both these spires were of timber covered with lead – as were the three spires of Ripon Minster. The central spire at Ripon was damaged by lightning in 1593 and fell in 1660. To prevent further disaster the spires in the western towers were removed four years later – probably to the great detriment of the look of the building. Such lead and timber spires were cheaper and easier to build than their stone counterparts – but things could go wrong, most famously at Chesterfield in Derbyshire, where the timbers warped, producing the famous ‘crooked spire’. In fact there are many such spires; another seven in England, 25 in Germany and no fewer than 68 in France.
There were several variations on how spires were used; in Hertfordshire, for example, there was a craze for very thin spires rising from the centre of a tower – these are known as the ‘Hertfordshire spikes’. Or you could decorate the base of your spire with an octagonal arcade of open arches, as at Patrington in East Yorkshire – a trick copied by Hull-born architect Bodley in the 19th century at his church in Clumber Park, Nottinghamshire.
The English love of the spire induced architects building in the classical style to add spires to their churches. In one of Wren’s designs for the new St Paul’s he added a six-storey spire on top of the dome – a very odd conception. But he did design some fine spires on his London churches, including those of St Mary-le-Bow and St Vedast, Foster Lane.
But it was James Gibbs at St Martin-in-the Fields who, by placing his spire over the columned front of his church, which would otherwise look like a Roman temple, transformed it into an Anglican parish church. It is a style that was transported to the United States, where it became the set pattern of the churches of the 18th and 19th centuries – a far cry from the early spires on the Norman cathedrals of Europe.
