In last week’s column we looked at how architects and others had treated decayed buildings, and had even recreated long-lost buildings, and asked whether restoration and reconstruction were good things. Were they, perhaps, something of a deception?
Architects, though, have always used deceptive features in their buildings. Landscape designers, too, have not been averse to some sleight of hand in their work. Sometimes this deception was used to bring down the cost of building yet maintain an appearance of grandeur; sometimes it was to achieve effects that were impossible in any other way.
Landscapers first. With the great garden at Studley Royal on our doorstep, Riponians have the great fortune to be able to study one aspect of this deception simply by taking a walk through the landscape laid out by John Aislabie in the years early years of the 18th century. It all seems quite simple – a straight canal, regular pools, temples. But look more closely. If you view, for example, the Temple of Piety from across the canal, it seems to be set on a considerable hill. Yet when you walk near it you will find that the hill hardly exists.
The effect of height is the result of careful shaping of the grassy banks between the temple and the round pool. The angles of these banks – known as glacis slopes – are calculated to give an illusory elevation. The same illusion is seen on the opposite side of the canal near the Drum Falls. And, of course, Studley is not the only place where the trick is used; the same sort of glacis slopes are used, for example, in the garden at Claremont, near Esher in Surrey, where a mock castle by Vanbrugh appears to be on the top of a steep hill – though in reality it’s just a shallow slope.
When the fashion for gardens like Studley waned a little later in the 18th-century, landowners and their landscapers went a new way, perhaps inspired by the poet Alexander Pope’s lines about the value of not making everything visible at once: ‘Let not each beauty everywhere be spied, / Where half the skill is decently to hide. / He gains all points, who pleasingly confounds, / Surprises, varies, and conceals the bounds.’ So landscapers became adept at concealing views with carefully-placed clumps of trees and the judicious use of the hahah; at every turn the eye of the viewer was presented with something new – Capability Brown was a proponent of the style.
They could also add follies – as Vanbrugh did with his castle at Claremont and his ‘ruined’ wall at Castle Howard – to suggest ancient lineage and long-established ownership of an estate, especially if, unlike the Aislabies at Studley, the Duncombes at Rievaulx or the Lascelles at Harewood, you didn’t happen to have a ruined abbey or castle on your estate. The follies at Hackfall are good examples of this trend; both Mowbray Castle and Mowbray Point (‘The Ruin’) look genuinely ancient, despite being built as the landscape was developed in the 1740s and 50s.
It was this same desire to make buildings look old that inspired some architects and owners of buildings to nail on thin, black, pseudo-Tudor beams in the 1920s and 30s (there are examples in Ripon’s Market Square) and for house-builders in the 70s and 80s (and some even today) to add similar beams or fluted sub-classical columns on the front of very ordinary houses.
This is not, of course a new phenomenon. The regular use of stucco in the 18th and early 19th centuries was motivated in large part by a desire to make a brick building look like stone. Stucco (a mixture of sand, lime and cement, mixed to a thick paste with water) provided a protective coating to a wall, and could be moulded to resemble blocks of stone – look at the lower part of the front of Ripon Town Hall for a good example. It could also be used for columns, especially if they were attached to the building rather than freestanding – again, the Town Hall is a case in point.
Inside buildings, too, architects could deceive. We have all come across ‘marble’ columns that are of cleverly-painted wood; they were the cheapest way to ‘get the look, as modern interior décor magazines say. If you had more to spend, but not enough to afford proper columns of solid marble, you went for scagliola. The word is Italian for ‘chips’; in its simplest form chips of marble were applied to a surface covered with plaster, then highly polished to resemble a solid block. It was a technique used by the ancient Romans and rediscovered in the Renaissance.
Scagliola columns and pilasters (part columns attached to a wall) are very common, even in the most sumptuous houses; the Marble Saloon at Wentworth Woodhouse in South Yorkshire has a marble floor but the columns, which look like expensive Sienese marble, are top-quality scagliola.
Architectural deception was never confined to secular buildings; we can see it even in churches. The west front at Ripon Cathedral was originally intended to impress visitors by its size, though once inside they would realise that the building was nowhere near as wide as it looked, and that the towers stuck out well beyond the rest of the structure.
Only in the 15th century did it get the aisles that give it its present width. And in the late 17th century, when Celia Fiennes visited Ripon, she noted in the Minster ‘a very fine painting over the alter [sic] it looks so natural, just like real crimson satten with gold fringe like hangings.’ Such trompe l’oeil painting is another trick that the Romans used, one developed in the Renaissance and still practised today.
One final deception: mirrors. Once mirrors could be made a decent size, they were used to create illusion – the Versailles Galerie des Glaces, begun in 1678, is the prime example. And this neatly takes us back to gardens, too, where even the smallest plot can be made to look larger with the judicious placing of a mirror. It’s just another way in which the eye can, often happily, be deceived.
